Friday, October 18, 2013

The Three Cardinal Virtues: Faith, Hope, and Charity


            In Canto X, the setting shifts to the House of Holiness where the Red Cross Knight meets Caelia, whose name means Heavenly. According to The Cambridge Companion to Spenser, “her three daughters personify the theological virtues according to St. Paul” (212). Their names are Fidelia, Speranza, and Charissa, which are translated as Faith, Hope, and Charity. The Cambridge Companion to Spenser states that the daughters’ level of seniority is in accord with “Protestant understanding that divine grace saves believers when it operates through inward faith rather than charitable works in the external world” (212). Spenser demonstrates this through the Red Cross Knight being able to move beyond his conviction of sin with guidance from the oldest of the three daughters, Fidelia. By moving beyond his conviction of sin, he is able to reach the Protestant ideal of divine grace, which saves him and allows him to be a righteous man. The Companion text indicates that after he is saved by grace, the “previously inarticulate and illiterate knight comprehends fundamental theological truths” (212). This reference to theological truths once again raises Protestantism to the one and only true Christian Church of England, while Catholicism is regarded as the false Church of Rome. 
 

            An article by Gerald Morgan entitled “Holiness as the First of Spenser’s Aristotelian Moral Virtues” further discusses the three cardinal virtues of faith, hope, and charity from an Aristotelian perspective. Morgan explains that Spenser wrote a letter to Sir Walter Ralegh, which included Spenser’s claim that “the moral argument of the poem [The Faerie Queene] is Aristotelian” (817). Morgan begins his discussion by explaining the difference between moral virtues, such as holiness, as opposed to theological virtues, including faith, hope, and charity. Morgan asserts that “in the hierarchy of virtues the moral virtues that are acquired by repeated acts are subordinate to faith, hope, and charity: that is, to theological virtues, which are infused by God” (827). Essentially, this means that moral virtue is “the source of acts in accord with right reason,” while theological virtue is “the source of acts in accord with God” (Morgan 827). 

Morgan discusses charity, referencing it as “the virtue that joins man to God… It extends to the acts of all the virtues, not as eliciting them but as commanding them, since its object is the end of all human life, namely, eternal happiness” (827). Spenser recognizes the importance of charity in his poem by having Charissa, the daughter who is representative of Charity, be the one who helps guide the Red Cross Knight onto the path that leads to heaven.
           
            Morgan also expands specifically on the virtue of hope as he says:
            The importance of hope in the life of holiness arises from the radical sinfulness of human             
            nature… Even saints are flawed, and consequently there is need for some extrinsic aid if            
            human undertakings are to be attended with success. Original sin is a corruption of human            
            nature, so that all works proceeding from that nature are essentially vitiated (828).

            According to Morgan’s interpretation, Spenser shares in this pessimistic view of sinful human nature and expresses this view through showing the Red Cross Knight as being “so changed by the impact of sin that it has now become the source of his misery” (828-829). Although Spenser does seem to share in viewing human nature as sinful, Morgan critiques Spenser’s view as he explains:

[Spenser’s] pessimism is characteristic of the thought of Augustine rather than of Aquinas (for whom original sin is a privation of original justice rather than a positive corruption of human nature), and here it would seem that Spenser’s Aristotelianism has been modified by his Protestantism (829).

Morgan’s critique suggests the powerful and influential impact that Spenser’s religious views had on his writing. In fact, Morgan says:  

It is evident that the moral argument of Spenser’s poem cannot be conducted in isolation from             wider spiritual concerns, for human law is dependent on divine law. In other words, there has to be a metaphysical foundation if moral concepts are to be meaningful and if the moral order is to be seen as real. Holiness is the first of Spenser’s virtues precisely because it is at the immediate point of contact between human choice and divine provision (830).

By understanding the influence of Protestantism on Spenser's writing, we are able to further analyze his work while always keeping in mind his admiration for Queen Elizabeth and her reign, which led to the true Church of England's establishment.


Works Cited

Hadfield, Andrew. The Cambridge Companion to Spenser. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2001. Print.   
         
Morgan, Gerald. "Holiness As The First Of Spenser's Aristotelian Moral Virtues." Modern Language Review 81.4 (1986): 817-837. Academic Search Complete. Web. 16 Oct. 2013.

Thursday, October 10, 2013

Recusancy: Catholics in a Protestant England



The term “recusancy” stems from the Latin recuso, meaning ‘I refuse.” The term can be used to refer to a general refusal to obey government orders.  The Columbia Companion to British History asserts that the term is most commonly used to refer to “the specific refusal to attend services of the Church of England, mostly by Roman Catholics” (413). Legislation against recusancy began in 1549 and was enforced especially under Elizabethan rule.  According to The Columbia Companion to British History, “an increasingly savage range of penalties was laid down, including fines, forfeiture of property, life imprisonment, banishment and death, although enforcement varied in anti-Catholic feeling” (413). The Companion text also indicates that “Roman Catholicism was severely repressed during Elizabeth I’s reign, and the government was very successful in associating Anti-Catholicism with patriotism” (138).  This belief that being Anti-Catholic made one patriotic caused much propaganda to go around for both sides of the argument.  Spenser’s Faerie Queene is one example of Anti-Catholic propaganda.  During the years of recusancy, many laws and acts were set into place, some that would call for punishment for practicing Catholics.  According to The Cambridge Historical Encyclopedia of Great Britain and Ireland:
                        The 1559 Uniformity Act imposed a one-shilling fine for each
absence from prescribed services of established Church, but
with growing fear of Catholics, fines increased in 1581 to a
huge sum of £20 per month. The fines were not widely exacted,
but the threat was used to intimidate Catholics into conformity;
laws tightened in 1587, 1597, and 1606.  Persecution of Catholics
varied with political circumstances, but Elizabeth temporized
in face of Parliament’s preference for stronger action. (131)
During a time where Protestantism was the only religion legally allowed to be practiced, recusants had only one option—to break the law.
An article by John J. LaRocca, S.J. entitled “Time, Death, and the Next Generation: The Early Elizabethan Recusancy Policy,1558-1574” explores the motivations behind the Anti-Catholic policies that Elizabethan governments enforced.  LaRocca says:
This article is an attempt to view the recusant problem from the perspective of the monarch and the Privy Council, because both monarch and Privy Council were aware of the international character of Catholicism and both stated clearly in their policies toward recusants the grounds of their objection to the Catholic community. An analysis of the recusancy policy established by Elizabeth between 1559 and 1574 reveals that her primary objection to the recusants was not religious but political. (102)
It seems strange that Elizabeth’s motivations would be political and not religious.  The issue of recusancy during this time had everything to do with religion on the surface.  In peeling back the layers of the issue, though, one can clearly see that Elizabeth’s primary problem was that the Catholics were going against her power, not necessarily that they were practicing Catholicism.  LaRocca asserts:
The recusants denied a fundamental claim of the monarch: the headship of the church and, therefore, the claim that the monarch was the source of all power within the realm. This article, then, will examine the ways in which she wished to contain a minority who denied her supreme power in the realm…(102)
English Catholics denied that Queen Elizabeth had any right to tell them how to worship or call herself the head of the church.  Because the English Catholics felt this way, it was seen as a challenge to the Queen’s supremacy and sovereignty.  Obviously, Queen Elizabeth did not like this. The recusants were identified as a disobedient and potentially rebellious section of the population (LaRocca 104).  Evidenced by the political action that took place, recusancy became embedded in the political matrix.
            Anyone who held office under the crown was asked to swear to an oath that ensured they were not associated with Catholicism.  If they refused to swear to the oath, they were barred from public office for the rest of their lives. Consequences of not swearing to the oath, actively disobeying the Queen, or not using the Elizabeth-approved Second Book of Common prayer included fines, imprisonment, and sometimes even death (LaRocca 104).
            Eventually, the recusancy laws were not strictly followed in some cases and very strictly followed in other cases.  Instead of inflicting multiple punishments on recusants, the group of disobedient individuals would be forced to conform to the religious standards set by the Elizabethan government on a certain day or multiple days throughout the year. The idea behind this was that “more was to be gained from the sight of known recusants conforming on occasion, thus accepting the authority of the queen, than from extracting the full penalty of the law or insuring that those who conformed received the sacrament” (LaRocca 111).  LaRocca goes on to say:
The English and the papacy had different interpretations of how they related and of which was superior. Priests were executed because their religious beliefs had practical political consequences in terms of which was superior, the temporal sword or the spiritual sword. Their religious beliefs denied the queen's claim to be the only source of power in the realm. The question for Elizabeth and the priests was still a religious-political question the two categories were still one and could not be separated in dealing with the recusants. To do that would be to distort their perspective on the problem. (116)
The religious and political differences became so overwhelming to some recusants that, if they were not already forced to live in exile, they chose to live in exile.  Communities were formed all around Europe where groups of recusants would live together and practice Catholicism.  Eventually, these groups living in exile began to train their priests for the sole purpose of returning to England and restoring Catholicism.  When these priests came, Queen Elizabeth’s problem was still loyalty.  However, she realized that her policies needed to change in order to move with the times and make her people happy (LaRocca 117).  She began to modify her policy and move in a direction that her Catholic subjects could appreciate.

Works Cited

Gardiner, Juliet, and Neil Wenborn. The Columbia Companion to British History. New York:
Columbia University Press, 1997. Print.
Haigh, Christopher. The Cambridge Historical Encyclopedia of Great Britain and Ireland.
Cambridge Cambridgeshire: Cambridge University Press, 1985. Print.
LaRocca, John J. "Time, Death, and the Next Generation: The Early Elizabethan Recusancy
Policy, 1558-1574." The North American Conference on British Studies 14.2 (1982): 103-17. JSTOR. Web. 10 Oct. 2013.

The Faerie Queen: Spenser's Allegorical reality

Though Edmund Spenser was not the first or last author to write in allegorical format, The Faerie Queen is written in a broken up and more complicated version of the popular literature technique.

            William Harmon’s A Handbook to Literature defines an allegory as “a form of extended metaphor in which objects, persons, and actions in a narrative are equated with meanings that lie outside the narrative itself”.  Simply put an allegory is a big symbolism or abstract of a bigger picture or story. Much like the parables Jesus spoke in throughout the New Testament, or Dante’s description of the various stages of hell, an allegory is a meaning within a story (inception) that goes beyond the surface text. The overlapping of two realities tends to enrich the plot and confuse the reader at the same time, making the literary technique powerful yet complicated without background information, and “evok[ing] a dual interest” that deepens meaning. It’s important to note the difference from allegory and symbolism though: a symbol is in physical reality and the allegory exists in a separate one. While the literal season of spring symbolizes rebirth, the lion tamed by Una’s innocence and killed protecting her is a metaphorical representation of Christ’s sacrifice for humankind to be cleansed.


            In Spenser’s Faerie Queen, the basic plot is that of a knight out to slay a dragon, accompanied by a fair lady and running into several obstacles. This plot line is extremely basic, especially for the time period, so therefore one is forced to look for a deeper meaning within the text. With the Red Cross Knight representing the virtue of holiness, Una being purity and oneness, and several obstacles as sin, duplicity, rage, and more, The Faerie Queen becomes an allegory for several layers of religious, political, and nationalistic debate. RCK slaying the monstrous dragon represents holiness overcoming the disgusting corruption in the Catholic church The story on the surface is “a chivalric romance, but it embodies ideological meanings”(Harmon 12). Spenser’s use of reoccurring themes such as propaganda against Catholicism, characters as virtues, and hidden details within names and actions enriches the overall allegory. While the main story is a dramatic battle of chivalric knighthood, deceit  and entrelacement of story lines, Spenser strives to call attention to the stronger meanings of the allegory. 

            Though the technique of allegory is not new, the debate of its definition and development over the centuries is new. Critic Walter Davis states, “the concept of allegory is desperately in need of historicizing. As if we cannot bring ourselves to believe that a literary technique two millennia old never changed at all, we frequently treat it in critical discourse by a definition of the real unchanging nature of allegory”. This claim brings forward the idea of allegory as a shape shifter technique. Yet Spenser’s work remains highly influenced by that of Chaucer’s Canterbury Tales and Dante’s Inferno. Because of the high influence and distinct parallels between the works (the bleeding tree highly mirrors circle seven of Dante’s hell) one can assume that the technique of allegory is constant through that time period as well as in modern literature. Constant throughout the works as an extended metaphor representing something bigger, allegory is a powerful technique that enriches an otherwise standard text.
Works Cited
Davis, William. Spenser and the History of Allegory. English Literary Renaissance. Winter 2002, Vol. 32 Issue 1, p152-167. Web.
Holman, C. Hugh and Harmon, William. A Handbook to Literature. Upper Saddle River: Prentice Hall, 2000. Print.

           
           

           




Monday, October 7, 2013

Queen Elizabeth I: The Virgin Queen




There have been several instances of literary criticism that assert Queen Elizabeth is a symbolized in Spencer’s character of Gloriana in The Faerie Queen. Gloriana is meant to be a representation of Queen Elizabeth and how she was received by the English people. As well as other works of the time period, Spenser’s The Faerie Queen was one of the many works that served as, “timeless reflections of Elizabeth’s perpetuation of ‘her maidenhood in a cult of virginity’ with her virginity seen as a perpetual state (King 32).  One of the most prominent aspects that defined Elizabeth’s role as Queen was her chastity, virginity, and purity. Elizabeth was known as the “Virgin Queen”.

Dominated by a patriarchal society, starting a reign as a female during the Renaissance would not have been an easy task for Elizabeth. However, instead of contending to her gender being a liability in her reign, Elizabeth made it an advantage (King 33). She used her virginity and purity as an advantage in her political career by gaining the admiration and respect of her people. Her image and how she was perceived by the people was everything. She not only maintained an image of virginal purity but also defied the patriarchal traditions of the time. Obviously, it would have been expected for her to marry and bear an heir to the throne. However, Elizabeth chose a rather radical path to remain a virgin and not marry. Modern scholarship has supported that it was entirely Elizabeth’s choice to choose a life of perpetual virginity (33). 

Elizabeth’s idea to defy the gender expectations and social norms for her position somewhat aligned with the changing times of the English Renaissance. New ideas and ways of thinking were being introduced; almost a new way of life. The people were undergoing a dramatic change in lifestyle without even realizing it. In regard to gender roles Rowse asserts that, “There was, too, freedom accorded to women that so much struck outside observers--something like equality” (4). Men and women certainly were not thought to be equal but the ways in which women of higher power were regarded were changing. Elizabeth’s choice of virgingity and to never marry was an indication of this. 

The earliest indication of Queen Elizabeth’s choice to remain pure and never marry was in one her earliest speeches. She describes herself as “already bound unto an Husband, which is the kingdom of England...” indicating that she is already bound in a marriage with her country and her people (King 33). Elizabeth positioned herself as an extremely virtuous woman. It seemed that by making this declaration, she was putting her own personal desires and potential happiness aside for the good of her kingdom. However, there has been speculation that there was more to Elizabeth’s motivations than simply being selflessly dedicated to her people.

Many scholars argue that Elizabeth’s main motivation for her choice of perpetual virginity was to position herself in a way in which she was defying the patriarchal expectations. By declaring she would not marry or bear children, she was defying the very expectations in which she was expected to follow as a woman and as a ruler. King describes Louis Montrose’s argument that by refusing the female expectations of the time, she sought avoidance “to become the medium through which power, authority, and legitimacy are passed through generations of men” (34). Perhaps she wanted control over her reign and did not want to pass off her power to her husband and eventually, her  heir. It is difficult to know if this was actually Elizabeth’s main goal in her choice of virginity, but regardless it defied the norm of a woman her position. 

King also points out that there has been criticism of Elizabeth’s speech that she supposedly never claimed she sought to outset in image upon the beginning of her reign in a view of celibacy but instead just wanted to emphasize her preference for unmarried life (37). Even if the focus of her speech was more focused along the lines of not wanting to focus on marriage, it still defied the expectations of the time period. Everyone knows that marriage and not remaining a virgin go hand in hand. So, by Elizabeth asserting she would like to avoid marriage, she is still saying she will remain a virgin. Even if her emphasis was simply on the act of marriage and not celibacy, she made it clear that she sought to be the head of her own reign and not have a man overshadow her command. 

From this point of view, it could be said that Elizabeth was sort of a feminist of sorts. It is impossible for anyone to ever truly know if Elizabeth’s role as the “virginal queen” was a life decision based on an unwavering devotion to her country, an act of defiance against the patriarchal societal expectations, or a little bit of both. 



 Works Cited

King, John. “Queen Elizabeth I: Representations of the Virgin Queen.” Renaissance Quarterly , Vol. 43, No. 1 (Spring, 1990), pp. 30-74. JSTOR. Web. 6 Oct. 2013.

Rowse, A.L. “The Elizabethan Renaissance: The Life of the Society.” New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1971. Print. 







Wednesday, October 2, 2013

The Dissolution of the Monasteries: What Was the TRUE Purpose?


            In the 1530s, King Henry VIII set forth legal processes to tear down many monasteries throughout England.  Henry ordered the majority of “900 religious houses in England” (Bernard 390) not only to be metaphorically separated in the sense that the communities of people were dissolved but also physically in that the buildings themselves were demolished.  As the head of his own denomination, Anglicanism, Henry not only held political power over his constituents but also self-designated religious authority.  While some historians speculate that the deconstruction of so many of these religious buildings was merely rooted in the maintenance of greed by looting monasteries’ relics rather than caused by ideological dissonance, G. W. Bernard argues that “we should be wary about interpreting the dissolution simply in material terms” (392).  That is, Bernard feels that Henry’s dissolution of these holy buildings had purpose other than that of simply obtaining items of high wealth and monetary value.
            Bernard does concede that Henry’s administration did, of course, take advantage of the materials that they stumbled upon in each monastery, pulling items of importance naturally to increase his own wealth, to assert his monetary dominance over his people.  Because “The revenues of the religious houses… amounted to over £130,000 a year” (Bernard 393), Henry and his cronies saw the opportunity to seize items of worth.  Even some of the less financially valuable parts of monasteries were taken and implemented: “after the dissolution of the monasteries much stonework was torn down and reused in Henry’s works, generally as rubble for foundations, but occasionally for other purposes” (“The King’s Houses – 1485 – 1660” 21).  Still, Bernard states that other purposes were key in Henry’s decision to demolish these buildings, as Henry desired firmly to state his religious presence and “his royal supremacy” (393) and to prove himself the worldly leader of his religion.  Furthermore, Henry not only wished to prove powerful in his religion but also to prove his religion powerful against other ideologies, “rival religious beliefs” (Bernard 393) like the Catholicism of the monasteries.
             The split of Anglicanism from Catholicism was, as many educated people know, Henry’s difficulty to “search for a divorce” (Bernard 395) and his denial from the Catholic Church.  His disagreements in belief, that he as royalty should be allowed divorce, with the Pope caused the “ultimate break with Rome” (Bernard 395), and Henry decided to form his own Christian denomination of the Church of England, inciting the English Reformation.  Bernard argues that Henry’s decision to split after the refusal of his divorce was not necessarily one of political agenda initially but rather that “it was at best embarrassing and at worst threatening to the king” (395).  Once he made the decision to split from the Catholic Church, Henry’s next step was to ensure that his citizens obeyed his orders and fell in line with his commands.
            Worrying that the monasteries, whose roots were Catholic, would stick to their traditional affiliation, “Henry was determined that monasteries should recognize his authority” (Bernard 396).  Henry and his “vicegerent in spirituals” (Bernard 396), Thomas Cromwell, then embarked on trips that were essentially monastery inspections.  Ascertaining wealth of each religious house was, of course, a factor in these treks, but Bernard argues that Henry primarily wanted “to assent royal authority” (396), to guarantee that the monks and friars legitimately considered him to be their leader.  Interestingly, Bernard notes that these inspections revealed much “evidence of sexual misconduct” (397) by several members of the clergy in a range of activity including that with boys and that with nuns, many of whom found themselves pregnant consequently.  As a result of the findings of these inspections, “there were discussions about what should be done to reform the monasteries” (Bernard 399), but these conversations were generally unfruitful.  Alas, the first round of dissolution began.
            The first act that demanded dissolution targeted only the smaller monasteries whose income did not justify their remaining open also because more abuse tended to occur in these smaller buildings.  Henry and Cromwell conveyed that this reformative move was so that “religion is right well kept and observed” (Bernard 399), so finances were not the only factor in their removal.  Ultimately, “Henry VIII was planning to confiscate the treasures of parish churches” (Bernard 400) according to gossip, which initially held no truth.  However, because word of mouth was spreading so fervently, a small rebellion in northern England came to be, forcing Henry to feel as though he had to put his foot down.  As religious and royal leader, Henry demanded the respect and obedience of his citizens, becoming filled with “outright hostility” (Bernard 402).  Bernard notes that ultimately, “At some point in late 1537 Henry and his counsellors [sic]” (404) decided to dissolve monasteries completely, commanding with full force the destruction of buildings and the reaping of worthy artifacts and relics from each one. 
            Bernard finally argues that Henry’s actions were not even completely those of a power struggle or an assertion of dominance, noting that the Church of England was “Catholicism without the pope, without monasteries and without pilgrimages… what he had already rejected was devotion to individual saints” (409), perhaps creating an attempt to be spiritually closer to God.  Regardless of the validity of Bernard’s final hypothesis, he states that wealth and greed were not the primary reasons for the Dissolution of the Monasteries.  Instead, his desire for respect and recognition of his authority in addition to a potentially genuine attempt to reform sexual corruption were the bases of the dissolutions.



Works Cited
Bernard, G. W.  “The Dissolution of the Monasteries.”  History 96.324 (2011): 390-409.  Academic Search Complete.  Web.  2 Oct. 2013.  <http://proxy-s.mercer.edu/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=a9h&AN=65302213&site=eds-live>.
 “The King’s Houses 1485 – 1660.”  The History of the King’s Works.  Ed. Howard Colvin.  Vol. 4.  London: H. M. Stationery Office, 1963.  Print.