To
understand the significance of the gender-bending present in the Elizabethan
Era, it is important to first know how it differed from the Tudor Era.
“Along
with birth, age, and wealth,” Capp states, “gender was one of the key criteria
that defined the social position and role of every individual in Tudor society”
(286). The inferiority of women was a notion that held religious backing, with
preachers and magistrates citing Eve’s role in The Fall as evidence that women
were easily tempted and necessitated the presence of a husband to instill “obedience”
(286). The medical field, unfortunately, did nothing to counteract these sexist
notions. In fact, Tudor science held the Galen belief that the typical balance
of the four humors in women “rendered them more emotional and volatile than
men” (286). “Both men and women [additionally] defined female ‘honesty’ and reputation
almost wholly in terms of sexual behavior, whereas a man’s good name rested on
a much wider range of attributes, and sexual lapses were often seen as unimportant”
(287).
However,
with the rise of Elizabethan England, this established philosophy of gender
came into question. “The potential fluidity of gender” was first illustrated in
the theater, where young boys often dressed as female characters (Capp 287). However, this concept of cross-dressing
extended beyond the borders of the playhouse and eventually into everyday life.
Women were experimenting with gender identity, a fashion at that time, which
also resulted in a significant number of women prosecuted by the courts for
dressing as men (287). “Genuine unease” concerning gender identity reverberated
throughout Elizabethan England, and became known as “a crisis in gender
relations” (287). But it wasn’t the act of dressing as the opposing gender that
was causing concern; rather, the idea that women could have equal power as
their male counterparts, or even surpass them in matters of intelligence or
authority in the household, was incredibly threatening (287).
This
debate then made its way into the pages of books and theater stages, which
approached the topic with comedy. While these artworks do bring the debate into
the forefront, they still “reinforce traditional norms” that were being
challenged at the time (Capp 287). “Insubordination,” Capp continues, “was frequently
linked with sexual fears, for it was widely assumed that a domineering wife
would be sexually unfaithful.” And the consequences for women, even if
convicted under mere suspicions, were undoubtedly heinous: “[I]f found guilty,
[she] faced a humiliating public penance in which she would have to beg
forgiveness, dressed in a white sheet, before the entire congregation... Other
women who behaved inappropriately… might be… punished by being ducked or placed
in stocks (287).
Shakespeare
was one of those artists who addressed the fluidity of gender with his sonnets.
Rather than offering a comedic commentary to the gender debate, it is argued
that he is actually parodying the sonnet form itself, thus making more of a statement
about gender instead of mocking it.
In
“Making the Woman of Him: Shakespeare’s Man Right Fair as Sonnet Lady,” author
M.L. Stapleton asserts that the Bard was mocking the sonnet form, rather than
revealing a closeted bisexuality. Because of the lavish language and overt-feminine
aspects of the male admired, this indicates parody on Shakespeare’s part.
The
Man Right Fair is the moniker of the man the speaker (aptly named “Will”)
addresses in his sonnets. The gender of Will’s subject alone “is a parody of
the sonnet lady,” mocking the ethereal women of the sonnets before
Shakespeare’s time (Stapleton 273). In the sonnet tradition, the standard form
involves a male speaker with a female object. In Shakespeare’s time, the
Petrarchism and anti-Petrarchism had gone out of fashion and satirical sonnets
were now becoming the established norm (276).
Thus, “Shakespeare’s decision to define the subjectivity of a masculine
addressee with ‘feminizing language,’” Stapleton states, “represents a truly
original, subversive, and amusing attack on sonnet traditions,” and does not
make Stapleton’s argument of parody seem out of the ordinary for other authors
were writing satirical sonnets as well (276). Stapleton also claims that because
this is not the first instance of parody in Shakespeare’s career, it is also
not outlandish to claim that a man famous for his puns and forms of high-brow humor
would continue this form in his poetic works (276).
“As
a means of parodying the genre,” Stapleton writes, “Shakespeare needed to
establish the femininity of the Man Right Fair in the manner of his
contemporaries toward their feminine subjects” (276). One of the ways in which
Shakespeare accomplishes this is through the overtly feminine characterization
of the Man Right Fair. Shakespeare does
this through his particular word choice, using terms such
as “sweet,” “fair,” “lovely,” and “beautiful,” all of which are terms
traditionally used to designate a female love. However, the Bard takes this one
step further with terminology like “thou,” “thine,” and “thee,” which are terms
men would only use in descriptions of women and never to delineate another man
(277). This “hyperfemininity” Stapleton refers to was important for the poet to
clarify his work as an art of humor as opposed to one of seriousness (278). Shakespeare
needed to make his satire readily apparent because “there…was no recognizable
precedent for a masculine addressee to be utilized as a tool for the satire of
sonnet conventions…” (278-279).
Shakespeare’s
satire also addresses “the voicelessness of the female subject in Renaissance
poetry perpetuated by the oppressive male creator” (Stapleton 282). In his sonnets, Shakespeare attributes this
to the constant rambling of these afflicted men. Essentially, women are
voiceless or passive in traditional sonnets simply because the admiring male
will not give his ramblings a rest (283). Perhaps she would be more vocal if
she was given a chance to speak.
As
a result, Shakespeare’s sonnets provide interesting commentary in an era where
gender appeared to not be as concrete as once thought. While he may have been
mocking the sonnet form, his notions on gender seem to be challenging the
established norm.
Works Cited
Capp,
Barnard S. “Gender.” Tudor England: An Encyclopedia. Ed. Arthur F.
Kinney and David W. Swain. New York: Garland, 2001. 286-88. Print.
Stapleton,
M. L. “Making the Woman of Him: Shakespeare's Man Right Fair as Sonnet Lady.” Texas
Studies in Literature and Language 46.3 (2004): 271-95. Academic Search
Complete. Web. 27 Oct. 2013.
<http://web.ebscohost.com.proxy-s.mercer.edu/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?sid=e4c82a94-915a-42a2-b000-7a801f63acff%40sessionmgr110&vid=4&hid=121>.