It is described as "the enterprise of searching for greater goods that might plausibly justify God’s permission of evil"(Trekakis 1). Russell M. Hillier argues John Milton's particular take on theodicy in his article: THE PATIENCE TO PREVENT THAT MURMUR: THE THEODICY OF JOHN MILTON'S NINETEENTH SONNET.
While many have, and even more still, question how God can be good or even exist when there is so much evil present in the world, Milton holds that one must be patient; that human works, good or bad, are not nearly as important as man's faith in God's ability to redeem (Hillier 2). Milton's theodicy revolved largely around God's ability to use evil for good, a theme that is prevalent in Paradise Lost (Hillier 8-13).
In Milton's Nineteenth Sonnet, the speaker reflects on his many struggles and questions why his life should continue. His struggle to understand God's purpose for his misfortune stems from how he seeks to understand God. He tries, and ultimately fails, to fit God into his own mortal way of understanding. His disregard of the unfathomable divinity of God results in an unattractive picture of God (Hillier 6). The speakers doubts no doubt reflect the ones Milton had at the time. As he was suffering from blindness that he doubted he would ever recover from, Milton surely questioned God's fairness (Hillier 6).
However, over time, Milton came to view his blindness in a new light. Many of his more critical contemporaries asserted that his blindness was a form of divine retribution; they argued that God was punishing him for what they perceived as being sins (Hillier 8). Milton held that the exact opposite was true. He believed that it is his blindness that allowed him to see God clearly when most other men could not. In fact, "Milton practically makes debilitation requisite to receiving a pure interior vision of God" (Hillier 8). He cites 2 Corinthians as proof of his assertion:
[The Lord! said to me, my grace is sufficient for you, for strength
i.s made perfect in weakness. Therefore, instead I will boast most
gladly about my weaknesses, that the strength of Christ might pro-
vide shelter [lit. a "tent" or a "tabernacle"l over me. Because of
this 1 revel in weaknesses, in insults, in hardships, in persecutions
and troubles, all for Christ's sake. For when I am weak, then I am
strong. (2 Cor. 12:9-10)"
Milton's theodicy caries over into Paradise Lost. While God allows Satan to succeed in bringing about The Fall, He uses Adam and Eve's sin to showcase His goodness. It gives Him an opportunity to display his mercy and love towards man (Hillier 14). While God encourages man to do right, He gives him the choice to do wrong, because even then God is able to turn it to something that glorifies Him.
Milton's belief in God's providence defines much of his later work. Knowing that there is a reason for God's allowance of evil is vital; it is what gives us the patience necessary to refrain from questioning God's goodness before His reasons become clear (Hillier 21).
-
Works Cited
-
Hillier, Russell M. "The Patience To Prevent That Murmur: The Theodicy Of John Milton's Nineteenth Sonnet." Renascence 59.4 (2007): 247-274. Literary Reference Center. Web. 8 Nov. 2013.
Trakakis, Nick. "Theodicy: The Solution to the Problem of Evil, or Part of the Problem?" Springer.com. Springer Science, 29 July 2008. Web.

