Wednesday, August 28, 2013

The Ruthwell Cross

The poem “Dream of the Rood” survives in two forms: a complete copy appears in the tenth-century manuscript known as the Vercelli Book, and an incomplete copy, including only the lines spoken by the cross, appears on one face of the Ruthwell Cross. This blog entry aims to give more information about both the artistic traditions from which the Ruthwell Cross emerged and the particular contents and function of that cross.

According to the New Cambridge Medieval History, “stone sculpture was a major form of artistic expression throughout western Europe between the seven and tenth centuries” (Nees 827).  The Ruthwell Cross, located in southwestern Scotland and standing 18 feet tall, reflects a number of different cultural traditions that affected medieval Northumbria, including artistic trends of the Pictish tribes, Ireland, and the Mediterranean. The Picts had a long tradition of carving imagery into stone. The earliest surviving carvings show symbols from the pre-Christian period, and later sculptures have images of crosses. Pictish carvings generally appeared on two-sided slabs with the shape of a cross inscribed upon it (Nees 829). While the Ruthwell Cross continues this Pictish tradition of carving imagery into stone, its overall shape is more similar to an Irish practice. Particularly in the ninth and tenth centuries, large stone crosses were prevalent in Ireland, where crosses could range in height from 3 to 10 meters. These crosses normally stood near monasteries, perhaps marking the borders of the monastery’s land, and were carved with Christian iconography (Nees 828). Because of the influence of the Roman church in Northumbria, it is not surprising that the Ruthwell Cross boasts elements of Mediterranean origin as well. Specifically, the vine borders that appear around some of the images on the cross and the cross’ iconographic imagery call to mind Roman and Byzantine art (Nees 829).
The Ruthwell Cross is decorated primarily with images of Christ. The two largest images, on opposite sides of the cross, may represent the dual nature of Christ (his divinity and his humanity). One shows Christ standing on the heads of two beasts, while the other shows a woman at Christ’s feet. Both pictures are accompanied by Latin inscriptions. With regard to the first image, the text asserts that the beasts recognized Jesus as the “Savior of the World” and the “Judge of Righteousness” (Hilmo 39). The Latin text next to the latter image narrates part of Luke 7.37-38 where a woman washes Jesus feet with her tears and hair (Hilmo 39, 44). The text of “Dream of the Rood” appears not as a main feature of one of the cross’ panels but as a border for images of vines, birds, and clusters of grapes. These symbols may evoke Jesus’ statement in the gospel of John that “I am the true vine” (Jn. 15.1). The excerpt of the poem found on the cross (lines 39-63) begins with the introduction of Christ as a hero and ends with his death.
In Medieval Images, Icons, and Illustrated English Literary Texts, Maidie Hilmo argues that texts and images are “intimately and symbiotically connected” on the cross (33). With this claim, she responds to earlier arguments from scholars who thought the poem did not correspond well with the cross’ images, both because of the subject matter of the image it directly surrounds and because Latin texts, not Old English ones, explained the other images. Hilmo connects the “Dream of the Rood” with the dual portrayals of Christ as God and man.  The victory that Christ and the cross achieve parallels the militaristic imagery of Christ standing on the heads of the beasts. Both the poem and the large image portray Christ as a victor. The language of the Old English vernacular (written in Germanic runes) and the first-person speech recorded in the poem suggest the psychological, and thereby the human, experience of the Passion (Hilmo 56). With this dynamic connection between text and image, Hilmo proposes that the Ruthwell Cross invited viewers to not just look at but experience the sculpture: “to look, to read, to recall, to listen, to feel, and to imagine” (56). The combination makes the message of divine incarnation more powerful and present.
While the Ruthwell Cross seems to have been designed to stimulate both the thoughts and feelings of its viewers, some Christians react negatively to pictorial representations of biblical stories, fearing that an image of God will become venerated as God. Because “Dream of the Rood” appeared alongside images on the cross, the only surviving runic version of the poem was very nearly lost. In 1642, following the passage of a Scottish law against “idolatrous monuments,” the Ruthwell Cross was smashed to pieces (Hilmo 55). In addition to debating the significance of the cross’ images, scholars also debate what the precise images on the cross were, since the present cross is a nineteenth-century reconstruction, made up of the broken pieces.


Works Cited
Hilmo, Maidie. Medieval Images, Icons, and Illustrated English Literary Texts: From the Ruthwell Cross to the Ellesmere Chaucer. Burlington, VT: Ashgate, 2004.
Nees, Lawrence. "Art and Architecture." The New Cambridge Medieval History. Ed. Rosamond McKitterick. Vol. 2. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995.

12 comments:

  1. This is a practice comment. I will need to know that students' names show up on comments, so I can keep up with who is posting when!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Upon learning that "Dream of the Rood" was inscribed on a cross, I was immediately struck by the idea of the poem coming to life on an 18 foot tall work of art. In my opinion, the poem is extremely "big" to begin with, in the sense that the story is literally epic. Because the poem is about the Passion and the role of the cross in the Passion, carving the poem into an actual cross just seems to make sense. As I was reading through the blog post, though, it really stuck out to me that there are some who fear "that an image of God will become venerated as God." This is something that I've never really considered. Again, I view the fact that the poem is carved into a cross with images of the Savior as something beautiful. Perhaps it is my Episcopal background that is strongly rooted in Catholicism that makes me think this way. I've never viewed icons as actually being God. Sitting in church every Sunday, I see icons everywhere. Never once has it crossed my mind to worship the icons and not God. It is extremely intriguing to think that there are individuals in the world who would think otherwise. I do not believe that "Dream of the Rood" was carved onto a cross with the intention of it being worshipped. I do believe, though, that the intention was to visually depict something already extremely thought-provoking in an attempt to allow readers, or viewers, to have a more intimate experience with the poem.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The two images show Christ standing on the heads of two beasts and a woman washing Christ's feet. These align with the combination of low and high Christology found in "Dream of the Rood", which we discussed in class. The picture with the woman also shows Christ being served by someone. In the longer text of Dream of the Rood, we see Christ being served by the cross itself.

    In the passage from Luke, the woman is considered sinful, but is forgiven after her service. She is redeemed. We see something of a parallel in "Dream of the Rood". Although the cross has been used as a device of torture and execution by the Romans, in the text it becomes an ally to Christ: "Strong enemies seized me there, / made me their spectacle, made me bear their criminals ... Then I saw the lord of mankind hasten eagerly when he wanted to ascend onto me. / There I dared not bow down or break" (Dream of the Rood, 30-34). Just as the sinful woman served Christ, so the cross--which had been long used for evil purposes--served him as well. In the text and the picture we see the moment of service to Christ. I would argue that Hilmo is correct, in that the text of "Dream of the Rood" and the pictures on the Ruthwell Cross are connected, and that the interplay between the two should be examined.

    ReplyDelete
  5. The fact that "Dream of the Rood" is inscribed on something so magnificent and religiously based is fascinating to me. The description of the artwork on the Ruthwell Cross that you described is very intriguing to me. Having Christ depicted in two very different forms, and ironically on two different sides of the cross, shows how creative the minds of people were back then. I feel like "Dream of the Rood" was written on the cross, because of its direct relativity to the two images for seen on the cross. This entire blog was interesting to me, and opened my eyes up to a piece of artwork that I didn't know existed.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Like Christ's juxtaposing images on the Ruthwell cross, "The Dream of the Rood" also depicts a cross seen in two complementary, although different, lights. In one of the two descriptions, the cross in this poem is enveloped in "garments" (14), "gold" (15), and "gems"(15), similar to how Christ is depicted as "standing on the heads of two beasts" (Raschko). Details for both the cross and Christ reveal images of glory and underscore the idea that both icons possess importance. However, importance is not synonymous with worship. Christ Himself ought to be worshipped, but the images of Himself and other elements relating to Him should not be, which is why I do not believe that the sculptors who molded the cross meant it to be purposed for an object of idolatry. To do so would be to contain His complex nature onto a mortal instrument. Even the cross, onto which He was nailed to, could not contain Him, much less a stone carving.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I find the dual nature of Christ a very interesting topic to examine. With the two largest images displaying Christ's divinity and humanity, it sparks the question of whether Christ is seen as a heavenly hero (line 39) or as a human warrior (line 60). In class, we discussed high and low Christology -- high Christology involving the power of God in the glory of crucifixion as opposed to low Christology involving the humanity of Jesus as a teacher who bleeds and suffers like humans do.

    Growing up in the 'Bible Belt' of the South, I have always been taught to think of God as a Holy and heavenly being. The focus did not tend to remain on the suffering of Jesus in his human form. The cross was seen as a tool for torturing and crucifying Jesus rather than a servant/support system for Him. The "Dream of the Rood" allows its readers to view Christ in both aspects of his dual nature, and it also allows its readers to see the dual nature of the cross.

    ReplyDelete
  8. It is interesting to see the different ways religion is viewed as centuries chronologically progress. For example, in the Ruthwell Cross poem, the author is totally God fearing. God is portrayed as the highest hero and there is no inclination that the author questions the nature of God or his works. The author, just like the cross, offers unwavering loyalty to Jesus. This can be contrasted with the works of the later centuries such as Paradise Lost which tries to justify God's doings to the people who need religious justification. We can also contrast it with an Essay on Man which seems to put the majority of emphasis on mankind instead of God. As humans become more and more enlightened in later centuries, we start to question our understanding of God. This questioning leads us to answers which lead to more unanswered questions. As science continues to advance in centuries to come, our perception of God will continue to change.

    ReplyDelete
  9. The representation of Christ as a brave hero intrigues me a lot in this poem. From my experience, I haven't encountered a lot of literary pieces that illustrate Christ as a charismatic king and a warrior as done in "The Dream of the Rood." Typically, the image of Christ is a peaceful, passive redeemer who seems to be far from being an active participant in physical, heroic actions. Perhaps this is to emphasize the lord and thane relationship that we had talked about in class. In order to build the hierarchy between the rood and Christ, perhaps it was the author's intent to portray Christ as a typical leader figure. The imagery of the battle seems to bolster the great struggle that they both go through and the accompanying loyalty. Despite the unconventional portrayal of Christ and his ways of salvation, this poem evidently elevates Christ as a savior and the Lord of his followers.

    ReplyDelete
  10. The use of the heroic Christ is an interesting appeal to the conversion of the invading pagans; the fact that the English would trouble themselves to attempt to convert the Vikings is interesting in and of itself. Co-suffering is the stressed relationship between the cross and the dying lord/young hero. This would have an appeal to the militaristic structure with which the Anglo-Saxons were most familiar. By likening the world to a place on endemic conflict, the author is encouraging the following of the Christ as a righteous ruler and sovereign war commander.

    ReplyDelete