Sunday, September 8, 2013

The Pardoner's Tale: What about preaching?


The attributes given to the Pardoner can be found in multiple preachers during medieval times, but these attributes are presented in a different way. For example, the pardoner sells relics while on his travel, which can be attributed to many preachers during this time. He also preaches to them, but does it through stories. In describing the Pardoner and telling his tale, Chaucer is, in a way, bringing a realization about medieval preachers through thier actions and preachings.
Though preachers are saying the relics they are selling are blessed by saints, they can be regular objects one may find in their home. The pardoner states, "By this gaude have I wonne yeer by yeer an hundred mark sith I was pardoner. I stonde lyk a clerk in my pulpet, and wan the lewed peple is doun yset, I preche so as ye han herd bifoore and telle an hundred false japes moore" (Chaucer 101-106). The pardoner has become a wealthy man because he has been selling false relics. He pokes fun at the individuals he sells to, as well. Once he has drained the "lewed peple" out of their money, he tells them stories of his tricks and possibly gain more from them. A reason for this act to be attributable to other medieval preachers can be due to the people being religious. Knowing that the dry bone or glove they have received promises good health or a possibility of going to heaven makes selling the false relics easy.
The pardoner shares the common preaching styles of preachers of the Middle Ages, as well. Siegfried Wenzel writes, "Late-medieval preachers were required to preach with regular frequency basic catechetical pieces of church doctrine...which included the Creed, the Ten Commandments, the seven deadly sins, and others" (xi). The Pardoner seems to be preaching about the deadly sins; some of which, like greed, he commits often. One can argue that the Pardoner's tale is a sermon. The "sermon" touch base on the consequences of committing some of the deadly sins. For example, due to thier wrath, they set out to kill Deeth. In doing so, they come across some gold. Their greed ends up becoming the best of them and they kill each other trying to become rich. A story like this shows that nothing good will come out of being greedy, which relates back to the Pardoner's earlier statement, "radix malorum est cupiditas" (Chaucer 46); greed is the root of evil.
The pardoner does fail to practice what he preaches. He preaches that one should not be greedy, but he suffers from greed. St. Gregory has been quoted saying, "No one does more harm in the Church than he who, having taken the title or rank of holiness, acts evilly" (Minnis 41). The Pardoner is guilty of acting "evilly". He waves his credentials in order to protect himself from harm and also to cheat people out of their money.
The role of the preacher is known to be important to the medieval people. Though they were important figures, preachers had their flaws, many of which are seen through Chaucer's "The Pardoner's Prologue and Tale". The selling of relics have been a commonality amongst clergymen. The relics have been said to provide good health and insure safe pasture into heaven. Preachers also shared common traits through their sermons as well. They preach about the Ten Commandments, the seven deadly sins, and many other biblical topics.


Works Cited

Chaucer, Geoffrey. "The Pardoner's Prologue and Tale". The Broadway Anthology of British Literature: Volume 1: the Medieval Period. Eds. Black, Joseph, Conolly, Leonard, Flint, Kate, Grundy, Isobel, LePan, Don, Luizza, Roy, McGann, Jerome J., Prescott, Anne Lake, Qualls, Barry V., and Waters, Claire. Ontario: Broadview Press, 2009. 518-530. Print.
Minnis, Alastair J. Fallible Authors. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2008. Print.
Wenzel, Siegfried. Preaching in the Age of Chaucer: Selected Sermons in Translation. Washington, DC: the Catholic University of American Press, 2008. Print.

6 comments:

  1. Dr. Raschcko asked us to consider whether or not an immoral person (The Pardoner) could tell a moral tale. Reading your essay or blog post immediately reminded me of that. Because God recognizes that humans cannot go through life without fault, he knows even the 'teachers' and 'leaders' of the community will deviate from his laws, yet he still uses them as vessels to deliver his message to people searching for faith and salvation. The Pardoner can tell a moral tale because he not only familiarized himself with the lessons and words of the bible, but he also directly defied them, understanding his defiance. Someone who can not only give example of something, but also give an example of its direct opposite has a deep understanding of that thing. Therefore, The Pardoner may have saved plenty of souls in his day.

    ReplyDelete
  2. It is interesting that you said the pardoner shared a preaching style with many preachers during the Middle Ages. This also makes me question if many preachers during this time used the immoral practices that the pardoner did as well. They would give "fire and brimstone" sermons, since many people feared going to hell or being stuck in purgatory, and the idea that the preachers could pull at their purses in this way is awful. Of course, the pardoner is not one to decide whether people are holy or not or even forgiven by God because he himself is by no means holy. I agree when you said he is guilty of acting "evilly" because he was promising these people false hope by letting them worship false relics that he created himself, but he is also a sneaky businessman in how he said only holy people could come to his relics and have him forgive them, because no one wants to tell on themselves for being unholy.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Throughout The Canterbury Tales, Chaucer seems to depict the characters in a negative way based on their profession. The pardoner is yet another character that Chaucer shows how he is doing the complete opposite of what he is suppose to be doing. The pardoner sells people fake relics in order to get monetary gain. He thrives off of peoples ignorance and religious ways. The pardoner is a liar, thief, false-preacher, and just an all around not good person. I feel like making the characters seem like "bad people" and showing that their not perfect like they're suppose to be, makes it easier for the reader to relate to and also makes for a better story.

    ReplyDelete
  4. It's easy to get caught up in the idea of getting rich and allowing that to corrupt our moral values, the pardoner is a very fine example of this. The pardoner was obviously versed well enough with the teaching's of the bible to convince others that he was a credible source, so his type of sin is, in my opinion, a particularly bad one. It is one thing to commit a sin in ignorance, but another to take advantage of people who have less knowledge than you do. Reading this blog post and taking into consideration what was said in regards to other preacher's of this time period, I wonder just how prominent this sort of corruption was within the church, and how this relates to today's religious practices. Is this sort of corruption still just as prominent today? And does it exist in the same forms? I'm not sure that people of today would fall victim to the selling of relics that was going on during this time period, but I do wonder what the counterpart is in today's society.

    ReplyDelete
  5. The Pardoner's tale is satirically hippocratic because he preaches a message and then acts in the opposite way. This being said, i agree with Ninti in that an immoral person can still portray a moral, helpful story. The Pardoner is keenly familiar with the sin of greed. He knows the ins and outs of it, and although he act in a way that is immoral, he knows exactly how to act moral. His story warns against the dangers that greed can present. He understands that greed, although he is greedy, is a bad (or religiously unsafe) trait to carry. Maybe he warns against it because he does not want people's life's to end up like his....sinful, hollow, and unrewarding

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think that there is enough inherent morality in the laws governing society that one could fabricate a moral tale. One is socialized into the surroundings he or she is born into, and thus expected to know and reciprocate the actions of the greater majority. Since the Pardoner is a member of the Catholic clergy, it is safe to assume that he has been surrounded by others that practice truthfully and honestly. Though he has seen what it takes to correctly serve, he chooses to abuse the legitimacy of his office by selling rights to his "relics". Thus, we can clearly see that morality is not the equivalence of one's true nature, but can still be displayed.

    ReplyDelete