Friday, September 13, 2013

Sovereignty in the Wife of Bath's Tale
 In the 18th century, sovereignty meant "territory under the rule of a sovereign, or existing as an independent state..." or "...supreme controlling power in communities not under monarchical government, absolute and independent authority" (Thomas 89).  In contrast to this, the American definition is "complete independence and self-government" (Thomas 89).  The argument made in this article is that while the knight took advantage of the wyf by having his way with her, she ended up with the sovereignty in the relationship, but what exactly does that sovereignty entail?  Also, why does she get this power over him when he can clearly overtake her?
In her tale, the Wife of Bath is attempting to show that women were not as helpless and dependent on men as thought at the time.  The wyf in the story is raped by the knight, but she takes him to court, where he has to marry her in order to keep his own life for the crime committed.  The knight is also pictured as not knowing what he wants.  He is given the choice, by the wyf, between whether he preferred obedience or beauty in women, but he could not choose.  These are clearly not the only two options for characteristics in a woman, but they are the main characteristics that would be sought by a character such as the knight, and the wyf knows this.  Him not even being able to decide between these two aspects shows the low view he has of women in the first place, since he sees them as equal traits.  If women were valued as intellectual beings, those would not be the only choices, but the wyf is aware of the knight's mental processes, or lack thereof.  As shown by him even raping her in the first place, "he has been under the control of his desires from the beginning, and thus he never attains knowledge or power" (Thomas 94).  Contrarily, "as a shapeshifter, the wyf represents the ultimate fantasy of power over one's own body" (Thomas 95).

In addition to the idea of women having more power than thought, other issues addressed are those of the court of law.  The wyf took the knight to court for raping her, and then she was allowed to decide his fate.  During this period of time, it was not rare for the citizens of a community to take the law into their own hands.  Stories and literature were produced during this time, such as Robin Hood and the Tale of Gamelyn, which talk about vigilantes.  "Both literary types look to the crown for provision of just laws; but one type thinks that in hard times the crown needs some good local men to jump-start the system with violent self-help" (Cambridge 100).  The wyf did not take the violence into her own hands towards the knight, but she now has control over him and his desires since they are now married, and this is seen as a form of justice for what he did to her.  If he was so stupid as to take out his desires on her, those of which he did not even have a mental control over, then now she is in a position where she can tell him what to do with those desires since she is his sovereign and does know how to control her own desires.  Thomas says, "the knight's redemption from poverte, or lack of worth, may be illusory" (Thomas 95).  He may not have been killed by the law, but now someone else is sovereign over him, and there is nothing he can do other than accept it.  Meanwhile, the wyf is fully aware of this, and finds it amusing: "Her apparent desire for the knight is part of the joke, making the 'bath of blisse' when he feels desire for her, not the knight's reward, but the moment when he becomes locked into an ever more abject relationship to the wyf" (Thomas 95).

Work Cited:
Thomas, Susanne Sara. "The Problem Of Defining "Sovereynetee" In The "Wife Of Bath's Tale.." Chaucer Review 41.1 (2006): 87-97. Academic Search Complete. Web. 13 Sept. 2013.
Galloway, Andrew.  The Cambridge Companion to Medieval English Culture.  Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2011. Print.

Wednesday, September 11, 2013

The Seven Deadly Sins

In “The Pardoner’s Tale”, Geoffrey Chaucer underscores a popular motif and mentality of his time—the idea of the Seven Deadly Sins. In his story, he especially focuses on two of the Sins, avarice and greed. In the following text, I will expound upon the idea of the Seven Deadly Sins, including a focus on these two vices found in Chaucer’s story.
 
 
The Seven Deadly Sins include the sins of pride, envy, anger, sloth, avarice, gluttony, and lust. These sins are not necessarily sins on their own, but they posed as dangerous because they were thought to bring “death to the soul” (Newhauser 2), meaning that through the action of any of these sins, one would stray away from the Christian life that he ought to live by indulging in these carnal inclinations. The subject of the Seven Deadly Sins was most prevalent in the 13th century and was often used for academic studies as well as for teaching within the church. At one point, the clergy even required the subject to be used in “catechesis, preaching, and heading of confessions" ("Seven Deadly Sins"), a fact which emphasizes its dominance in medieval mentality. Expressions of this common mentality could be seen within the art realm and were often connected with purgatory and hell ("Seven Deadly Sins"). An example of the art works during this time, Hieronymus Bosch's The Seven Deadly Sins and the Four Last Things, can be seen below:
 
 
Different periods within the middle ages would mainly focus on one or more of the seven sins, highlighting the different moral concerns of each time period ("Seven Deadly Sins"). Around the time in which Chaucer wrote “The Pardoner’s Tale”, the vice of avarice was one of the most prevalent Deadly Sins in discussion (Newhauser xiii). Reflecting this mentality, in Chaucer’s story, the narrator’s tale is a moral lesson about the Deadly Sins of avarice and envy. The outline of this story is about three men who seek out Death for vengeance of their slain friend, and in the midst of finding Death, ultimately die because of their greed for worldly wealth. The sin of avarice was not only seen as a sin to the self but also to God and to others. To be greedy was to put another element in the place of God, and therefore, was considered to be idolatry. Avarice disrupted the social standards of the body of Christ because it was seen as withholding help to others. In the medieval culture, within the Christian body, those were financially sufficient possessed the obligation to help those who were not able to help themselves (Newhauser 5). In addition to avarice, envy may have even been worse than avarice, although there was no set hierarchy comparing each sin to another (Newhauser 2). Whereas avarice is related to happiness when one possesses a want, envy is the happiness derived from another person who is rejected with a desire(Newhauser 44). Although these sins are carnal and thought to be inherent in human nature, one could resist the temptation to indulge in them by living a more stoic life, such as through "voluntary poverty and almsgiving… but they must be accompanied by the correct motivation" (Newhauser 45).
 
The focus on avarice was prevalent in times other than the medieval period. A key figure in the development of the Seven Deadly Sins was Evagrius in 4th century Egypt. His original list consisted of eight human vices (Newhauser 53), which was later reduced to the seven we have today. The eight vices were obstacles that the monks had to overcome, and with each new victory, he would attempt to overcome the next vice. However, one key obstacle for the monks was that of avarice (Newhauser 53), a fact which reveals that this vice is a barrier for the ages; it was present in Evagrius’s days, in Chaucer’s time, and in our world today.
 
In “Preaching the Contrary Virtues”, Richard Newhauser extends the subject matter of Seven Deadly Sins within the 13th-15th centuries by incorporating the idea of “contrary virtues”. These virtues are the opposite, honorable elements to the Seven Deadly Sins, also known as, the vices. For example, if pride is the vice, humility would be the contrary virtue. Through the examples of many given sermons over the course of the medieval period, he makes the argument that the topic of the Seven Deadly Sins was often preached, and in the preaching of this message, the content of the sermon also included these contrary virtues, which were often implied through the use of the given vices. The number of contrary virtues was “derivative” of the number of vices given, meaning that for every vice, there was one contrary virtue (Newhauser 138). He also goes on to argue that although the vices, the Seven Deadly Sins, have a set standard—pride, envy, anger, sloth, avarice, gluttony, and lust—the contrary virtues could change based on the preacher’s purpose in his message (Newhauser 161-162).
 
 
 
Works Cited
 

Newhauser, Richard. The Early History of Greed: The Sin of Avarice in Early Medieval Thought and    Literature. Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge UP, 2000. Print.

Newhauser, Richard. "Preaching the 'Contrary Virtues'" Mediaeval Studies (2008): 135-62. EBSCO.     Web. 9 Sept. 2013.
 
Strayer, Joseph Reese. "Seven Deadly Sins." Dictionary of the Middle Ages. 1st ed. Vol. 11. New York: Charles Scribners' Sons, 1989. 211-12. Print.
 

Sunday, September 8, 2013

The Pardoner's Tale: What about preaching?


The attributes given to the Pardoner can be found in multiple preachers during medieval times, but these attributes are presented in a different way. For example, the pardoner sells relics while on his travel, which can be attributed to many preachers during this time. He also preaches to them, but does it through stories. In describing the Pardoner and telling his tale, Chaucer is, in a way, bringing a realization about medieval preachers through thier actions and preachings.
Though preachers are saying the relics they are selling are blessed by saints, they can be regular objects one may find in their home. The pardoner states, "By this gaude have I wonne yeer by yeer an hundred mark sith I was pardoner. I stonde lyk a clerk in my pulpet, and wan the lewed peple is doun yset, I preche so as ye han herd bifoore and telle an hundred false japes moore" (Chaucer 101-106). The pardoner has become a wealthy man because he has been selling false relics. He pokes fun at the individuals he sells to, as well. Once he has drained the "lewed peple" out of their money, he tells them stories of his tricks and possibly gain more from them. A reason for this act to be attributable to other medieval preachers can be due to the people being religious. Knowing that the dry bone or glove they have received promises good health or a possibility of going to heaven makes selling the false relics easy.
The pardoner shares the common preaching styles of preachers of the Middle Ages, as well. Siegfried Wenzel writes, "Late-medieval preachers were required to preach with regular frequency basic catechetical pieces of church doctrine...which included the Creed, the Ten Commandments, the seven deadly sins, and others" (xi). The Pardoner seems to be preaching about the deadly sins; some of which, like greed, he commits often. One can argue that the Pardoner's tale is a sermon. The "sermon" touch base on the consequences of committing some of the deadly sins. For example, due to thier wrath, they set out to kill Deeth. In doing so, they come across some gold. Their greed ends up becoming the best of them and they kill each other trying to become rich. A story like this shows that nothing good will come out of being greedy, which relates back to the Pardoner's earlier statement, "radix malorum est cupiditas" (Chaucer 46); greed is the root of evil.
The pardoner does fail to practice what he preaches. He preaches that one should not be greedy, but he suffers from greed. St. Gregory has been quoted saying, "No one does more harm in the Church than he who, having taken the title or rank of holiness, acts evilly" (Minnis 41). The Pardoner is guilty of acting "evilly". He waves his credentials in order to protect himself from harm and also to cheat people out of their money.
The role of the preacher is known to be important to the medieval people. Though they were important figures, preachers had their flaws, many of which are seen through Chaucer's "The Pardoner's Prologue and Tale". The selling of relics have been a commonality amongst clergymen. The relics have been said to provide good health and insure safe pasture into heaven. Preachers also shared common traits through their sermons as well. They preach about the Ten Commandments, the seven deadly sins, and many other biblical topics.


Works Cited

Chaucer, Geoffrey. "The Pardoner's Prologue and Tale". The Broadway Anthology of British Literature: Volume 1: the Medieval Period. Eds. Black, Joseph, Conolly, Leonard, Flint, Kate, Grundy, Isobel, LePan, Don, Luizza, Roy, McGann, Jerome J., Prescott, Anne Lake, Qualls, Barry V., and Waters, Claire. Ontario: Broadview Press, 2009. 518-530. Print.
Minnis, Alastair J. Fallible Authors. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2008. Print.
Wenzel, Siegfried. Preaching in the Age of Chaucer: Selected Sermons in Translation. Washington, DC: the Catholic University of American Press, 2008. Print.

Friday, September 6, 2013

The Knight- Estate Ideals in the General Prologue

Chaucer's Canterbury Tales uses the prologue to provide character briefings for each pilgrim. The Knight's description differs from the others by showing an ideal character in a good light rather than being satirical. Each character is described by their dress, their occupation, and their personality. By providing these three things, Chaucer was able to critique characters by these qualities being opposing. This is seen in all but one character, the Knight. The Knight is the first pilgrim described and is shown as a good example of chivalry with no qualities opposing that.

In the general prologue, Chaucer uses caricature and sarcasm in Old English to portray the story in a genre that has made him an  important literary figure. Many estates satirist try to connect the pilgrims to real life figures or aspirations of real life people of the time. Jill Mann chooses to view the characters in a more closely view of the literary technique used to develop the characters in her book Chaucer and Medieval Estates Satire.

Estate satire is a medieval literary genre that uses humor to critique life in society. An estate is a type of persons also pertaining to class or rank. Chaucer continued this idea of estates along with a person's occupation. Many characters have ironic qualities of being in one class or having one job with its stereotypes, and acting the complete opposite. He uses social stereotypes to contrast characters to. The character can then be “typified in two ways… by evoking the qualities that go with a profession, the “ideal version”; and alternatively, he can evoke malpractice and frauds thats usually go with the “normal version”.”(Mann).

The characters are suppose to be going on a pilgrimage but many seem to be going for less of a religious purpose and more for show for their appearance. Many characters are seen poorly by their clothes, their personality, like being angry and deceitful like the Reve, or their language of being profane.. Mann states that “Chaucer used the assembly of skill, duties and jaron that characterises an estate.”. He typically started out with describing what the character looked liked. Characters who were suppose to be peasants could be seen wearing a nice coat or a character who is suppose to be a monk is wearing fur from hunting.This also leads to professions. The monk again is a perfect example of this because he is not focused on his religious work and more interested in leisurely fun of hunting which is a luxury. Social rank in society was questioned too. A peasant trying to be someone of power, like aspiring to be priest like, is an example of a pilgrim who ignores rank in society.

The Knight is viewed as a perfect portrait of knighthood. Chaucer uses the Knight as an “archetype off ideal chivalry” (Elst). He is described as being, “...a man engaged in both peace and war, “worthy” as well as “wyrs” and described in lively detail” (Elst). Knights should be devoted to truth, honor, freedom, and courtesy. The Knight was “Ful worthy was he in his lordes were” and “And evere honoured for his worthynese” (Chaucer). The Knight shows love for what he does. He does not decorate himself and dress showy because his focus is on his work. This is in contrast to the Squire who is dressed up his armor and has curly locks. The Squire is focused on his looks.The Knight is wearing “Al bismotered with his habergeo” when arriving to go on the pilgrimage. The opposing views of his son the Squire and himself show a differencing in time in generations.  The Knight is focused on his work in traveling especially. Chaucer list many campaigns that the Knight has been on. The campaigns are less of fighting in war and more on the romance of traveling and beating the heathens. Fighting is seen as a job and a way of making money but in the case of the Knight, his fighting in the Holy Land reinstates his devotion to religion.  


The Knight sets the prologue for Chaucer to contrast the son of the Knight, the Squire and also the other characters. The Knights perfection makes the other characters flaws more apparent. Why Chaucer prefers the Knight is unknown. It is known that the Knights qualities especially being chivalrous, are important to building his tale which Chaucer writes later. Chaucer's choice of words and repetition in the Knights lines in the general prologue build his character without having the character have narrative and action. Chaucer does this with the other characters but in a negative way.

Citation:
Vander Elst, Stefan. "'Tu Es Pélérin En La Sainte Cité': Chaucer's Knight And Philippe De Mézières." Studies In Philology106.4 (2009): 379-401. MLA International Bibliography. Web. 5 Sept. 2013.

Mann, Jill. Chaucer and Medieval Estates Satire. London: Cambridge University Press, 1973. Print. 5 Sept. 2013

Tuesday, September 3, 2013

The General Prologue of The Canterbury Tales

The background of Chaucer’s The Canterbury Tales traces its roots back to the lifestyle and interests of its author. According to the Encyclopedia of the Novel, during his lifetime “Geoffrey Chaucer traveled in Europe and read widely” (Sholty), exploring new places, being introduced to new concepts and methods of writing, and meeting a variety of new people along the way. According to The New Princeton Encyclopedia of Poetry and Poetics, his early writings seem to be heavily influenced by notable French poets of the time, including “Guillaume de Lorris and Jean de Meun (part of whose poem Chaucer translated in the Roumant of the Rose), Froissart, and Machaut (whose influence may be seen in The Book of the Duchess)” (Osberg 1383). As he traveled, he eventually made his way through Italy, where he was introduced to the works of Dante, Petrarch, and Boccaccio. Chaucer’s travels through Europe seem to be a likely start to his conception of a story based around a pilgrimage, and many of the characters seen within The Canterbury Tales could have been based off of the myriad of people Chaucer met during his journeys and the plethora of stories they had to tell.

Geoffrey Chaucer

The writers that influenced Chaucer’s writing would help hone his skills and develop the themes consistent with both his earlier works and The Canterbury Tales. While there is no concrete evidence to suggest exactly when Chaucer wrote, based on his inspiration by both the earlier French writers and the later Italian writers, we have some idea of the influences present in his writing and when such influences could be seen. For example, “the middle or It. period, consisting of The House of Fame, The Parliament of Foules, Troilus and Criseyde, and The Legend of Good Women, is heavily indebted to Dante, Boccaccio, and, to a lesser extent, Petrarch” (Osberg 1383). So during this period, we can reasonably assume that as he was writing these works, Chaucer was exploring Italy and being subjected to the works of the great Italian poets. After Chaucer returned home to England, scholars are reasonably sure that “his late, Eng. period encompasses most of The Canterbury Tales” (Osberg 1383).    
The actual inspiration for The Canterbury Tales is still debated and speculated. A likely start or structure to The Canterbury Tales was an “unfinished collection of ten extant fragments, whose tales are connected by narrative links” (Osberg 1383). While this collection may or may not have been a part of The Canterbury Tales, Chaucer was clearly interested in the idea of a story broken up by individual accounts and stories within a shared framework. This, coupled with his travels through Europe and the religious background of the Crusades throughout his life, could have given Chaucer a reasonable starting place to establish his work. Within this framework, Chaucer could have his characters “touch on the great issues of the poem: love both secular and divine, justice, the power of lang., the trust necessary for community, the pilgrimage to God” (Osberg 1383).

Medieval Pilgrimage

Having established the background and inception of The Canterbury Tales, we can delve deeper into the General Prologue and the nuances to be found within. Colin Wilcockson has written an interesting and insightful article on the first thirty-four lines of the poem, "The Opening of Chaucer’s General Prologue to The Canterbury Tales: A Diptych," which explores both the structure and the allusions made within the very beginning of the poem.
Wilcockson states that, “The opening thirty-four lines of the General Prologue set the scene, and divide into two equal halves” (Wilcockson 345). Within these thirty-four lines, he claims, three distinct parts can be made out. Lines one through sixteen “are concerned with matters general: the renewal of nature in April with the simultaneous desire of men and women to set out on pilgrimages” (Wilcockson 345). Interestingly, lines seventeen and eighteen “are a rime riche (perfect rhymes on words that are different parts of speech). They state the object of the pilgrimage” (Wilcockson 345). And finally, “the last sixteen lines… home in on a specific group of pilgrims: their reception at the Tabard Inn and their plans for the next day” (Wilcockson 345). While this by itself is fascinating enough, Wilcockson suggests that even more significance can be drawn from the structure of the first thirty-four lines.
Alluded to in the title of the article, a diptych holds great significance for the opening thirty-four lines. Essentially two pictures or tablets hinged together, they were commonly used as a list of living and dead on two separate panels to be prayed for during Mass. As Wilcockson explains, “The thematic link between the natural description and the pilgrimage is that of death and rebirth” (Wilcockson 346). With that in mind, the two sets of sixteen lines before and after lines seventeen and eighteen can be seen as expressions found on a diptych.
Wilcockson also discusses the particular word choices used by Chaucer to denote the death and rebirth of nature, such as the fact that “it was thought in the Middle Ages that God created the world in March… In line 2 of the General Prologue Chaucer specifically mentions the ‘droghte of March’ which is broken by April rain” (Wilcockson 347). These precise descriptions and explanations of the individual word choice coupled with the overall tone of the opening help to lend credence to Wilcockson’s ideas.
The image below details the interesting rhyme structure to be found within the opening thirty-four lines.



Finally, Wilcockson ties religious allusions into the line seventeen-eighteen couplet. He states that Saint Augustine believed, “17 is significant because 10 can denote the Decalogue and 7 the gifts of the Holy Ghost” (Wilcockson 349). He further states that, “it is perhaps significant that line 17… contains the first mention of ‘the holy blisful martyr’, the saint whose shrine at Canterbury is the object of the pilgrim’s quest” (Wilcockson 350). An intriguing and thoughtful look into the structure of The General Prologue, Wilcockson delivers a fascinating reading of Chaucer’s work.

Works Cited

  • Osberg, Richard H. “English Poetry.” The New Princeton Encyclopedia of Poetry and Poetics. Ed. Alex Preminger, T.V.F. Brogan, Frank J. Warnke, O.B. Hardison, Earl Miner. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1993. xlvi, pp. 1383.

    Sholty, Janet P. “Medieval Narrative.” Encyclopedia of the Novel. Ed. Paul Schellinger, Christopher Hudson, Marijke Rijsberman. Chicago; London: Fitzroy Dearborn Publishers, 1998.

    Wilcockson, Colin. "The Opening of Chaucer's General Prologue to The Canterbury Tales: A Diptych.” The Review of English Studies, Vol. 50, No. 199 (Aug., 1999), pp. 345-350. http://www.jstor.org/stable/517880