In
the 1530s, King Henry VIII set forth legal processes to tear down many
monasteries throughout England. Henry
ordered the majority of “900 religious houses in England” (Bernard 390) not
only to be metaphorically separated in the sense that the communities of people
were dissolved but also physically in that the buildings themselves were
demolished. As the head of his own
denomination, Anglicanism, Henry not only held political power over his
constituents but also self-designated religious authority. While some historians speculate that the
deconstruction of so many of these religious buildings was merely rooted in the
maintenance of greed by looting monasteries’ relics rather than caused by
ideological dissonance, G. W. Bernard argues that “we should be wary about
interpreting the dissolution simply in material terms” (392). That is, Bernard feels that Henry’s
dissolution of these holy buildings had purpose other than that of simply
obtaining items of high wealth and monetary value.
Bernard does concede that Henry’s
administration did, of course, take advantage of the materials that they
stumbled upon in each monastery, pulling items of importance naturally to
increase his own wealth, to assert his monetary dominance over his people. Because “The revenues of the religious
houses… amounted to over £130,000 a year” (Bernard 393), Henry and his cronies
saw the opportunity to seize items of worth.
Even some of the less financially valuable parts of monasteries were
taken and implemented: “after the dissolution of the monasteries much stonework
was torn down and reused in Henry’s works, generally as rubble for foundations,
but occasionally for other purposes” (“The King’s Houses – 1485 – 1660”
21). Still, Bernard states that other
purposes were key in Henry’s decision to demolish these buildings, as Henry
desired firmly to state his religious presence and “his royal supremacy” (393)
and to prove himself the worldly leader of his religion. Furthermore, Henry not only wished to prove
powerful in his religion but also to prove his religion powerful against other
ideologies, “rival religious beliefs” (Bernard 393) like the Catholicism of the
monasteries.
The split of Anglicanism from Catholicism was,
as many educated people know, Henry’s difficulty to “search for a divorce”
(Bernard 395) and his denial from the Catholic Church. His disagreements in belief, that he as
royalty should be allowed divorce, with the Pope caused the “ultimate break
with Rome” (Bernard 395), and Henry decided to form his own Christian
denomination of the Church of England, inciting the English Reformation. Bernard argues that Henry’s decision to split
after the refusal of his divorce was not necessarily one of political agenda
initially but rather that “it was at best embarrassing and at worst threatening
to the king” (395). Once he made the
decision to split from the Catholic Church, Henry’s next step was to ensure
that his citizens obeyed his orders and fell in line with his commands.
Worrying that the monasteries, whose
roots were Catholic, would stick to their traditional affiliation, “Henry was
determined that monasteries should recognize his authority” (Bernard 396). Henry and his “vicegerent in spirituals”
(Bernard 396), Thomas Cromwell, then embarked on trips that were essentially
monastery inspections. Ascertaining
wealth of each religious house was, of course, a factor in these treks, but Bernard
argues that Henry primarily wanted “to assent royal authority” (396), to
guarantee that the monks and friars legitimately considered him to be their
leader. Interestingly, Bernard notes
that these inspections revealed much “evidence of sexual misconduct” (397) by
several members of the clergy in a range of activity including that with boys
and that with nuns, many of whom found themselves pregnant consequently. As a result of the findings of these
inspections, “there were discussions about what should be done to reform the
monasteries” (Bernard 399), but these conversations were generally
unfruitful. Alas, the first round of
dissolution began.
The first act that demanded
dissolution targeted only the smaller monasteries whose income did not justify
their remaining open also because more abuse tended to occur in these smaller
buildings. Henry and Cromwell conveyed
that this reformative move was so that “religion is right well kept and
observed” (Bernard 399), so finances were not the only factor in their
removal. Ultimately, “Henry VIII was
planning to confiscate the treasures of parish churches” (Bernard 400)
according to gossip, which initially held no truth. However, because word of mouth was spreading
so fervently, a small rebellion in northern England came to be, forcing Henry
to feel as though he had to put his foot down.
As religious and royal leader, Henry demanded the respect and obedience
of his citizens, becoming filled with “outright hostility” (Bernard 402). Bernard notes that ultimately, “At some point
in late 1537 Henry and his counsellors [sic]” (404) decided to dissolve
monasteries completely, commanding with full force the destruction of buildings
and the reaping of worthy artifacts and relics from each one.
Bernard finally argues that Henry’s
actions were not even completely those of a power struggle or an assertion of
dominance, noting that the Church of England was “Catholicism without the pope,
without monasteries and without pilgrimages… what he had already rejected was
devotion to individual saints” (409), perhaps creating an attempt to be
spiritually closer to God. Regardless of
the validity of Bernard’s final hypothesis, he states that wealth and greed
were not the primary reasons for the Dissolution of the Monasteries. Instead, his desire for respect and
recognition of his authority in addition to a potentially genuine attempt to
reform sexual corruption were the bases of the dissolutions.
Works Cited
Bernard, G. W. “The Dissolution of the Monasteries.” History
96.324 (2011): 390-409. Academic Search Complete. Web. 2
Oct. 2013. <http://proxy-s.mercer.edu/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=a9h&AN=65302213&site=eds-live>.
“The
King’s Houses 1485 – 1660.” The History of the King’s Works. Ed. Howard Colvin. Vol. 4.
London: H. M. Stationery Office, 1963.
Print.
The idea that Henry's dissolution of the monasteries for money is intriguing. When you think about it, most monasteries, even the poorer ones, had to be turning a decent profit selling indulgences. They would have had quite a bit of money, providing the monks and others were as holy as they claimed and not using the money for worldly goods. Money could have been a driving factor in deciding to destroy all of the churches. I don't quite understand how they were allowed to seize these finances without there being some sort of backlash. It just doesn't seem to me that destroying the buildings entitles the king to have everything that was found in them.
ReplyDeleteI wonder if the 'divine right of kings' would have anything to do with this paradox. While it does seem that the king would be doubted and held in contempt of the church, the followers of 16th century Catholicism were taught to think that the office he held was a forthright blessing from God himself. Despite King Henry's Protestantism, he still claimed to follow the deity of God and Jesus Christ. Bernard's reasoning-that suggests a moral purpose behind Henry's action-is founded on the assumption that the king was, in fact, acting under the will of God. Instead of acting for his own self-serving purposes by snuffing out the church that would not grant him the divorce he wanted, we are presented with the possibility that the king was acting (either consciously of unconsciously) under a divine will.
DeleteKing Henry VIII was a man who wanted to establish his reign and, as suggested by his perseverance to obtain a divorce despite Catholic laws against this action, determined to carry out his personal desires. It comes as a surprise that one of the reasons why he tore down the monasteries was because that he wanted to stop the immoral actions and abuse of power within these institutions; it seems to be too noble of a motive.
ReplyDeleteI wonder about his religiousness in that to not only tear down monasteries but to also use the remnants that are left for secular things is considerably sacrilegious. Henry did not use these goods to help his people but to rather establish his power and make personal use of sacred materials. Again, as we discussed in class, politics intertwine with religion, just as the pieces of the monasteries became part of the kings' buildings.
Bernard's suggestion that Henry VIII's dissolution of monasteries stemmed from a need for reformation and becoming spiritually closer to God is very interesting. As Taelor stated, many of the monasteries Henry VIII visited were corrupt. By dissolving these institutions, Henry very well could have been seeking to purify Christianity and get back to the roots of the religion sans Catholic traditions. However, I am not personally persuaded that was the case. I am unsure if England's monarch system was caesaropapist, but if it was, it would be very important to Henry VIII that his people viewed him as not only their king, but their main religious leader. To me, it makes sense that Henry VIII would want to destroy monasteries not only for the material goods they would supply, but as a symbol of his power to the people of England. If your king physically tore down a place that signified your religion, it would be a very clear message who was actually in charge of your religion. The Pope could, of course, put monasteries in place, but Henry VIII could just tear them down.
ReplyDeleteyeah!
Deleteyeah!
DeleteThe whole process involved with the split from established religions is very confusing. I may just be thinking in terms of religion today, where religion is not essential to the running of the country, but back in this time period, religion and ruling were very much tied together. While there wasn't necessarily a religious ruler of a nation like England, the people in charge were expected to follow the religion held by the people. And when these shifts in religion occur, the whole order is upset. Looking through this article, Taylor, I really try to visualize the entire process that went into converting England from Catholicism to Anglicanism, not just spiritually but structurally. Religion was very important not just for how people worshiped but how their livelihoods were arranged. And this very organized destruction of monasteries stands as a testament to just how easily fluctuations of any kind back then could have an impact on an entire nation, and how deeply rooted these systems are that they have to be physically uprooted to make a change. The purpose behind this concentrated effort to demolish monasteries is also interesting; often times, religious institutions possessed a lot of the wealth of a nation. The cynic in me believes that though the religion has changed, the money and power is still with those in charge. But I thought this was a very enlightening article, Taylor. Good job!
ReplyDeleteWhat’s pretty interesting is the irony of the situation. King Henry VIII saw monasteries as places housing immense wealth and corruption, all of which go against Christian ethics. Yet, his reactions seem to strike the same note with him pillaging these religious institutions. Taking the stonework to help build Tudor mansions alone is striking symbolism for how Henry essentially ravaged these religious houses and established his own religious authority.
ReplyDeleteWhile Bernard’s argument is plausible, it doesn’t really seem to make Henry’s actions seem any better. In essence, what he did reminds me a lot of other events in history, especially Hitler’s rise, which included burning away anything that disagreed with his doctrines or beliefs.
In a way, Henry’s actions are understandable to some effect, for if he did not strictly enforce his new form of religion, it would more than likely not be followed. Still, the fact that monasteries and religious figures were put out of their residences is a frightening thing to imagine. Today, we would associated that more with a sort of terroristic act than a way of exacting a ruler’s authority of his people, which, you could argue, is a form of terrorism.
I guess, for me, asserting his authority and taking money from the monasteries seem to go hand in hand. And the idea of Henry trying to advocate for sexual reform is interesting, to say the least, specifically considering his own personal life.
I do wonder, though, if this somehow benefited the artwork that Henry took from these religious places. It says that the artwork was taken, most likely for a visual display of his wealth and, therefore, power, but I wonder if Henry’s coveting of this artwork allowed for it to be preserved rather than fading away in an isolated and secluded monastery. Perhaps this ended up being a positive for the preservation of artwork?
Bernard assertion of Henry VIII's motive for Dissolution of Monasteries was to reform corruption in the Church of England is quite arguable and unconvincing. The more plausible reason behind the dissolution was stemmed from vengeance. King Henry VIII most likely wanted to get back at the Church for disapproving his divorce and to demonstrate that he is the true ruler of England (not the Pope) in both politic and religion. Bernard suggested that Henry VIII genuinely attempt to reform the Church of England because he destroyed the corrupted churches. However, I see it nothing more than a wise plan to garner public supports for destruction of monasteries. It was an irony how Henry VIII's greed for power lessen corruption in the churches of England.
ReplyDeleteI have to agree with Kim here. King Henry's motive for the Dissolution of the Monasteries was probably not to reform the church and get the people to be more spiritual. Rather this was a purely political move to have more power. The church in Rome was above any king in England. For Henry this was a threat so the best thing to do for him was to declare himself ruler of both church and state.
DeleteI have to disagree with this idea that King Henry VIII pillaged and destroyed monasteries in an attempt to become more spiritual. Most evidence seems to say otherwise. It seems to me that he simply did not like not getting his way. Seriously, he completely denounced a religion just because he was not allowed to divorce his wife. The monasteries were constant reminders of the Pope's power. So, what better way to assert his dominance over the religious authority that denied him his wishes then to destroy its buildings of reverence. As for stealing the wealth of the monasteries, if you are going to destroy a building then it only seems logical to take anything of value first. Especially if you are a greedy, pompous monarch. And what better way to stick it to the Pope than to steal his wealth.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Jayme. King Henry's past spiritual occurrences hadn't been done with a good moral heart. This is a man who attempted to change the oldest religion just because his wife wasn't sexually pleasing him anymore. Since monasteries are rich in Catholic ritual and rooted in catholicism sin general, it wouldn't be unexpected for King Henry to destroy them because of a personal bias.
DeleteThank you for this response! I totally agree. To me, it seems like King Henry VII's desire to break down the monastery was another part of his religious and political temper tantrum of sorts. When he did not get his way or something did not align with the way in which he thought, his method is to retaliate. I do not believe at all that he destroyed the monasteries because he thought they were corrupt and impeded spiritual growth and connection. Now, he might have thought they were corrupt because they were rooted in Catholicism, as Jayme and Taylor have said. This is not to say that Henry was a terrible brute that had no real reason for good intentions for tearing down the monastery. However, I do think that most of what Henry did was for selfish reasons and the dissolution of the monasteries would be no different.
DeleteAfter reading your blog, I now no longer like King Henry Vlll. The fact that he wanted to go against the church's ways and get a divorce never bothered me, because I feel like if he was really unhappy then he should freely be able to do as he pleases. But now with this added knowledge of the possibility that he only wanted to tear down the monasteries for his own beneficial purposes makes me no longer like him. The fact that he was greedy enough to tear down people's places of sacred worship fro his own gain is just plain out wrong. Especially when he's the King, which means that he already has enough wealth. So for me this blog just made me dislike King Henry.
ReplyDeleteI don't think we should view the dissolution of the early monasteries or the claiming of their goods as sacrilegious. It's important to remember that there was "evidence of sexual misconduct" including boys and nuns within the monasteries, particularly the early targets of dissolution. While we could look at the destruction of these places as sacrilegious, there is a strong precedent within Christianity for the purging of holy places. Jesus turns over tables in the temple (Matthew 21) because he is displeased with the money-changers exploiting pilgrims. As a more extreme example, we've read about alleged heretics being executed for their allegedly false beliefs. Certainly cleansing the monasteries of the sexual behavior of the monks is grounds for similar action. Maybe, the destruction of the buildings wasn't sacrilegious--maybe it was restoring true religion. The behavior of those inside the monasteries could render the buildings themselves non-sacred, making the buildings' destruction permissible.
ReplyDeleteHowever, Henry had bigger fish to fry in terms of motivation. Purging the religion was probably not his first priority. I just wanted to comment on the justifiability and "sacrilegiousity" of his actions.
Its important to keep in mind the amount of authority King Henry held.. Although this is mere speculation, i think there is a different meaning behind "the divine right of kings" possibly a less divine, more worldly one. It meant; whatever the king wanted done would be done. Possibly, the king could have made up these accusations of sexual misconduct in order to support his argument or create his argument pushing for the destruction of the catholic monasteries. Or maybe he found one case of sexual misconduct and transposed the misconduct onto multiple monasteries. Coercion and corruption happen daily in our modern society, and I am sure it happened as frequently or even more frequently during the time of kings.....In defense of the monasteries....
DeleteAfter reading this, I made the observation that the significance of "sexual reformation" would not have been so dominant if the setting was not in a monastery. Being chaste is an issue well beyond monastic life, but because these people vowed before god to maintain celibate, the consequences seemed more severe. Their hypocrisy did not cause them to gain spiritually, but only physically, which took away from the center of monastic life.
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeletePersonally, I believe that King Henry VIII’s demolition and dissolution of these monasteries were motivated by his religious ideologies and beliefs as opposed to his greed or any possibility of obtaining any kind of monetary value. I believe this is true primarily because of the type of society that he lived in during his time period. During Henry VIII’s reign (and most of England’s history) England was notorious for its religious intolerance. Today, this behavior would be frowned upon but in a time period where religious intolerance was very uncommon I can’t imagine that it was really that big of a deal. Furthermore, due to the fact that Henry VIII was king at the time it would be hard to imagine that he would not also try to establish himself as the (earthly) religious leader as well as many kings before (and after) him had.
It is interesting that most of the royal actions during this time period were secretly based on the pursuit of total power. We repeatedly encountered themes of propaganda in our readings, and this event doesn't seem like an exception. Beneath the layer of religious efforts, perhaps the reason why King Henry demolished monasteries was based on his desire for more power. If you think about it, essentially, demolishing the religious buildings to suit his religious preference would mean that his presence would go beyond that of religion, since religion was an immense part of daily living during the time period. On top of his personal problems regarding a divorce, the dissolution was indeed geared toward recognition of King Henry's authority, as Bernard claims. Although Bernard concludes that King Henry's action wasn't ultimately led by his desire for power, I'm still doubtful of whether it is really the case. It seems that there is always something hidden behind political actions...whether they happen during the Medieval Era or the 21st century.
ReplyDeleteyeah!
DeleteWhile we will likely never know the true motivation behind Henry VIII's demolition of monasteries, I believe that is was most likely equal parts monetary gain and a means to assert his religious authority. I feel as though greed and power are two equal forces in human nature, and it is difficult for anyone to resist them when they're faced with an opportunity such as the one Henry VIII was faced with. Although, I would have to agree with Bernard in some ways because if King Henry VIII had not been denied a divorce by the catholic religious leaders, he probably would never had asserted his religious authority over the country in the first place. His anger at the religion in general was the fuel for his actions, and it is likely that he wanted to ensure that no one could practice the religion at all. The money was a happy side effect that probably was an equal deciding factor in the idea to tear down religious structures.
ReplyDeleteI agree in that I think the fact that King Henry was the denied by the church probably made him feel as though revenge was the only way to regain his manhood or to reestablish his sense of power. In his mind this could only be down by shutting down those who had essentially wronged him by not being on his side. The fact that there was loot, gold, and relics that was gathered was only a major plus. Essentially, whether or not the there was treasure really did not matter.
DeleteThis was quite an interesting read, as well as eye-opening. I knew that Henry VIII wanted to split from the Catholic church because he wanted a religious tradition that would allow him to divorce since none of his wives seemed to be able to produce a son for him, but it makes it that much worse because he was also stealing valuables. Of course, his destruction of many of the monasteries was to show all of his subjects that he was mightier than the church and that they were there at his disposal, but it he was trying to remain a religious figure, destroying houses of worship was probably not the best route to choose. Those that were religiously pious would lose faith in him as a leader since he was clearly using religion at his own selfish advantage.
ReplyDelete