Sovereignty in the Wife of Bath's Tale
In the 18th century, sovereignty meant "territory under the rule of a sovereign, or existing as an independent state..." or "...supreme controlling power in communities not under monarchical government, absolute and independent authority" (Thomas 89). In contrast to this, the American definition is "complete independence and self-government" (Thomas 89). The argument made in this article is that while the knight took advantage of the wyf by having his way with her, she ended up with the sovereignty in the relationship, but what exactly does that sovereignty entail? Also, why does she get this power over him when he can clearly overtake her?
In her tale, the Wife of Bath is attempting to show that women were not as helpless and dependent on men as thought at the time. The wyf in the story is raped by the knight, but she takes him to court, where he has to marry her in order to keep his own life for the crime committed. The knight is also pictured as not knowing what he wants. He is given the choice, by the wyf, between whether he preferred obedience or beauty in women, but he could not choose. These are clearly not the only two options for characteristics in a woman, but they are the main characteristics that would be sought by a character such as the knight, and the wyf knows this. Him not even being able to decide between these two aspects shows the low view he has of women in the first place, since he sees them as equal traits. If women were valued as intellectual beings, those would not be the only choices, but the wyf is aware of the knight's mental processes, or lack thereof. As shown by him even raping her in the first place, "he has been under the control of his desires from the beginning, and thus he never attains knowledge or power" (Thomas 94). Contrarily, "as a shapeshifter, the wyf represents the ultimate fantasy of power over one's own body" (Thomas 95).
In addition to the idea of women having more power than thought, other issues addressed are those of the court of law. The wyf took the knight to court for raping her, and then she was allowed to decide his fate. During this period of time, it was not rare for the citizens of a community to take the law into their own hands. Stories and literature were produced during this time, such as Robin Hood and the Tale of Gamelyn, which talk about vigilantes. "Both literary types look to the crown for provision of just laws; but one type thinks that in hard times the crown needs some good local men to jump-start the system with violent self-help" (Cambridge 100). The wyf did not take the violence into her own hands towards the knight, but she now has control over him and his desires since they are now married, and this is seen as a form of justice for what he did to her. If he was so stupid as to take out his desires on her, those of which he did not even have a mental control over, then now she is in a position where she can tell him what to do with those desires since she is his sovereign and does know how to control her own desires. Thomas says, "the knight's redemption from poverte, or lack of worth, may be illusory" (Thomas 95). He may not have been killed by the law, but now someone else is sovereign over him, and there is nothing he can do other than accept it. Meanwhile, the wyf is fully aware of this, and finds it amusing: "Her apparent desire for the knight is part of the joke, making the 'bath of blisse' when he feels desire for her, not the knight's reward, but the moment when he becomes locked into an ever more abject relationship to the wyf" (Thomas 95).
Work Cited:
Thomas, Susanne Sara. "The Problem Of Defining "Sovereynetee" In The "Wife Of Bath's Tale.." Chaucer Review 41.1 (2006): 87-97. Academic Search Complete. Web. 13 Sept. 2013.
In addition to the idea of women having more power than thought, other issues addressed are those of the court of law. The wyf took the knight to court for raping her, and then she was allowed to decide his fate. During this period of time, it was not rare for the citizens of a community to take the law into their own hands. Stories and literature were produced during this time, such as Robin Hood and the Tale of Gamelyn, which talk about vigilantes. "Both literary types look to the crown for provision of just laws; but one type thinks that in hard times the crown needs some good local men to jump-start the system with violent self-help" (Cambridge 100). The wyf did not take the violence into her own hands towards the knight, but she now has control over him and his desires since they are now married, and this is seen as a form of justice for what he did to her. If he was so stupid as to take out his desires on her, those of which he did not even have a mental control over, then now she is in a position where she can tell him what to do with those desires since she is his sovereign and does know how to control her own desires. Thomas says, "the knight's redemption from poverte, or lack of worth, may be illusory" (Thomas 95). He may not have been killed by the law, but now someone else is sovereign over him, and there is nothing he can do other than accept it. Meanwhile, the wyf is fully aware of this, and finds it amusing: "Her apparent desire for the knight is part of the joke, making the 'bath of blisse' when he feels desire for her, not the knight's reward, but the moment when he becomes locked into an ever more abject relationship to the wyf" (Thomas 95).
Work Cited:
Thomas, Susanne Sara. "The Problem Of Defining "Sovereynetee" In The "Wife Of Bath's Tale.." Chaucer Review 41.1 (2006): 87-97. Academic Search Complete. Web. 13 Sept. 2013.
Galloway, Andrew. The Cambridge Companion to Medieval English Culture. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2011. Print.
I personally enjoyed reading the Wife of Bath's Prologue. It was entertaining in that the Wife spoke so openly about all her partners and had a very strange way of justifying her "scandalous" behavior. She referenced God many times in the Prologue in discussion of sex and marriage. Her reasons for her actions are very well explained and backed up by referencing powerful characters in the Bible such as Abraham, Lameth, and Jacob. I feel as though the way she excuses her actions is somewhat blaspheme because she is almost twisting or changing God's words in order to excuse the actions that others would consider unacceptable during that time and even in today's society. While I found her ways of reasoning harsh and at times inappropriate, she definitely makes valid points in her beliefs on how women should and should not act in regards to sex and marriage.
ReplyDeleteIt is interesting that Chaucer choose to develop a character such as the Wife of Bath to such extent. Her prologue is very long and contains a lot of details about her life which to an extent applies to the role of women in medieval society. Furthermore, as Lizzie noted the Wife of Bath's narrative is design to defend her character and show that women were integral members of medieval society. We see a character who has a purpose and role in society not like other women of this era who had to conform.
ReplyDeleteAs all of us may know, women in Chaucer's era has little to no power in medieval society. Women were expected to be a housewife and have little said in the marriage because the husband are the decision maker. However, in Chaucer's tale, the Wife of Bath possessed a subtle power that is considered rare for that time period. She has been through five marriages. The Wife of Bath has forced her rapist to become her husband,emphasizing that she now of the decision over the rapist's fate and is the temporary dominant in their relationship, as mentioned by Lizzy. The Wife of Bath's power to force someone into marriage has somewhat extended the role women in medieval society.
ReplyDeleteI think the definitions at the beginning of this blog post pose an interesting question about the Wife of Bath. In promoting sovereignty for women, is she promoting the idea that women should get to rule others or just the idea that they should get to rule themselves? At the end of the prologue, she suggested that her husband "yaf me al the bridel in myn hond / To han the governance of hous and lond" (813-814). In that scenario, then, she claims to have the sovereignty in a wider sense than just self-governance.
ReplyDeleteAlso, I find the idea of shape-shifting being a form of ultimate control over one's body really fascinating.
Although the Wife of Bath is totally promoting the idea that women should get to rule over others, I honestly think that overall the right to govern oneself is more than enough power to hold at a time. I say this because I am thinking about present day predicaments, such as the right to govern over your own reproducing organs, the right to marry whoever you choose, the right to choose your own career and etc. All of these rights come with so much responsibility and hardships that I feel wanting control over others/men is vengeful and greedy. However, from the Wife of Bath's point of view, she sees men as power abusers who only look at woman as portraits of beauty and sculptures that can be manipulated for sex. They believe women can never hold dominance over them because a woman's purpose in life is to be strictly determined by a male. It is evident that when given the opportunity to switch roles with the knight, the Wife of Bath immediately turns the table with the intentions to receive justice for the heinous crime committed.
ReplyDeleteThe tale of the Wyf of Bath was definitely a display of the power struggle between men and women. Although the Knight did not receive a fair punishment for rape and essentially was rewarded in the end, I believe the tale display a woman's attempt at rehabilitation versus the male system of rehabilitation at the time. While the justice system is supposed to correct illegal activities, it often does not manage to transform the criminal; however, the women in the Wyf's tale managed to teach the man a lesson and rehabilitate him. By taking away the man's power over his life and subjecting him to the power of women, he learned to respect and listen to the wisdom of women. Essentially, he may have not been punished, but he was rehabilitated.
ReplyDeleteThe Wife of Bath's Tale provided an interesting view of the power dynamic between men and women during the medieval time period. It's interesting to me that Chaucer could write something so clearly beyond his time period. Sovereignty for women is likely something that wasn't even considered by most men of the time period, so for him to be able to write about a woman who had sovereignty over a man is very interesting. I don't remember whether we touched on this in class, but I wonder how well received the Wife of Bath's Tale was during the time period that it was written.
ReplyDeleteThis post is very interesting to me because it is written by an author who is writing against the misguided gender norms of the times. Furthermore, what makes it even more interesting is that it was authored by a male writer. This text shows that (some) people were aware of the negative stereotypes and misguided ideas about women at the time. Furthermore, this text also showed that (some) people cared enough to attempt to awaken their audiences and peers to the corrupt ideologies of the time.
ReplyDelete