In
his elegiac, yet satiric proposal to solve Ireland’s poverty crisis, sparked by
the English invasion, Jonathan Swift writes, “It is a very melancholy
reflection, that such a country as ours, which is capable of producing all
things necessary, and most things convenient for life, should yet lie under the
heaviest load of misery and want” (528). These opening words delved into the
dilemmas of Ireland and described the intense contrast in Irish lifestyle
before and after the Anglicization of Ireland, which lead to a loss of Irish
culture and doctrine. The moment King Henry VIII of England overturned the
Fitzgerald Dynasty of Ireland; he commenced a conflict that would last for over
a century that did not end until the early modern period when Anglican beliefs
dominated the religious organization of Ireland. For that century, Irish
Catholics struggled with English colonization. English monarchy attempted to
transform Irish culture and convert the native and Anglo-Irish to Protestantism.
Wagner articulates, “by 1603, English lord deputies, backed by a growing
military establishment, had extended effective English rule throughout Ireland”
(641). As a result of constant struggle and war, poverty and starvation shook
Irishmen to the core.
One of the major sources of the Anglicization
of Ireland stemmed from English monarchs’ belief that Protestant doctrine
existed as the one, true religion of God, leaving Irish Catholicism to sink, as
Micheál Ó Siochrú states “religion undoubtedly played a major role in the
conflict of the mid-seventeenth century” (26). English colonization and
settlements created a divided Ireland, with not only two conflicting religions
but also two conflicting political ideas. The invasion of English armies and settlers
disrupted external trade and caused “the
debasement of coinage (that) caused severe economic hardship” (34). Famine,
poverty, and sickness writhed the streets of Ireland, causing the weakness of
many Irishmen and the depleting strength of their armies. Siochrú writes of
the year 1650, claiming that, “the city experienced
severe food shortages throughout the summer, while the plague claimed as many
as 400 victims each week” (46).
Irishmen
could not fight against the stronghold of Englishmen who would invaded urban
areas with thousands of soldiers at a time, bringing with them weapons, the
plague, and Protestant doctrine. Over the course of one hundred years,
Englishmen slowly diminished the culture and influence of Irish tradition in
the Irish’s native land and assimilated a people to foreign ideals and
religious beliefs. English soldiers not only forced Irish citizens to accept
their religious beliefs, but also to accept and bow down the crown and monarchy
of England. The once Lordship of Ireland transmogrified into the Kingdom of
England; monarchy gripped the land of Ireland, dissipating the central
political influences of Ireland.
Although
cities such as Waterford, Limerick, and Galway attempted to cleanse their
churches of Protestant influence, “reclaiming churches and in some cases
expelling the local Protestant population,” British leaders such as Cromwell
still maintained a stronghold on Ireland and subjected the people with
influence of a foreign state (Siochrú 5). The fearsome, Irish commander Hugh
Dubh O’Neill bravely lead a strong army of Irishmen against the British
invasion in a vain: “Despite the failure of foreign
aid to materialize, O’Neill continued to hold out in Limerick. Unable to breach
the defenses of the strongest fortress in Ireland, Ireton resolved to starve
the inhabitants into submission” (Siochrú 51). Years
of conflict depleted the strength of Irishmen, causing issues with population,
money, and health. Streets were filled with depressing sights and soldiers
watched as people suffered with an uncaring eye as Siochrú described:
“28,000 people crammed inside the city walls” while “the plague continued to
claim a large number of victims,” and finally, “the inhabitants of Limerick,
Waterford, and Galway had suffered terribly as a result of the conflict, with
plague, famine, and siege warfare claiming thousands of lives” (Siochrú 21) .
This
political upheaval and unrest of the Irish state goaded Jonathan Swift into
writing his satirical essay that would solve all of the issues in Ireland
caused by poverty and war. The consumption of babies would not only feed
starving families and hungry lords, but also clothed the poor and provide them
with an good that could be traded for funds. The essay symbolized the greedy
monarchs who sloughed aside the lives of the Irish harshly. Swift “comically” suggests that England invaded Ireland
and dismissed their culture, stating, “It is too well known, that we are forced
to obey some laws we never consented to” (529). He symbolizes the callous
attitude of British officials and their dehumanization of Irishmen, stating
that the poor women who begged needed an “easy method of making (their)
children sound and useful members of the commonwealth” by contributing “to the
feeding, and partly to the clothing of many thousands” (522-524). The images of
poverty in Swift’s proposal pull readers into the struggles of the mid-seventh
century Ireland.
Works Cited
Schmid,
Susan Valters, and John A. Wagner. Encyclopedia of Tudor England, Volume 1.
Santa Barbara: ABC-CLIO, Inc, 2011. Print.
Siochrú, Micheál. "Civil Autonomy and Military Power in
Early Modern Ireland” Journal of Early Modern History 15. (2011): 31-57.
Print.
Swift, Jonathan. A Modest Proposal. LePan, Jon, Ed. The Broadview Anthology of British Literature: The Restoration and
Eighteenth Century. Canada Book Publishing Fund, 2012. p. 522-528. Print.




