Thursday, August 29, 2013

The Battle of Maldon-Anshu



The Viking Era 
        During the 9th and 10th centuries of the Middle Ages, the Vikings were an infamous peoples known throughout Europe for there ruthlessness and militaristic tactics. The Vikings hailed from the Scandinavian lands of Northern Europe; from the modern day countries of Norway, Sweden, and Denmark. In this short introduction, I will detail a portion of history known for violence, greed and bloodshed; a period where a race of beings pillaged lands ranging from modern day Russia to Ireland; a race described by one victim as “a terror” to his “most lovely land” (Sawyer 79).   

 http://www.worldatlas.com/webimage/countrys/europelarge.jpg


               In relation to our focus areas of Western Europe, the Vikings began raids on the coasts of Frankia and Britain circa 800 Common Era. We can infer such information from past letters sent between men of power both among the Vikings and their victims. In the early 800’s, Viking raids were carried out on a smaller scale. Often, no more than a few ships would be used to raid the northern coasts and islands. Their first victims were England and the Frankish Empire, which today covers the lands of Germany and France. Initially, they would cross the North or Baltic Sea and attack coastal villages, pillaging the surrounding land and then heading back home with treasure and occasionally slaves. 
            However, within the first few years, a more effective strategy came to dominate the Vikings plan of attack. They would build settlements in areas which had been conquered. As early as 811 and 822, “mention is made of the obligation to destroy forts built by pagans” (Sawyer 78).  
Regarding the target of Viking attacks; inevitably, the best places to acquire fine goods like silver and gold ornaments were the local churches. Alcuin, a future abbot in Tours, described such attacks, saying “shrines were desecrated and the bodies of saints trampled like dung in the streets, ornaments were plundered, the blood of priests was shed and some of the members of the community were captured, at least one of whom was ransomed” (Sawyer 79). Through the decades, monarchs defended their lands from invasion with differing levels of success. In the middle to late 800’s, Vikings would successfully penetrate deep into the lands of Frankia and England, building settlements along inland rivers. Particularly in Frankia, Vikings would pressure to the very centers of King Charles’ kingdom. The weakness of the Frankish resulted in bribes of silver often being given to the Vikings in return for peace. Surprisingly, Vikings would honor such agreements with due diligence, though often such bribes were on the whole ineffective because one bribe would not cover every band of marauders, all of whom hailed from different Scandinavian countries and localities.
          From the next century to 991, Viking activity gradually shifted away from a plundered Frankia towards English lands. During this time, Aethelred the Unready was the king of the country, though only in name, for the nation was relatively weakened by fractious internal struggles. Prior to the Battle of Maldon, raids were carried out on a smaller scales and, up to that point, the English were partially successful in repulsing Viking invaders.
          However, Maldon signified a turning point in relations between the two nations. One author states that “the battle itself was a decisive one, marking, as it does, the first overthrow of the English after a long sequence of victories. It marks, indeed, the opening of a new epoch in Viking history.” (Kendrick 258). The Battle was a large scale Viking assault, after which Aethelred was forced to pay tribute to appease a growing force of Vikings, hailing from all Scandinavian countries, though King Svein of Denmark was the largest acquirer.  On four other major occasions, King Svein attacked England, only to be bribed each time, with “the sum increasing steadily from £10,000 in 991 to £72,000 in 1016” (Neidorf 454).
         Finally, such bribes became a fruitless deterrence and Svein crowned himself King of England in 1014, though the payments continued to flow. Sveins reign only lasted a short while, “for he died suddenly at the beginning 1014” (Kendrick 267). Afterwards, the Vikings fall in and out of power for another couple decades, only to eventually lose ground completely. This henceforth ended the English reign of the Vikings. 
Scholarly Article
       Our chosen article is titled “Aethelred and the Politics of the Battle of Maldon” (Neidorf 451).  Within its dense contents, the author argues for a reinterpretation of the seemingly obvious stance of the authro. According to scholarly consensus, the writer, through so many subtle hints, states that appeasement policies for the Vikings is undesirable and that true men would fight for hearth and home, giving up life and limb for king and country. Neidorf, in slight opposition, seems to argue that such inferences are too hasty and one should pronounce, with greater emphasis, the surrounding political context, which sharply affects the readers taking of the poets’ “puzzlingly benign representation of the Vikings” (Neidorf 452).
       Neidorf argues that the author is writing his rendition of the battle in what is likely political circumstance which prevents the writer from exposing an honest, impartial viewpoint. He states that the author lived in a political environment bleached with policies on Viking appeasement and forgiveness of past transgressions. He cites historical records of “a policy of converting Viking raiders into English allies” (Neidorf 456). There are official mandates which create “mandates for forgiving and forgetting the Vikings” (Neidrof 455).
      Neidorf also speaks of poems written near the time of our authors writing, which often related “such abundance and variety of negative terms” which are directed at the Vikings (Neidorf 458). In comparison, the Maldon author uses “words of a neutral valence” in regards to the Vikings (Neidorf 462).
       In the conclusion, Neidorf discusses the exact date of the writing. His argument hinges upon nailing the date of the writing because it could have been written as late as 1021, after the events of Aethelred's appeasement policy (Neidorf 469). As a result, Neidorf pins the date to before 1006, leading to a final solidification and legitimacy of the prior twenty pages of supporting material.


Works Cited
Kendrick, T.D. A History of the Vikings. 1st Ed. New York: Frank Cass and Company, 1930. Print. 
Sawyer, P.H. Kings and Vikings. New York: Metheun, 1982. Print. 
Neidorf, Leonard. "Aethelred and the Politics of the Battle of Maldon." Project Muse. 111.4 (2012): 451-473. Print.



           


18 comments:

  1. I really enjoyed reading your post; it was very insightful. It was engaging and taught me a great deal about Vikings; things that were very relatable to The Battle of Maldon poem that we read in class. The poem was all about the brutality of the viking's invasion and how they were known to killing people in the most violent of ways.

    ReplyDelete
  2. It was interesting that the author of the article argues that the poem was written in a time of appeasement between the Vikings and the English. Throughout the poem there seems to be no distinguishing characteristics that make the Vikings villains in contrast to the heroic English. Instead the poem is more focused on the heroic deeds of the English and seems to use the Vikings to develop of the plot of the poem. "... the poem's moral absolutes are not arranged as an English "us" against a Viking "them," but as a stark personal choice between courage and cowardice, truth and treachery, which is only made cleared by the impossibility of victory." (The Battle of Maldon). If this poem was written at a time where conflict between the English and the Vikings was occurring a clearer distinction of each group would have been made. One group would have been portrayed as good and the other evil.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The Battle of Maldon shows the same historical evidence that the vikings developed the strategy of threatening war in payment of silver by way of the messenger who asks to “...call it truce in exchange for gold.” (The Battle of Maldon). I feel like you gave a thorough history of the vikings pilgrimage and their goals for their intrusions. The trait of being heroic was admirable trait sought after by many men of the period. As seen in the Battle of Maldon, heroic actions of war were used as a way of continuing a name and being remembered. Therefore it was common for the stories to be written. The men in this poem fought in the name of their lord. The fact that the earl made the decision to fight and not pay tribute to the vikings can be seen as a change in course to the common method of paying off the vikings which you pointed out was becoming less and less effective. I feel like choice of words and name calling shows little evidence of the common feeling of the vikings. I think the author chose to put less emphasis on the feelings towards the vikings and more emphasis on the actions taken for the loyalty of their lord which is seen in a majority of the poem.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The attention to detail in your post really enriches it's quality. So often vikings are thought of as ruthless killing machines (which they pretty much are but that's beside the point) and your article pulls from The Battle of Maldon to describe the vikings as a purpose-driven people. Also describing Maldon as a "turning point" in viking history gives an insightful opinion on viking strategy and victory.

    ReplyDelete
  5. It is interesting to see how the political structure of a society can greatly influence literature. I agree with Neidorf that due to the Viking appeasement policies, The Battle of Maldon was quite forgiving of Viking's brutality (Viking's invasion) based on the choice of words that were used to describe the Viking. Instead of demeaning the Viking's action and character, loyalty and courage was praised throughout the poem.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Having the historical information supplementing what we have read so far can help the reading experience; in this case, I do believe that it did. Additionally, your posting the map was a nice addition to your words, a smart aid to help readers envision what you are saying. While I was reading your blog, my mind interspersed scenes from the History television series Vikings, replaying the vicious, brutal scenes between the Englishmen and the Norsemen.
    Further, the quotations that you decided to use were beneficial especially in their wording, as some of the detail ("shrines were desecrated and the bodies of saints trampled like dung in the streets") created a fantastic visual of the events that happened at Maldon and other locations. Overall, this was a nice read.

    ReplyDelete
  7. It seems to me that both fighting the Vikings and trying to appease them through payments were both fruitless. Even though they were paid and the sums increased over a period of time, the Vikings still ultimately settled in England and Svein crowned himself the king of England in 1014 as you stated in your 6th paragraph. Obviously, the money wasn't enough. However, in the battle of Maldon, they couldn't defeat the Viking forces. Paying tribute wasn't even an option for them. Byrhtnoth says that the only tribute they will get will be poisoned points and ancient swords(line 46-47). They suffered a defeat at the hands of the Vikings that day, even with their bold words. There doesn't seem to be a way that the British can guarantee that they will not be attacked.

    ReplyDelete
  8. You did a great job at giving a significant amount of historical background to provide a better understanding of the events taking place in the text. The vikings were obviously a very violent people and not easy to negotiate with. However, it is interesting that throughout the poem, the brutality of the vikings is not focused on. I can see where instead of a poem about the terrible bloodshed of the war, the poem is a medium for emphasizing the English's appeasement with the Vikings.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I am a little confused by some of the ending statements. Specifically, the third-to-last paragraph. While it makes historical sense that the English would have eventually accepted the Vikings and started forgiving them, I do not see this reflected in the poem. The battle is not explicitly portraying the Vikings in a negative light, especially when compared to other contemporary works. But the Vikings still invade, they still kill good men, and they still invade England. If there has been an official mandate to forgive and forget the Vikings, then this work does not seem to be towing the line. Perhaps it is more forgiving than other works, but writing a poem about the crucial battle in the Viking invasion is far from forgetting. I would be very curious to see exactly how Neidorf argues this point. It is very likely that additional source material would be needed to argue the point.

    ReplyDelete
  10. It was interesting to focus on the historical reasoning as to why the Vikings initially invaded England after plundering Frankia of all its riches. Before I read this, I believed that the Vikings had no strategy when pillaging villages; however, now I understand that they tactfully posed a threat on a nation to form a peace treaty, benefitting themselves by gaining gold and riches. Although our reading of "The Battle of Maldon" intimated this idea, it did not further explicate that the Vikings traveled from country to country using the same mercenary tactics.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I found the apparent use of "political correctness" to be an interesting and rather funny concept concerning Vikings. The idea that the author of the 'Battle of Maldon' would intentionally give a broad, un-biased view on the situation during the early Medieval era based on the political situation is both intriguing and discomforting; normally we associate being politically correct with our time period, but the fact that this practice was carried out centuries ago gives a lot of food for thought. While understandable that one would not wish to upset the Vikings and incur a local raid (specifically on the author of such writing), it does speak a lot about both the political world that these people lived in and the consequences of such actions made. While during our day and age something biased would probably be met with stern looks or strong words, Vikings would have a much more personal and sharp way of getting payback. The policies of appeasement also tie into this politically correct notion: by remaining as passive as possible and not giving them any reason to invade, Europeans reassured themselves that all was well, perhaps ignorant of the fact that not every Viking followed the rules. These ideas of appeasing and staying on the Viking's good side shows just how dangerous this group of people were, that parties of these warriors could have kings paying them off not to invade their lands. A very helpful look and insight into the world of people who lived long ago, Anshu!

    ReplyDelete
  12. What I find interesting about this entry is how much land they went through in their conquests. And as for accepting the bribes and honoring agreements, I'm curious about the level of honor that the vikings may have had. Yes they were brutish warriors, but how highly did they regard honor? And what did they consider as honorable? It would be interesting to look at the similarities and differences between warrior's honor mentality of the Vikings and the English.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I enjoyed reading this. I find it interesting that you chose to incorporate a contrasting view of the Vikings that we do not get in the text. Many accounts of Vikings, including the text, seem to paint them as brutes. Though this is my own view of the matter, I feel as though they were only a strong military power. In a sense, the Vikings were the Spartans of their age. Another interesting idea is how long they fought and conquered. This also supports the idea of them being a strong military power. The only bad thing about being a strong military power is the fact that many tend to forget the humanity aspect of the power; hence, where the idea of the Vikings being brutes come from.

    ReplyDelete
  14. In reference to the scholarly article mentioned in this post when you say that "Neidorf argues that the author is writing his rendition of the battle in what is likely political circumstance which prevents the writer from exposing an honest, impartial viewpoint.", I'd like to point out that is nearly impossible to remain completely impartial on something that so negatively affected the people of the time. When something as devastating as the Viking reign has occurred, there is naturally going to be some hatred towards the controlling power, whether that power be a negative or positive force. It is human nature to not want to be told what to do, and a healthy amount of patriotism is to be expected.

    ReplyDelete
  15. In response to Glen's comment about the Vikings being the "Spartans of their age"..... I would argue otherwise, I think that the Vikings were the Persians of their age. The Persians like the Vikings were both very prideful armies. This trait propelled them to push the limits on how far they could go, how many people they could conquer, and how many riches they could plunder. Although maybe effective in the short run, often times this pride or "ofermod" can and has lead to demise in the long run.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Typically, when one reads about Viking history we read that they were brutes and savages while this blogpost echoes this in some ways it also shows that the Vikings were a lot more civilized and cognitive than they are traditionally given credit for. Never before this blogpost have I heard of Vikings making bribes and (loose) bargains with other people. Usually, when one hears tales of Vikings one hears that they used brute strength and force in order to obtain the things that they wanted and needed.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I think that the Vikings were a worthwhile mechanic used in the passage to sharply contrast the heroic attributes of the English. While the English churl is honorable for leading his people in conflict toward an unlikely victory, he is also discredited for allotting the invading Vikings too much land. This proves to be a fatal mistake; it is also a violation of the code of honor and chivalry that would be tantamount to any leader's character. Since pride is considered one of the deadly sins, the English defeat would be seen as swift and severe retribution for the fault of the churl.

    The fact that the Vikings took bribes to avoid conflict further proves the theme of divine intervention. Previously, their greed could be seen as impediments to military success. The inciting event of the English falling to the whiles of overconfidence is highlighted by an especially hard fall from grace.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I'd say that the victory of the Vikings up until King Svein proclaimed himself the ruler of England and dies was all the product of excellent planning of military strategies. Even the monetary installments and the allowed settlements prompted the Vikings to acquire even more power and justice.I understand why people are more inclined to think negatively of the Vikings as Anshu begins this post, however how else would you label warriors of war. War is not pretty nor is suppose to be described as such. I feel if the roles were reversed England would get the exact same negative adjectives attached to their name.

    ReplyDelete