Friday, September 27, 2013

There is another Morte Darthur?

Min Hyun Oh
Malory, Morte Darthur: Caxton’s Morte Darthur


            Sir Thomas Malory’s Morte Darthur was written during the late fifteenth century, when the English society was greatly influenced by the War of the Roses and the growth of the bourgeois merchant class (Armstrong 133). After Malory had written this piece of literature, a man named William Caxton found England’s first printing press and began to print and distribute Morte Darthur. Because Morte Darthur was written and distributed in the “intersection of manuscript and print culture,” the text exists in two different forms—the Winchester manuscript and the Caxton edition. The controversy regarding which version the “right” Morte Darthur is has been continuing ever since the Winchester manuscript was found in 1934 (134). There are considerable differences between the two versions, and it is difficult to categorically claim that one is better and truer than the other. In the research article, Armstrong explores Caxton’s Morte Darthur and distinguishes the significant changes that were made to the original manuscript, which in turn reflects the new perception of the reading public during the time period (134).



< Malory's Morte Darthur >


            At the end of the fifteenth century, the late medieval society was reshaping itself in regards to literature. The rise of print production led to a shift in the reading audience: while Malory’s Morte Darthur was targeted for the noble’s enjoyment and enlightenment, Caxton’s version focuses on a wider gamut of reading public that spans from both the nobles and to the bourgeoisie (135). There is also a difference in how Malory and Caxton treat their readership. In Malory’s Morte Darthur, the audience is established based on class, whereas Caxton attempts to construct a comprehensive readership through a new concept of “gender specificity” where he uses gender-focused vocabulary (135). Armstrong claims that among over hundred pieces of Caxton’s prints, Caxton’s edition of Morte Darthur is critical in recognizing the “interrelationship of literacy, gender, and audience” during the late fifteenth century (135). Despite such significance of Caxton’s version, his edition of Malory’s text may not initially seem so different from other works targeted to the male audience; this is because Caxton’s Morte Darthur was written within a literary continuum that is also known as the “Worthies Series” of the 1480s.
            Before going into the idea of the “Worthies Series,” it is important to understand the background of Caxton’s printing culture during the late fifteenth century. As mentioned beforehand, the presence of the printing press gave rise to a transition between manuscript and print cultures. This led Caxton’s printshop to handle several clashing concepts such as: “patronage and entrepreneurship, feudalism and capitalism, and noble and bourgeois” (136). Such balancing of oppositional concepts in Caxton’s prints is noteworthy, for Caxton’s version of Morte Darthur effectively handles the intricate mix of “manuscript, print, gender, class, and consumerism” (136). Consumerism is an interesting aspect in Caxton’s Morte Darthur, for he was able to catch the shift in the readership of the time period. While Malory only targeted the nobility with Morte Darthur, the text attracted the rising merchant class who wished to learn the noble ways (137). Caxton recognized such trend and sought to satisfy the demands for similar books, and thus adroitly satisfied customers from both levels of social classes—forming what Armstrong describes as a “permeable membrane” between the two different groups of readership (137).
            Going back to the concept of the “Worthies Series,” Caxton’s version of Morte Darthur exists between a continuum between two other works in the series—Godefroy de Boloigne and Charles the Great. Caxton intended these three pieces to be read together and tried to amplify the effective deliverance of moral lessons. For example, Armstrong points out that Caxton “admonishes” the reader to receive the lesson from Morte Darthur to “doo after the good and leve the evyl and it shal brynge you to good fame and renomme” (137). This didactic nature builds a clear contrast to Malory’s Morte Darthur, whose intended purpose was to provide “entertainment [and] benefit” to its readers (134). Interestingly, Armstrong highlights how quickly Caxton switches from simple description of the text to instruction of the reader. According to Armstrong, this leads the readers to become “active participant[s] in a drama of good and evil, rather than a passive observer” (140). Another difference between Malory and Caxton can be seen through the Pentecostal Oath in the text. With this oath, Malory idealizes the chivalric values to delineate the early days of King Arthur and to stipulate chivalric values within the law. On the other hand, Caxton mentions the oath on a subtly different note. He codifies the law and improves the gender model established by the Pentecostal Oath. Caxton’s version identifies expectations of knights and lists the masculine virtues, which in turn creates a “corresponding model of feminine virtue” (142). He intentionally deletes all clauses that are offensive to women (ex. the rape clause) and upholds his model of feminine virtue by limitedly mentioning women’s capabilities. According to Armstrong, such revision in Caxton’s Morte Darthur makes the text a literary piece it is truly understood to be. 
            All in all, in spite of the slight differences between the two versions of Morte Darthur, Armstrong suggests the importance of looking at both versions. Malory and Caxton’s editions of Morte Darthur are perceived as a literary conversation where “the voices of script, print, class, gender, and producer-consumer relations intermingle” (145). Even though Armstrong points out the limitation of fully understanding and defining the medieval readership, taking a closer look at Caxton’s Morte Darthur in comparison with that of Malory allows us to see the “cultural continuity” of the fifteenth century (Lawton 246). Not only are we able to observe the shift from manuscript culture to that of print, but also we can observe the deeper intentions of Malory and Caxton—their pursuit of the time without “complicated morality, bold action, and human and divine justice” (Simmons 280). In the large picture, as Armstrong would agree, exploring both editions of the text will become highly conducive to comprehending the developmental period of English literature during the fifteenth century.


                                                                
                                                                Works Cited

Armstrong, Dorsey. "Gender and the Script/Print Continuum: Caxton's Morte Darthur." Essays in Medieval Studies: Proceedings of the Illinois Medieval Association 21 (2005): 133-150. Web. 23 Sept. 2013. 

Lawton, David. "English Literary Voices, 1350-1500." The Cambridge Companion to Medieval English Culture. Ed. Andrew Galloway. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2011. 237-257. Print. 

Simmons, Clare A. "Re-creating the Middle Ages." The Cambridge Companion to Medieval English Culture. Ed. Andrew Galloway. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2011. 279-298. Print. 




            

Monday, September 23, 2013

Was there really a historical King Arthur?

This week’s reading, Geoffrey of MonMouth’s Britain is the first narrative account of King Arthur's life. This work, is a collection of imaginative account of British Kings beginning with King Brutus going well into the 7th Century ending with Welsh king Cadwallader. 

The existence of a historical King Arthur has been debated by many historians and scholars alike for centuries. Furthermore, many of these historians and scholars have pointed to evidence (or a lack thereof) to support their claims of whether or not King Arthur (or even existed) ruled in the late 5th and early 6th centuries.  Our textbook suggests that a lack of evidence for King Arthur’s existence has led “Geoffrey of MonMouth’s (the author of The History of the Kings of Britain also known as Historia Regum Britanniae) imagination and status as a historian to become the subject of much debate” (Black et al. 158). For instance, “in 1198 the historian William of Newburgh concluded that the Arthur and Merlin who appear in Geoffrey’s Historia are fictitious characters, not historical ones, and he condemned Geoffrey as the father of lies” (Black et al. 158). While, some historians and scholars have a definitive opinion on the actual existence of King Arthur, some historians and scholars assert that it is probable that King Arthur may have existed even though there is a lack of substantive evidence.  

The Dictionary of the Middle Ages makes reference to several text that give the history of King Arthur’s life and his “supposed” accomplishments and accolades. “the earliest account of Arthur’s supposed flourishing (ca. 490-540) is that of Gildas, whose De excudui et conquest Britanniae was composed in the mid sixth century; it does not mention Arthur. Nearly three centuries passed before the personal exploits, the incredible military victories, and the marks of divine favor associated with Arthur and his noble retainers were celebrated in what case to be an outpouring of writings in many tongues and genres” (Stryaer 564).  Furthermore, this dictionary on the middle ages also questions the validity of several of these texts and proposes that some of these alleged events are unlikely and improbable. However, The Dictionary of the Middle Ages also states that some of the material written on King Arthur could be probable.  According to the section on Arthurian literature in The Dictionary of the Middle Ages
“The first chroniclers’ stark records of these decades came ultimately to be enriched by a far more circumstantial tradition in which the British leader is identified as Arthur and given a more elevated status. No Arthur was known in ancient Celtic lore; but the name was well established in Rome, whence it was transplanted to Britain. For example, Artorius Castor, a distinguished member of the gens Artoria, served as commander of a Roman legion stationed at York In the second century, according to a coffin inscription found in Dalmatia. That the name was adopted by native Britons is readily demonstrated. In particular, Nora Chadwick notes that in Adamnan’s life of St. Columbia, written before 704, a king of Argyll is reported to have a son named Arthur who met death while fighting the Saxons in southeastern Scotland. But evidence that stories about this dimly historical prince ever drifted south to Wales and Cornwall, along with northern British lore about such figures as merlin, is lacking. Nevertheless, that a prototype of some sort existed is probable. Legendary heroes, of course, are commonly folk creations: some local figure too obscure for historical notice is endowed with a brilliant fictional biography, built up largely of old age motifs, such as that of the culture hero who’s parentage is mysterious and whose career ends not in death but with a journey to the otherworld, from which he may be expected to return when needed by his people. (Strayer 564)”

The obvious argument being made here is that while it is probable that a historical King Arthur may have existed in the late 5th to early 6th century, however it is highly unlikely that this is the case. is suggesting that due to an abundance of old age motifs found in the stories of King Arthur’s life then King Arthur may be no more than a common a legendary hero which he states are: of course,  commonly folk creations. However, The Dictionary of the Middle Ages does take into consideration several historical arguments that suggest that King Arthur did exist and rule in the late 5th and early 6th century. For instance, the text mentions the fact that the name Arthur was long established in Rome and transplanted to Britain, and also that there are reports of a king of Argyll had a son named Arthur who died in battle against the Saxons in southeastern Scotland. Nevertheless, The Dictionary of the Middle Ages suggests that there is insufficient evidence to confirm or deny the existence of a Historical King Arthur, therefore the actual existence of a historical King Arthur is unknown.


Works Cited

Black, Joseph, et al. eds. The Broadview Anthology of British Literature: The Medieval Period. Peterborough: Broadview Press, 2009. Print.


Strayer, Joseph R. ed. Dictionary of the Middle Ages. New York: Scribner, c1982-c1989. Print.

Thursday, September 19, 2013

Margery Kempe: Accused of being a what?

Margery Kempe had visions of demons, argued with the Archbishop of York, did a lot of crying, started a brewery, almost got executed for heresy, and talked her husband into a vow of chastity in exchange for dinner dates on Fridays (Broadview 608, 616, 609-610, 609, 618, 613).

As our book introduces her, Margery Kempe lived from around 1373 to 1439 (Broadview 604). To put these dates into perspective, Geoffrey Chaucer lived from 1343 to 1400 (379). Our reading for class, The Book of Margery Kempe, is the earliest surviving autobiography written in English (604). This makes it interesting for what it says about women at the time, as well as the information it gives us about autobiographies and stories from this period. Margery Kempe's story is almost entirely religious. As our textbook says, she "was ... on a self-described quest for sainthood" (604). Our reading follows her from being a proud sinner to her life as a unique kind of Christian.

I had several questions while reading. Why was heresy considered such a serious offense during this time? Why is Kempe on trial for heresy? On page 615 of The Broadview Anthology she is almost imprisoned, accused of being a heretic and a Lollard, and is eventually shackled. For the next few pages she is questioned by the Archbishop. From a surface reading, I did not think she had done anything meriting accusal of heresy, and her actions did not seem to merit the death penalty. I was also confused about what a Lollard was, and it turns out that Lollardy might play a part in why she was accused.

Although many of us know that heresy was a larger offense in medieval England than it is now, it is still worth trying to understand the reason for the magnitude of a heresy charge. A central difference between our society and Medieval England is that we have a legal separation of church and state. They did not: "an accusation of heresy might seem remote and inconsequential; however, in light of the lack of separation between Church and State in medieval England, the charge was life-threatening" (Hall 64). This meant the accused was not only fighting the church, but the state as well.

Lollardy is a slightly different beast. The term "Lollard" was used as a derogatory term for followers of John Wyclif, but its original use was a "name for a religious eccentric or vagabond, usually loosely tied to the church" (Dictionary 7:645). In the looser, original sense, we could say that Kempe was a Lollard, but it remains to be seen whether or not she aligns with Wyclif's beliefs.

John Wyclif held some beliefs that threatened existing religious systems. Wyclif "maintained that secular and ecclesiastical authority depend on grace, and that the clergy, if not in a state of grace, can lawfully (and should) be deprived of their property by the civil power" (Dictionary of the Middle Ages 6:199). Thus, his followers were encouraged to disrupt church structures which were not "in a state of grace". This belief made Lollards dangerous to the established religion. Some Lollards even used Wyclif's charge to purify the church as a license to reclaim corrupt, secular governments: "The doctrine could be interpreted to support insurrection through the dismantling of clerical authority and, by extension, might also apply to those abusing positions of secular power" (Hall 64). Given that the religious and state systems were not entirely separate, a charge of Lollardy was similar--if not identical--to a charge of treason.

Wyclif's teachings included allowing unofficial preachers to speak: "He encouraged his 'poor priests' in their itinerant, unlicensed preaching" (Dictionary 6:199). Kempe does preach in a sense. In the midst of her conflict with the Archbishop, Kempe defends her own teaching and rebuking: "Then the Archbishop said to her, 'You shall swear that you will not teach or scold the people in my diocese.' 'Nay, sir, I will not swear,' she said, 'for I shall speak of God and rebuke those who swear great oaths wherever I go" (Broadview 16). Perhaps here Kempe does resemble a Lollard.

In Literature and Heresy in the Age of Chaucer, Andrew Cole gives a different view on Margery's supposed Lollardy. He puts forth that her ideas are not the reason for her accusal. The accusations against her are based primarily on her external resemblances to Lollards. For example, her frequent bouts of crying and her independent personality align with the stereotypes of a lollard. Lollards were known for loud, emotional outbursts: "And so what they could not achieve by true reason they sought by aggressive bluster, with clamant voice ... and pompous high sounding words" (Henry Knighton, qtd. in Cole 160-161). It is not in her opinions that Kempe appears a Lollard, but in her mannerisms and presentation. Cole writes, "It is 'reason' vs. noise. No wonder, then, that Kempe is often taken to be a 'lollard,' no wonder that her crying is understood by others to be hypocritical, for what often offends is not what she says but how she says it, and how loudly" (161). Given this interpretation, Kempe is not truly a Lollard--even though she may look like one.

In summary, there is not a clear consensus on whether or not Kempe was actually a Lollard. In part, this is because the meaning of the term Lollard was dynamic: it could mean a follower of Wyclif, or simply a religious wanderer. If Cole is correct, it could also mean a religious person who is just loud and emotional. Either way, the charge of Lollardy against Margery Kempe was serious, and she was lucky to avoid penalty.

Works Cited:

Black, Joseph, et al. eds. The Broadview Anthology of British Literature: The Medieval Period. Peterborough: Broadview Press, 2009. Print.

Cole, Andrew. Literature and Heresy in the Age of Chaucer. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1968. Print.

Hall, Kathryn A. "Teaching Margery Kempe in Tandem with the Wife of Bath: 'Wanderynge by The Weye' pairing." South Atlantic Review 72.4 (2013): 59-71. JStor. Web. 17 September 2013.

Strayer, Joseph R. ed. Dictionary of the Middle Ages. New York: Scribner, c1982-c1989. Print.

Sunday, September 15, 2013

Antifeminism in the Wife of Bath

As a character, the Wife of Bath represents a culture confused about the role of women in society. There were many conflicting generalizations being made about women during this time period. Though all assumptions were not deeply embedded in misogyny, they all possessed a deprecating view of women’s sovereignty. Women were seen either “as dangerous temptresses whose company should be shunned by holy men, weak-willed vacillating creatures, easily misled and needing strict supervision for their own good, [or] as delicate merciful peacemakers who needed protection in an evil world” (Jewell 171). Though some women were revered in society, especially those affiliated with the Church, there was still a looming sense of derogation. The idea that women needed to be repressed in some way was widely accepted, especially by the Church. The teachings of the Church “heavily emphasized the submissive role deemed appropriate to women, and their mischievous tendencies if left unchecked (Jewell 171). Despite a woman’s good deeds, intentions, and overall character, she was still just a woman, seen primarily as a relation of Eve, the original sinner. Basically, “it was better to be a secret sinner than a woman” (Minnis 246).
The Wife of Bath
The Wife of Bath focuses most of her prologue defending women’s rights to sexual relationships and condemning Against Jovinian, a popular antifeminist text by St. Jerome. St. Jerome uses scripture to defend his argument that marriage and partaking in sexual relations was an abomination, mainly due to the fact that a woman’s body was considered to stem directly from evil. To St. Jerome, “marriage and whoredom have much in common” (Minnis 254), and it was better to only prostitute yourself to one man (your husband) instead of many men (multiple husbands). In fact, “one of [St. Jerome’s] main motives in writing [his antifeminist text was] the excoriation of women who had behaved rather like the Wife of Bath in rushing from one marriage into another” (Minnis 254). Because it was women’s bodies that were considered evil, by not engaging in sexual activity, women could reach a higher power by being chaste.
The Wife of Bath directly responds to St. Jerome’s argument and uses his same methods to arrive at her conclusions about sex and marriage. Although sex was considered a taboo subject, there was a familiar character troupe in literature during this time which conflicted with the idea that sexual matters shouldn’t be discussed.  “Chaucer’s basic model [for the Wife of Bath] was the literary type of the old woman who teaches the young about love” (Minnis 251). Alastair Minnis, author of Fallible Authors: Chaucer’s Pardoner and Wife of Bath, argues that what the Wife of Bath is advocating for is not all that radical in the context of the old woman character troupe. Although she is arguing for sexual sovereignty for women, the Wife of Bath is really a “tissue of antifeminist discourses relating to sexually aggressive and shrewish women” (Minnis 251). She promotes promiscuity and advocates that women should trick their husbands, things that men would expect women to do.
However, what is important is the way the Wife of Bath is presenting her argument. “The Wife of Bath is engaging not just with male authority but with male methods of argument, the techniques of disputation which were the staple method of intellectual inquiry in medieval schools of higher education, from which women were barred” (Minnis 253). She might not be saying things that are ground-breaking, but using examples from the Bible, however far-fetched they may be, is something innovative. Also, it is not just important that the Wife of Bath is “acting and talking like a man” but that she is “behaving like an educated man…like a preacher, and a real preacher at that, not just a metaphorical one who teaches love-doctrine, as in the Pardoner’s formulation” (Minnis 258). The Wife of Bath uses real passages from the Bible, something most people, even men, did not have access to know. This, according to Minnis, accounts for the Friar’s uncomfortable outburst. By using the Bible to back up her reasoning, the Wife of Bath goes beyond her own stereotype. “There was nothing particularly troubling about an old woman teaching about love and womanly wiles…but the Wife’s Prologue and Tale surmount the confining discourses of that ‘oulde daunce’” (Minnis 259). In that way, the Wife of Bath not only embodies one of the expected stereotypes of womanhood, she uses the discourse of antifeminism to reiterate her point. The Wife of Bath learned the “academic techniques of ‘arguing by authority’” (Minnis 253) from her husband, Jakyn, from being forced to listen to passages from his Book of Wicked Women. Jakyn thought he was teaching her how to be and obedient wife; he actually taught her how to scrutinize textual laws and form her own opinions using those same texts. So, though the Wife of Bath’s character was not actually liberating women through her belief in sexual autonomy, she does represent a woman capable of intellectual discussion, something far more valuable to the construction of rights for women.

Works Cited

Jewell, Helen. Women in Medieval England. New York: Manchester University Press, 1996. Print

Minnis, Alastair. Fallible Authors: Chaucer’s Pardoner and Wife of Bath. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2008. Print




Friday, September 13, 2013

Sovereignty in the Wife of Bath's Tale
 In the 18th century, sovereignty meant "territory under the rule of a sovereign, or existing as an independent state..." or "...supreme controlling power in communities not under monarchical government, absolute and independent authority" (Thomas 89).  In contrast to this, the American definition is "complete independence and self-government" (Thomas 89).  The argument made in this article is that while the knight took advantage of the wyf by having his way with her, she ended up with the sovereignty in the relationship, but what exactly does that sovereignty entail?  Also, why does she get this power over him when he can clearly overtake her?
In her tale, the Wife of Bath is attempting to show that women were not as helpless and dependent on men as thought at the time.  The wyf in the story is raped by the knight, but she takes him to court, where he has to marry her in order to keep his own life for the crime committed.  The knight is also pictured as not knowing what he wants.  He is given the choice, by the wyf, between whether he preferred obedience or beauty in women, but he could not choose.  These are clearly not the only two options for characteristics in a woman, but they are the main characteristics that would be sought by a character such as the knight, and the wyf knows this.  Him not even being able to decide between these two aspects shows the low view he has of women in the first place, since he sees them as equal traits.  If women were valued as intellectual beings, those would not be the only choices, but the wyf is aware of the knight's mental processes, or lack thereof.  As shown by him even raping her in the first place, "he has been under the control of his desires from the beginning, and thus he never attains knowledge or power" (Thomas 94).  Contrarily, "as a shapeshifter, the wyf represents the ultimate fantasy of power over one's own body" (Thomas 95).

In addition to the idea of women having more power than thought, other issues addressed are those of the court of law.  The wyf took the knight to court for raping her, and then she was allowed to decide his fate.  During this period of time, it was not rare for the citizens of a community to take the law into their own hands.  Stories and literature were produced during this time, such as Robin Hood and the Tale of Gamelyn, which talk about vigilantes.  "Both literary types look to the crown for provision of just laws; but one type thinks that in hard times the crown needs some good local men to jump-start the system with violent self-help" (Cambridge 100).  The wyf did not take the violence into her own hands towards the knight, but she now has control over him and his desires since they are now married, and this is seen as a form of justice for what he did to her.  If he was so stupid as to take out his desires on her, those of which he did not even have a mental control over, then now she is in a position where she can tell him what to do with those desires since she is his sovereign and does know how to control her own desires.  Thomas says, "the knight's redemption from poverte, or lack of worth, may be illusory" (Thomas 95).  He may not have been killed by the law, but now someone else is sovereign over him, and there is nothing he can do other than accept it.  Meanwhile, the wyf is fully aware of this, and finds it amusing: "Her apparent desire for the knight is part of the joke, making the 'bath of blisse' when he feels desire for her, not the knight's reward, but the moment when he becomes locked into an ever more abject relationship to the wyf" (Thomas 95).

Work Cited:
Thomas, Susanne Sara. "The Problem Of Defining "Sovereynetee" In The "Wife Of Bath's Tale.." Chaucer Review 41.1 (2006): 87-97. Academic Search Complete. Web. 13 Sept. 2013.
Galloway, Andrew.  The Cambridge Companion to Medieval English Culture.  Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2011. Print.