Monday, November 25, 2013

England’s Push for Religious Uniformity During the 17th Century


After a tumultuous start to the 17th century characterized by nationwide religious unrest, the Parliament of England called for uniformity in hopes to stabilize the nation. Baptists, Congregationalists, Royalists, Independents, Quakers, Calvinists, Protestants, Presbyterians, Anglicans, and Catholics were religious subdivisions scattered throughout England. Needless to say, uniformity was going to be a challenge. Would this undertaking prove to be worth the effort? This religious multiplicity had developed in the 1640’s and 1650’s and was believed to be the main cause of England’s religious and therefor political instability. Each religious sect had their own practices. They differed in religious opinions, customs, and rigidity. This was thought to disturb the general peace of the kingdom, and for the English Parliament, the diversity of religious ideals made their constituents harder to control. Logically, it is easier to control a population of like-minded people as opposed to a handful of independently thinking religious subclasses. It is through the hope of uniformity that Parliament forced upon its diverse citizens penal acts of religious censorship that affected and oppressed all branches of religion besides that of the Anglican, Church of England. These acts were built up by Parliament to establish and protect an Anglican/Royalist religious and governmental monopoly.

Religion and government were one in the same in 17th century England. Government legislation directly affected religious happenings. Their interconnectivity made parliamentary biased religious decisions unavoidable, which was the intent. Under the reign of the recently restored Charles II, a number of acts were installed between the years 1660 and 1688 that would characterize the quarter century known as the “Era of Great Persecution” (White, 95). The Test Acts purpose were to strip citizens of their religious freedoms and force them to merge with the traditions and customs of the Anglican Church. The first of these acts was the Corporation act of 1661. This act was intended to ensure that all government positions were held by members of the Anglican Church. The passing of this Corporation Act received a royal assent to authorization rather than a drawn out fight through the levels of a non-bias parliament. The Corporation Act stated that all people of governmental importance such as mayors, town clerks, councilmen, owners of corporations, or any person bearing office be required to “take the oaths of Allegiance and Supremacy; then they must assert that they ‘do declare and believe that it is not lawful under any pretense whatsoever to take arms against the king” (White, 100), thus restricting public office to members of the Church of England. The English government sought to control religion through penal legislation in hopes of bringing peace and uniformity to England.

In addition to the ever-important Corporation act, there were many other penal laws established to further refine Parliamentary/ Anglican/ Royalists power. These Test Acts further tested people’s religious affiliation and loyalty in order to weed out religions sects such as Catholicism and Presbyterianism. Another act that is relevant to our class reading was the 1662 Act of Uniformity. This act required that all ministers were to have received an episcopal ordination, and also had to publically declare their “unfeigned accent and consent” (White, 103) to all and everything taught in the Church of England’s Book of Common Prayer. This book was accepted by both houses of parliament, and contained all the workings and teaching of the Anglican Church. Under this act, priest and ministers all over England were doomed. They were forced to change. Expectedly this didn’t sit well with many, and when there was non-cooperation, there was persecution, uprising, and general unrest. This push for religious uniformity intended to make life blissful for England and the Anglican Church, it is arguable whether this intent was met and, as a side affect, religious progression in England was greatly impeded.

It is argued by Clyde L. Grose under the American Society of Church History, that restoration of an Established Church was a mistake. He says that political restorations (Charles II) and required religious institutions (Church of England) have almost never made long lasting positive affects. Instead of England moving forward with individualistic thinking, the nation put itself into a sort of religious coma, where no positive progress was made until the established religion was repealed. England during the 17th century had many bright minds (such as John Bunyan) who were progressing, innovating, and positively challenging the religious norms of the day. The majority of these bright minds were affiliated to religious sects other than the Church of England. Once the established Church forcibly took over, these bright minds lost their the right and ability to voice their innovative ideas to the easily influenced public.

There is no competition in uniformity. Without competition, people, ideas, and religions become stagnant. They idle instead of moving forward. It is through competition that ideas are able to be built upon, tested, and succeed. The Act of Corporation, the Act of Uniformity, and the rest of the Test Acts all but doomed the competitive, individualistic thinkers of 17th century England.

“A restoration is supposed to be a return to normalcy, it is never genuinely that. It invariably means a return to situation normal to a time past” (Grose, 3).

The restoration of Charles II and the establishment of a uniform religion through the Test Acts impeded England’s religious and governmental evolution in the 17th century.




(Easy to say in hindsight!)


Works cited

Grose, Clyde. “The Religion of Restoration England.” Church History Volume. 6, No. 3     (1937): 223-232. Online database.

White, B. R.. “The English Baptists of the 17th Century.” Ed. Roger Hayden. The   Baptist Historical Society, 1996. 93-107. Print.

20 comments:

  1. One might think that, with so many people trying to change someone's own religion, that person would not place those same impositions on someone else. However, that is not the case with the rulers of Britain. Instead, they constantly forced their constituents to adhere to their own religious beliefs, apparently not realizing that their own religious oppression caused (or should have caused) feelings of displeasure. Chesny's summation of the Test Acts is insightful, providing a detailed narrative as to what the were intended to do and what they accomplished. As one may expect, the "religious coma" that came hindered progress, the inevitable result of so much religious control.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Living in a time where I am free to practice whatever religion I choose, it is difficult to think of a time where people could not do that. Reading Bunyan's Pilgrim's Progress is almost inspirational given the circumstances in which Bunyan was writing. The fact that he was imprisoned for his religious beliefs is truly sad. However, I really enjoyed Pilgrim's Progress, and I am glad that his imprisonment resulted in this text. I have to wonder if I lived in these times if I would stand strong with my beliefs or conform to avoid persecution.

    ReplyDelete
  3. One way to repress the spreading of ideas is to take away freedom. It seems that by limiting the people's choices to their religion, rather than peaceful unity, reluctant conformation occurred. Considering this, it is no surprise that, according to common belief, citizens of this society would want to flee from an oppressive and over-controlling government. If the government is so strict with its top leaders and officials, how much worse can it treat its "lesser" citizens?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Like Grace, I find it difficult to imagine a time in which I would not be free to practice whatever religion I choose in whatever way I choose to practice it. After reading this historical context about Bunyan's life as well as reading his work in Pilgrim's Progress, I find his writing to be passionate, inspiring, and easy to understand. Knowing that Bunyan stood strong in his beliefs, served as an example for other people to firmly stand up for what they believe in, and that he wrote while he was imprisoned provides exceptional background to further admire and respect his work. Bunyan writes in such a way that makes his work accessible to all people, no matter their gender, age, or socioeconomic status. Rather than invoking a muse (as others, like Milton, have done), Bunyan states that his work just happened during his imprisonment and then later evolved into a work that allows people with somewhat of a guide/directions in order to reach the Holy Land.

    Through the Act of Corporation, the Act of Uniformity, and the rest of the Test Acts passed by Parliament, I am able to better understand Bunyan's situation and the context in which he writes Pilgrim's Progress. Personally though, I cannot imagine a world in which state is not separated from religion. As America prides itself on individualism and freedom of the people to think and make decisions for themselves, I believe that imposing religious uniformity would create detrimental instability and unrest among the people. It makes sense that the English Parliament would want to use homogenization of religion in order to control the population, but if there is no learning dynamic and room for question, then how did the government expect England to propel forward as a powerful, intelligent nation?

    ReplyDelete
  5. It is interesting to note the symbolic characteristics of John Bunyan's work and how they may relate to the political events of the time. The main character is forced, in the early parts of the story, to choose between the non-religious and religious life. After little deliberation, he forgoes a life of practicality and choose to go on a journey of religion. Such choices may reflect the nature of the deeply religious society Bunyan was born into. In 1600's, society could not imagine itself without religion. In today's atmosphere, one might not think it a very big deal to squash together many Christian organizations because, whatever the differences, everyone believes that Jesus is the son of God. The incredibly religious nature of our past readings indicate the level of religiosity of the time.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Once again, it is fascinating to see the ties between religion and politics throughout the history of England. For me, I was actually a little surprised that something as stringent as the Test Acts, Act of Uniformity, or even the Corporation Act had not been instilled sooner amongst the English people.

    Recalling Elizabeth I, religion has played an integral role in the presence and power of the monarchy. And now, after the ascension of Charles II, it seems almost as if the dismantlement of the monarchy previously had never occurred in British history. Once more, legalities are put into place in order to ensure that the power remains at the throne rather than the people. By making those in political positions of power swear their authority to the throne and thus against anything (including religion) that would go against his rule, religions becomes a sort of treason, particularly in this era.

    I do agree with Grose’s claims about this sort of religious stagnation that resulted from these acts. In my opinion, it would be rather difficult to question, let alone write about anything religious without fearing repercussions. In a way, these acts allowed for a sort of censorship of the arts, where only writings that glorified the monarchy and the Church of England went unchallenged by the king and other authorities.

    John Bunyan’s life was definitely a tumultuous one, with him coming and going from prison. Still, I guess these acts were important because they magnified the importance of writers like Bunyan, who challenged and questioned the Church of England and religion as a whole. There may have been only a few of these “bright minds” as they are called working throughout the country, but I do think that these Acts that were meant to suppress these bright thinkers had a positive effect in the sense that they made what these people were doing so important in both the literary as well as religious realm.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Theoretically, uniformity in a society inhibits competition and self-expression. However, it seems that reality proves otherwise. As shown in Bunyan’s case with Pilgrim’s Progress, his discontent with the government’s move towards the religious uniformity sprung from such “uniformity.” Even though governmental oppression on freedom of ideas, it also seems to promote clandestine yet clever movement among the mass public. It may be true that restrictions such as the Act of Corporation, the Act of Uniformity, and the rest of the Test Acts suppressed the individualistic thinkers during the time period, we can also notice that it challenged such thinkers to be more flexible and symbolic with their expressions. As with Bunyan’s Pilgrim’s Progress, it is sometimes straightforwardly evident that he uses symbolism in his plot and characters. I’m not sure what the standards of religious restrictions were at the time, but it is clear that Bunyan managed to continue his individualistic thinking through his writing. It is always intriguing to discover the hidden efforts of the writer during such periods of restriction.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Like others, it is difficult for to imagine living in a society where I was forced upon a certain religion that if I did not adhere to to there would be severe consequences. Like Tiffany said, it is only natural that people would want to turn away from or rebel against a society that forces them to practice a certain religion. However, it is also natural that some will convert or go along with what they are being told in order to not face the consequences. If one does not truly believe what they are forced to believe, doesn't that defeat the purpose of so called unity among a kingdom's people?

    ReplyDelete
  9. The seperation of Church and State is extremely important to me, and, as many of my classmates have already stated, I cannot imagine a time in which those two institutions were mixed. With your religion telling you one thing and your country another, I imagine it would be difficult to come to a religious truth. Bunyan's Pilgrim's Progress, as he states in the introduction, makes an excellent tool for someone living in an era of religious uncertainty. His use of allegory really makes clear what, in his opinion, one must do to become saved from damnation. Given the historical background, I'm sure many people during Bunyan's time were very confused and unsure which religion they could trust.

    ReplyDelete
  10. While reading this article about imposed religious conformity and punishing any who stray from the allocated beliefs, we may think such activities to be arcane or old fashioned. But there still are a lot of enforced but not necessarily demanded religious beliefs kept in check today in our society. Much of our government still functions within the guidelines established in the Constitution and other documents, many of which contain Christian messages and morals. We still swear on Bibles in a court of law. It also doesn't seem to matter who our President is, as long as they are Christian. There were even debates during certain President's terms of office; Kennedy met scrutiny for his Catholicism, for example. Our money still has "In God we Trust," and the Pledge of Allegiance spoken by kids has "One nation, under God." It's unlikely that we'll ever see a non-Christian president very soon, because a lot of people hold religion and politics as still very close together- there would probably be uproar if a Muslim, Jewish, or Hindu person ran for office. The point being, reading this article might make all the religious turmoil and imposition of the past seem very quaint and antiquated, but we can't ignore the fact that religion still has a strong grasp on politics. Not in a commanding sense, but in a communal sense; people impose their religion on public officers, and if their views aren't shared, there's uproar and condemnations. While our government doesn't impose religious uniformity, there still is a very Christian majority that keeps the religious affiliations of presidents and institutions in check. While the Christianity dictated during the time period of this article was a very specific one, Christianity as a whole still holds sway in politics today. And while it's not technically bad that it still has as much influence as it did in the past, the fact that similar strains of imposed religious beliefs can be traced hundreds of years between governments rubs a little the wrong way.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Although religion and its practice hold much significance, the demand of religious uniformity in 17th century England proved arbitrary according to Jonathan Swift, who not only ridiculed its humanly synthesized nature due to differences in perceptions of the same text, but also its pension for commencing life-threatening battles. When Swift describes the old magistrate's decree that outlawed cracking an egg on its big end, thus creating the Big-Endian domination, he illustrates the English monarch's frivolous need to make himself feel normal by creating a uniform law that all citizens must follow. He also demonstrates the issue of biblical interpretation and how although men read the same text, worship the same God, and recognise the same Saviour, they do not realise the detrimental effects of self-righteousness.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Trying to have religious uniformity in order to bring stability to England might have done the contrary. Since there was so many religious groups in England at this time it was difficult to bring them under one religion. Furthermore, people were unlikely to change their religious beliefs because they were told to do so. Rather, people were more likely to fight for their religious beliefs and consequently bring instability to the country.

    ReplyDelete
  13. During the time where of great religious division in England, it is quite understandable for England to enforce various uniform acts. As seen throughout history, religion played a big role on one's decision and subsequent actions. Instead of unifying the country, England's plan to unify the country religiously brought more unrest to the society. I believed the plan failed dues to it harsh punishment toward non-conformers and it urgency. It is a difficult task to unify groups of people religiously who were divided for decades in a matter months.

    ReplyDelete
  14. It is hard to even fathom or even understand on the most basic of human levels how the English Parliament could believe that stripping their constituents of their religious beliefs, heritages, and freedoms would make them ore easier to control. It is to the surprise of no one that such religious insensitivity and discrimination led to such tumultuous behavior and chaos. Personally, I believe that the English Parliament got what was coming to them once they began to strip way one of the most basic human rights. Furthermore, I believe that it is only natural that the people of England would riot and protest against this religious persecution and oppression.

    ReplyDelete
  15. The “Era of Great Persecution” is a very accurate statement as I cannot believe that the Test Acts was even passed. I am truly appalled as to how a body of people especially one claiming to belong to the Church under the beliefs of God would think it is okay to strip someone of their religious beliefs in order to have uniformity. I completely understand the want for people in governing positions to be of the church, but to extend this control towards the towns people is absolutely absurd. The demand for uniformity allowed nothing but uprisings and retaliation from society simply because it wasn't executed properly. One must persuade others to conform through words not through persecution and biased laws. It makes perfect sense to me that no positive progress was made due to the demands of Parliament during that time.

    ReplyDelete
  16. First, I don't think it's that difficult to imagine a lack of religious freedom. Our society--especially the South-Eastern US--is very Christian. As C.J. pointed out, presidents typically "have" to be Christian, in that we won't vote for them otherwise. Growing up in a mostly anti-homosexual culture is similar, I think. If someone doesn't seem interested in members of the opposite sex, or if they show interest in one of their own, they're singled out. Individuals are afraid of having thoughts which might make them question their own sexuality. In an Anglican culture, some people would be singled out for believing differently. Some might want to tow the party line, but feel themselves drawn to the theology of Calvinism or the rituals of the church in Rome.

    As for the idea that enforcing religious conformity inhibits progress: well. Yes. Yes it does. But what did the government want? I *don't* think they wanted progress. The point of the Test Acts was to create unity, not to advance the academic or intellectual state of religion. I think the argument in Grose's article is correct in that the actions of the government prevented religion from "moving forward". However, I think to say that the actions were a mistake requires that we accept religious progress as more important than cultural unity. I think *that* was the topic of decision made by the government. They didn't try to advance religion and utterly fail, they chose to be unified.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The fact that religious freedom is rare cannot be understated. Even after the pilgrims landed at Plymouth, which was an event we identify with the founding of America for religious autonomy, various splits occurred with later-forming sects such as the Quakers. The Salem Witch Trials is perhaps one of the more poignant examples of oppression, injustice, and the twisting of belief to work toward one's favor. The ability at which religious mechanics can be manipulated to achieve political and personal gain is repeated throughout history within the context of many cultures and has served to incite some of the most noteworthy conflicts. The bottom line is that religious upheaval is inherent in all stretches of the globe.

      Unity in the sense of single-minded followship is what seems like the appropriate description. A common belief of a mass number of people demands a like-mindedness that inhibits the innovation of 'subversive' thought. Yes, the government may not have been concerned with progress, but it was concerned with fostering a community of people that did not question their central authoritative figure.

      Delete
  17. Trying to force everyone to practice the same religion might have seemed like it would erase problems in governing all of the subjects, but it actually did the opposite. Of course, there are always going to be people that fight laws implemented, and there would definitely be people to protest the outlawing of religious practices. Just because a king decreed that a religion could not be practiced does not mean that people would suddenly change what they had believed and practiced for so long. People would fight back, even though there would be consequences, and this would lead to further uprisings because then those people would be viewed as martyrs that had to be avenged.

    ReplyDelete
  18. The idea of having religious uniformity is like the idea of a universal language: unlikely. The idea becomes utopian and unrealistic to the point where it's not possible to achieve and frustrates those who actually believe it could happen. Of course the people in England would protest, hundreds are being told to change what they've known their whole lives. While it's a nice idea from a political standpoint, it's not realistic.

    ReplyDelete
  19. When your in a society that is filled with a mixture of different religions, and you have a government that controls everything including religion and this government is pro one religion, it is no surprise that the other religions are going to retaliate. There is no possible way to have religious uniformity, like Taylor said, because people have their own beliefs and ideas, and are not going to change or convert those ideas just because the government tells them to. We as humans are stubborn and stuck in our ways, so for a government to even think about placing us all on the same page when it comes to religion is absurd.

    ReplyDelete