Friday, November 8, 2013

Milton: Theodicy

       The concept of theodicy is still used even today. 
It is described as "the enterprise of searching for greater goods that might plausibly justify God’s permission of evil"(Trekakis 1). Russell M. Hillier argues John Milton's particular take on theodicy in his article: THE PATIENCE TO PREVENT THAT MURMUR: THE THEODICY OF JOHN MILTON'S NINETEENTH SONNET. 

       While many have, and even more still, question how God can be good or even exist when there is so much evil present in the world, Milton holds that one must be patient; that human works, good or bad, are not nearly as important as man's faith in God's ability to redeem (Hillier 2). Milton's theodicy revolved largely around God's ability to use evil for good, a theme that is prevalent in Paradise Lost (Hillier 8-13).

         
       In Milton's Nineteenth Sonnet, the speaker reflects on his many struggles and questions why his life should continue. His struggle to understand God's purpose for his misfortune stems from how he seeks to understand God. He tries, and ultimately fails, to fit God into his own mortal way of understanding. His disregard of the unfathomable divinity of God results in an unattractive picture of God (Hillier 6). The speakers doubts no doubt reflect the ones Milton had at the time. As he was suffering from blindness that he doubted he would ever recover from, Milton surely questioned God's fairness (Hillier 6).

       However, over time, Milton came to view his blindness in a new light. Many of his more critical contemporaries asserted that his blindness was a form of divine retribution; they argued that God was punishing him for what they perceived as being sins (Hillier 8). Milton held that the exact opposite was true. He believed that it is his blindness that allowed him to see God clearly when most other men could not. In fact, "Milton practically makes debilitation requisite to receiving a pure interior vision of God" (Hillier 8). He cites 2 Corinthians as proof of his assertion:



[The Lord! said to me, my grace is sufficient for you, for strength i.s made perfect in weakness. Therefore, instead I will boast most gladly about my weaknesses, that the strength of Christ might pro- vide shelter [lit. a "tent" or a "tabernacle"l over me. Because of this 1 revel in weaknesses, in insults, in hardships, in persecutions and troubles, all for Christ's sake. For when I am weak, then I am strong. (2 Cor. 12:9-10)" 


       Milton's theodicy caries over into Paradise Lost. While God allows Satan to succeed in bringing about The Fall, He uses Adam and Eve's sin to showcase His goodness. It gives Him an opportunity to display his mercy and love towards man (Hillier 14). While God encourages man to do right, He gives him the choice to do wrong, because even then God is able to turn it to something that glorifies Him.


       Milton's belief in God's providence defines much of his later work. Knowing that there is a reason for God's allowance of evil is vital; it is what gives us the patience necessary to refrain from questioning God's goodness before His reasons become clear (Hillier 21).


-
Works Cited
-

Hillier, Russell M. "The Patience To Prevent That Murmur: The Theodicy Of John Milton's Nineteenth Sonnet." Renascence 59.4 (2007): 247-274. Literary Reference Center. Web. 8 Nov. 2013.

Trakakis, Nick. "Theodicy: The Solution to the Problem of Evil, or Part of the Problem?" Springer.com. Springer Science, 29 July 2008. Web.

Wednesday, November 6, 2013

Areopagitica: Milton and Censorship

Censorship in England has been an ongoing issue throughout history in which both government and religion made attempts to control the ideas present within the country.  The issue became much more pressing, however, with the invention of the printing press.  With the printing press, there was a significant growth in the numbers available to the public.  And with that rise in availability, came a rise of literacy among the people.  During Henry VIII’s rein, there was a proclamation made against any texts that went against the Catholic religion (182).  With religious reformation taking place all over Europe, by 1538 books authors needed a license before being publishing works, especially texts regarding scripture (182).  By Elizabeth’s rein, the need for licenses were maintained and was limited to London and only two universities (183).  The use of licenses was maintained after Elizabeth’s rein under Charles.  Parliament eventually passed the Licensing Act that required an inspection of the actual texts before being published.  Despite the limitation presented by the need for licenses, people were still able to print and distribute pamphlets (183).  Milton ultimately distributed his Areopagitica as a pamphlet.

In response to the Licensing Act, Milton wrote Areopagitica.  Milton was against the idea of censoring a work before it has been published.  He believed that by preventing books from being created, Parliament would be discouraging education and reason.  He argued that even if books containing negative thoughts or ideas were not published, it would not necessarily prevent the common-people for hearing about those ideas through spoken word.  By allowing the press to have freedom, knowledge and reason too would have freedom to expand within society.  He argues that even the negative ideas would encourage greater reason among the people.  Despite his arguments, Parliament ignored Milton’s pleas.  However, the Licensing Act was did not get renewed in 1695 (183).


In his article, "Gathering the Scattered Body of Milton's Areopagitica", James Rovira argues against critics who have claimed Milton was not an advocate of free press.  Rovira states that critics who make such claims do so because shorly after writing and distributing Areopagitica, “Milton himself served as state censor…a move that makes plausible the idea that Milton wasn't so much concemed for freedom of speech in general, but for freedom of speech for himself” (87).  In his argument, Rovira emphasizes the importance of historical context, particularly in the field of philosophical reasoning.
In the Areopagitica, Milton displays humanist ideals of the time, he “associates reason with immortality, the human intellect, the image of God, and the content of books…[and that] reason is what humanity has in common with the gods” (89).  He elevates the human capacity for reason to a level of divinity.  This form of divinity, to Milton, is expressed through language, and books are repositories of reason
because they are made up of language” (90).

Although Milton does argue against censorship, he does argue its elimination completely.  Rather, “Milton elevates writers and their product to almost divine status in order to persuade Parliament to exercise less control over printed material”  (91).  Milton argues against Parliament’s claims about bad books by stating “books should not be suppressed because they can work against evil without significantly contributing to it. Both "good" and "bad" books can serve evil ends in a lustful heart, and a society without books would still find plenty of opportunity for evil” (94).  Rovira wants to emphasize Milton’s belief that books themselves do not cause degradation in societal morals and beliefs.  But rather, the very things that Parliament wants to bar form society are already very prevalent within society.

In 1643, “the publishing of any book was forbidden without prior review and licensing” (99).  Milton calls for going back to a different form of control over printed works that required only the name and consent of the author before printing.  However, this argument did not prevent Parliament from censoring after it is published.  In regards to licenses, Rovira states that Milton argues “that licensing will only remove the objects of lust, not lust from the human heart” (93).  By referring to books as objects of lust, Milton is arguing that books do not inherently have the ability to implant any form of sin or degradation within a human being that isn’t already in existence.

Rovira argues that despite Milton’s participation in censoring works, he was still an advocate of free press.  He states that Milton’s “immediate goal still appear[ed] to be at least a relatively free flow of  ideas through the vehicle of a free press (97).

Works Cited
Cannon, John Ashton. The Oxford Companion to British History. Oxford, England: Oxford UP, 1997. 182-83. Print.
Rovira, James. "Gathering The Scattered Body Of Milton's Areopagitica." Renascence 57.2 (2005): 87-102. Literary Reference Center.

Friday, November 1, 2013

John Donne: from Catholicsm to Protestanism

          John Donne was born into a devote family of Roman Catholics as his mom was Catholic, his father who was believed to practice Protestantism in private, two of Donne's uncles were Jesuit priests and his brother Henry who was incarcerated for his devotion (Warnke 3). Donne attended Oxford where he began his studies in 1854, but was also believed to have studied at Cambridge, because at Oxford he was unable to obtain a degree due to his Catholic faith as an impediment (3). Donne's period of religious discourse began at Lincoln's Inn in the early 1590s where he was determined to study law. This transition was a slow and conscientious adaptation from his religious restrictions to a more "freethinking position" (3). Due to his scholarly background, the only way to determine the true reasons for the opposition towards Protestantism was through in-depth theology research. Donne felt as though this was the only way in which he could unravel the truth. Donne spent most of his life gathering knowledge of the opposing faiths in attempt to make his own decision of allegiance instead of being forced and sheltered from the truth. He wanted to discover for himself which form of Christianity was the right one as stated by John Stubbs (5). Donne set out to learn law in its entirety and ended up unable to resist the appeal of divinity in 1593 (5). He relentlessly became preoccupied with personal studies that were suppose to help him come to a substantial conclusion from his own merits. Donne stated,'til I had, to the measure of my poore wit and judgement, suruayed and digested the whole body of Diuinity,' he was never to give up this religious mission (5). During this era, this type of determination was not appalling as Queen Elizabeth was excommunicated, damned, and rejected, loyalties were being re-evaluated within the church (8). This relates back to Donne's disrupted learning at Oxford which was caused by the "obliged oath of loyalty to the Reformed, Protestant Church, and to the Queen as the head of that Church" (8). Donne and his brother was no longer allowed to attend Oxford as instructed by their parents who disallowed any opportunity for conversion to the Protestant faith. The result on this conquest was the conversion from Catholic to Protestant. Donne ended his life as an ordained priest of the church of England in 1615 where he delivered his first sermon and was also appointed royal chaplain in the same year. This was a grave contrast from Donne's early years where he was the young man from a distinct Catholic lineage into the dedicated Protestant clergyman.
 
        In "John Donne and the Art of Adaptation," Cothran argues that Donne did not simply convert, but that essentially he learn to adapt (91). Cothran begins her argument with two contrasting images of Donne, one as a young male who has a strong Catholic origin in which he flaunts, while the other is him as an elder that is deeply respected as the Dean of St. Paul's Cathedral in London. She is reluctant to use the word conform to explain this transition because she believes Donne mindfully decided to seek an understanding of the reality of Catholicism in comparison to that of Protestantism. Cothran states that both religions are evident in the works of Donne, more specifically his poems (91). Her reason behind specifically implementing the word adaptation is that Donne was guided by his own conscious to explore the world of Protestantism and that this was accomplished through concentrating on his poetry. It was the time period of his upbringing that greatly influenced this exploration as there was a plethora of religious transitions. The stability of the Catholic church was dwindling causing for wide speculation and uncertainty among the English. Considering "Elizabethans often attempted to find way to deal with their religious situations" it was only natural for Donne to make a path of his own in order to deal with his religious doubt (90). One can ask to which is the allegiance true and Cothran's answer would be that it is evident in Donne's poetry that the process in which he adapted resulted in the combination of old and new habits that involved Catholic beliefs and practices with Protestant expression (89). 


Warnke, Frank J. John Donne. Boston: Twayne Publishers, 1987. Print.

Stubbs, John. John Donne: The Reformed Soul. New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 2006 . Print

Cothran, Anne Faulkner. "John Donne And The Art Of Adaptation." Anglican Theological Review 87.1 (2005): 89-115. Academic Search Complete. Web. 31 Oct. 2013.

Monday, October 28, 2013

She and Him: Gender Politics in Shakespeare’s Sonnets


To understand the significance of the gender-bending present in the Elizabethan Era, it is important to first know how it differed from the Tudor Era.   
“Along with birth, age, and wealth,” Capp states, “gender was one of the key criteria that defined the social position and role of every individual in Tudor society” (286). The inferiority of women was a notion that held religious backing, with preachers and magistrates citing Eve’s role in The Fall as evidence that women were easily tempted and necessitated the presence of a husband to instill “obedience” (286). The medical field, unfortunately, did nothing to counteract these sexist notions. In fact, Tudor science held the Galen belief that the typical balance of the four humors in women “rendered them more emotional and volatile than men” (286). “Both men and women [additionally] defined female ‘honesty’ and reputation almost wholly in terms of sexual behavior, whereas a man’s good name rested on a much wider range of attributes, and sexual lapses were often seen as unimportant” (287). 

 
However, with the rise of Elizabethan England, this established philosophy of gender came into question. “The potential fluidity of gender” was first illustrated in the theater, where young boys often dressed as female characters (Capp 287).  However, this concept of cross-dressing extended beyond the borders of the playhouse and eventually into everyday life. Women were experimenting with gender identity, a fashion at that time, which also resulted in a significant number of women prosecuted by the courts for dressing as men (287). “Genuine unease” concerning gender identity reverberated throughout Elizabethan England, and became known as “a crisis in gender relations” (287). But it wasn’t the act of dressing as the opposing gender that was causing concern; rather, the idea that women could have equal power as their male counterparts, or even surpass them in matters of intelligence or authority in the household, was incredibly threatening (287).
This debate then made its way into the pages of books and theater stages, which approached the topic with comedy. While these artworks do bring the debate into the forefront, they still “reinforce traditional norms” that were being challenged at the time (Capp 287). “Insubordination,” Capp continues, “was frequently linked with sexual fears, for it was widely assumed that a domineering wife would be sexually unfaithful.” And the consequences for women, even if convicted under mere suspicions, were undoubtedly heinous: “[I]f found guilty, [she] faced a humiliating public penance in which she would have to beg forgiveness, dressed in a white sheet, before the entire congregation... Other women who behaved inappropriately… might be… punished by being ducked or placed in stocks (287).
Shakespeare was one of those artists who addressed the fluidity of gender with his sonnets. Rather than offering a comedic commentary to the gender debate, it is argued that he is actually parodying the sonnet form itself, thus making more of a statement about gender instead of mocking it.

In “Making the Woman of Him: Shakespeare’s Man Right Fair as Sonnet Lady,” author M.L. Stapleton asserts that the Bard was mocking the sonnet form, rather than revealing a closeted bisexuality. Because of the lavish language and overt-feminine aspects of the male admired, this indicates parody on Shakespeare’s part.
The Man Right Fair is the moniker of the man the speaker (aptly named “Will”) addresses in his sonnets. The gender of Will’s subject alone “is a parody of the sonnet lady,” mocking the ethereal women of the sonnets before Shakespeare’s time (Stapleton 273). In the sonnet tradition, the standard form involves a male speaker with a female object. In Shakespeare’s time, the Petrarchism and anti-Petrarchism had gone out of fashion and satirical sonnets were now becoming the established norm (276).  Thus, “Shakespeare’s decision to define the subjectivity of a masculine addressee with ‘feminizing language,’” Stapleton states, “represents a truly original, subversive, and amusing attack on sonnet traditions,” and does not make Stapleton’s argument of parody seem out of the ordinary for other authors were writing satirical sonnets as well (276). Stapleton also claims that because this is not the first instance of parody in Shakespeare’s career, it is also not outlandish to claim that a man famous for his puns and forms of high-brow humor would continue this form in his poetic works (276).
            “As a means of parodying the genre,” Stapleton writes, “Shakespeare needed to establish the femininity of the Man Right Fair in the manner of his contemporaries toward their feminine subjects” (276). One of the ways in which Shakespeare accomplishes this is through the overtly feminine characterization of the Man Right Fair.  Shakespeare does this through his particular word choice, using terms such as “sweet,” “fair,” “lovely,” and “beautiful,” all of which are terms traditionally used to designate a female love. However, the Bard takes this one step further with terminology like “thou,” “thine,” and “thee,” which are terms men would only use in descriptions of women and never to delineate another man (277). This “hyperfemininity” Stapleton refers to was important for the poet to clarify his work as an art of humor as opposed to one of seriousness (278). Shakespeare needed to make his satire readily apparent because “there…was no recognizable precedent for a masculine addressee to be utilized as a tool for the satire of sonnet conventions…” (278-279).
Shakespeare’s satire also addresses “the voicelessness of the female subject in Renaissance poetry perpetuated by the oppressive male creator” (Stapleton 282).  In his sonnets, Shakespeare attributes this to the constant rambling of these afflicted men. Essentially, women are voiceless or passive in traditional sonnets simply because the admiring male will not give his ramblings a rest (283). Perhaps she would be more vocal if she was given a chance to speak.    
As a result, Shakespeare’s sonnets provide interesting commentary in an era where gender appeared to not be as concrete as once thought. While he may have been mocking the sonnet form, his notions on gender seem to be challenging the established norm.



  
Works Cited
Capp, Barnard S. “Gender.” Tudor England: An Encyclopedia. Ed. Arthur F. Kinney and David W. Swain. New York: Garland, 2001. 286-88. Print.
Stapleton, M. L. “Making the Woman of Him: Shakespeare's Man Right Fair as Sonnet Lady.” Texas Studies in Literature and Language 46.3 (2004): 271-95. Academic Search Complete. Web. 27 Oct. 2013. <http://web.ebscohost.com.proxy-s.mercer.edu/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?sid=e4c82a94-915a-42a2-b000-7a801f63acff%40sessionmgr110&vid=4&hid=121>.


Thursday, October 24, 2013

Humanism and its Influence on England




            Shortly after the death of Chaucer, English writers began to imitate and exalt his style in order to make their writing profitable. However, many writers started having difficulties finding patronage due to the similarity in the writing styles of many authors. To make writing more profitable, English writers began adoption the style of writing of Humanists. Humanists were predominately Italian immigrants who went to England, during the fifteenth century, in order to make a profit out of their writing. The Humanists were drawn to England, because the Italian citizens of this time thought of the English as being gullible and rich. This perception influenced the decision of many Italian writers to move to England in order to make a living from their talents. In Italy the market for Humanists writers had been saturated, and there was much political mayhem which forced trained Italian writers to move to other locations. At first Italian Humanists moved north of the Italian Alps, however, demographic pressures forced them to seek their fortune in other parts of the European continent.
            What Humanists brought to England was a new form of sonnet with interesting structural properties. For example, conventional topics addressed by older styles of sonnet, such as clever innuendos were expanded to more complex forms of expression in the Humanist sonnet. Moreover, the topics addressed in the Humanist Sonnet were tangled with religious, philosophical, political, and many other controversial and thought provoking ideas of the fifteenth and sixteenth century.  As stated by William J. Kennedy, in The Cambridge Companion to The Sonnet:
During these years, the conventional topics addressed by the sonnet from expanded from guileful entreaties of sexual seduction to more complex expressions of tangled erotic yearning, tumultuous sexual impulse and exalted amatory devotion, in associated ways laden with statements of religious conversion, philosophical conviction, political sentiment and even scientific insight. (Kennedy 84)
Therefore, many writers were drawn to his form of sonnet because of the many possibilities of topics and expression.
            One of the most influential Humanists in England was Francesco Petrarca. Petrarchism arrived at the court of Henry VIII during the 1520s with the amateur sonnets of Thomas Wyatt. The Petrarcal influenced sonnets of Wyatt quickly captured the attention of English writers. English writers were drawn to these sonnets not only because of their innovative writing style, but because of the prosperous life this poet lived under the Tudor monarchy. Moreover, the sonnet’s descriptions of the upper classes were very popular among readers. It was because of the works of Petrarca and his successors that English amateur writers began to adopt the style created by the Humanists. (Kennedy 101)
            The amateur writer Sir Philip Sydney began the movement of Humanist sonnet writing among English professional writers of the sixteenth century. After the publication of his sonnet Astrophil and Stella, the trend of sonnet writing began. (Kennedy 101) Although Sydney was an amateur writer at the time, he managed to capture the essence of the Humanist sonnet. Sydney was influenced by Francesco Petrarca’s style and sonnet sequence. Furthermore, he discussed many controversial topics of the time, such as religion and politics. Sydney also brought his own style to the Humanist Sonnet which made it more appealing to other writers and the public.
            Humanists not only brought a new literary style to England, but they gave local writers the ability to fulfill their desires and ambitions. English writers were able, for the first time, to practice professional authorship, which would bring them monetary gain:
What these humanists did when they arrived in England was make a practical reality of the ambitions of persons…they practiced professional authorship. They traded their reputations, their literary skills and talents, and their writings for money and other rewards, competing for Patronage, often successfully with local writers. (Carlson 274)
What Humanist did when they came to England was to further the career of many authors of this time. No longer did English writers have to conform to the traditional writing styles and topics, they now had the ability to choose what they wanted to write about. However, it cannot be assumed that Humanist literature took hold of England as soon as the style was introduced by Italian Humanists. At the end of the fifteenth century, professional Humanistic literature was absent. As in all intellectual movements, amateurs, such as Sir Philip Sidney in the sixteenth century, were the first to be influenced by the style of sonnet, and the works were not well known. It was not until the Humanist Literary Movement had established itself that professional writers began to adopt the style.  (Weiss 13)

Works Cited
Carlson, David R. "Chaucer, Humanism, And Printing: Conditions Of Authorship In Fifteenth-Century           England." University Of Toronto Quarterly 64.2 (1995): 274. Academic Search  Complete. Web. 23 Oct. 2013.

Kennedy, William J. The Cambridge Companion to the Sonnet . 1st ed. Cambridge: University Press, 2011. Print.

Weiss, Roberto. Humanism in England During the Fifteenth Century, Editors Introduction.            Oxford: B. Blackwell, 2012. PDF.

Wednesday, October 23, 2013

Sir Philip Sidney


   

Sir Philip Sidney was well-known among his contemporaries as the embodiment of English courtliness and honor. He was a soldier, courtier, and a poet. Sidney died at the age of thirty-one at the battle of against the Spanish force at Zutphen. This event made him into an iconic representation of protestant heroism since died for a protestant cause.  Sidney was born in 1554 and was the eldest son of two distinguishable parents, Henry Sidney and Mary Dudley. His father, Sir Henry Sidney, was the lord deputy of Ireland. However, he has difficulty supporting his family because of financial issues.  When the Queen rewarded Henry a barony title, he declined because “it was beyond the family already attenuated financial resources” (Kinney 648).   
Despite financial problem in his childhood, Sir Phillip Sidney received his education at Shrewburry School and later at Christ Church, Oxford. However, it was in the grand tour of the Continent which including Germany, Switzerland, Hungary and Italy (1572 to 1575) that greatly influenced his developments and views.  In his subsequent travel to Paris in 1572, Sidney was determined to become a militant Protestant after witnessing the St. Bartholomew’s Day Massacre.  St. Bartholomew’s Day Massacre was where more than thousands of French Protestants were slaughtered at Catholic Command.  Through his subsequent travels, he met and won patronage from literary figures and humanist such as, Hubert Languet.  The two maintained extensive correspondence, because Languet deems Sidney “as a sympathetic and influential voice who might help secure English support for anti-Catholic projects” (Kinney 649). After his tour, Sidney returned to England to attend the governmental service. For three years, 1576 to 1579 Sidney sought to win significant position in court. However, his ambition was received with hostility by Queen Elizabeth’s suspicion toward Sidney’s popularity with Continental associates. Further straining the relationship with the Queen, Sidney wrote a letter to the Queen opposing the projected marriage to Anjou, Catholic duke of Alençon. This letter made it impossible for Sidney to advance any further in court society. Sidney resigned from court after becoming more frustrated with the lack advancement in court. Sidney retired to the town of Wilton, where he focuses on writing poetry.  During this retirement in Wilton, Sidney wrote many works, including Astrophel, Defense of Poesy, and Acardia.
One of Sidney most influential work is the Defense of the Poesy. In this work he argues for social and cultural revaluation of poetry and poet in response to perceived decline of poetry. Sidney views poets as a second God, creating a second nature via poetry.  However, an article by Roger Moore, Sir Philip Sidney's Defense of Prophesying, argues that the Defense of the Poesy was written to defend prophesying. Moore notes that throughout the text, Sidney characterizes both poetry and prophecy in similar light, “Like a prophet, the poet reveals divine truths to sinful humanity and leads them to moral and spiritual renewal” (Moore 36). Moore accounts that early Puritans has adopted "prophesying exercises” as a tool to discuss and interpreted and discussed complex biblical passage. Prophesying is often associated with preaching and a prophet could also be anyone who spoke under divine inspiration. Fearful that nature of prophecy exercises could result more “dangerous speculation” of Elizabeth's church and social unrest, eventually leads Queen Elizabeth to issue proclamation to suppress political prophecies among the Puritans and Familists (Moore 35). Moore identifies that it is plausible that Sidney was defending prophecy because most Elizabethan often regard poets, who also claim divine inspiration, and prophets “as cunning deceivers who used their talents to lure the simple into scandalous, dangerous behavior” (Moore 44). Moore reasons that Defence of Poesy is an attempt to change contemporary’s view of prophecy from a despised and dangerous form into an instrument of English moral reformation. Rodger Moore further argues that Sidney had prior interest in prophecy before that development of the Defence of Poesy. In Sidney’s letter to Queen Elizabeth about the projected marriage to Alençon, Sidney prophesied that the potential marriage will bring disaster to England.
It is apparent that Sidney incorporated his religious belief into his poetry. From Defense of the Poesy it can be seen that Sidney believes that you could assess religious concepts and virtues through poetry. Furthermore, he used his writing to discuss and explain religious passages.



Work Cited

Kinney, Arthur F. et al. Tudor England : an encyclopedia. New York, London: Garland 2001. 

Moore, Roger E. "Sir Philip Sidney's Defense of Prophesying." Studies in English Literature, 1500 - 1900 50.1 (2010): 35-62. ProQuest. 21 Oct. 2013 .