this is a test run
Wednesday, November 4, 2015
Thursday, December 5, 2013
Swift's Politics and Gulliver's Travels
The Restoration in England
encompassed times of religious turmoil as well as political division throughout
the late 17th and early 18th centuries. When the Anglican
Church and its effects on societal behavior came into question, church leaders
throughout Europe began looking for solutions to restore the Church’s
importance into the lives of its communities. Under the rule of Charles II,
Parliament reinstated the Anglican Book of Common Prayer and barred all
nonconformists from holding religious meetings outside of the established
church. Charles II conformed to Parliament’s imposing of the Anglican Book of
Common Prayer however, still felt sympathetic towards those wishing to practice
Catholicism. These actions were seen negatively in the eyes of the biased
anti-Catholic Parliament.
As the reign of Charles II ended,
anger and upheaval spread throughout England. Because Charles II had no
children, he did not have a legitimate heir. In turn, his brother James, a
practicing Catholic, was the next in line for the throne. During this time known as the “Exclusion
Crisis” (1679-1681), the Anti-Catholic Parliament was against this succession
and attempted to force Charles to exclude his brother from being the next heir
to the throne. As a result, Charles ended this time known as the “Exclusion
Crisis” by dissolving Parliament. This crisis caused separation between people
who supported the continued line of kingship and people who supported
Parliament’s anti-Catholic belief system. Consequently, England developed and
divided into two political parties known as the Tories and the Whigs. Tories,
being secessionists, felt loyalty toward their king and believed kingship
should continue through family lineage. Whigs however, in opposition of the
king, sided with Parliament. They opposed not only the practice of Catholicism,
but also absolute power which James now held due to his brother’s dissolving of
Parliament during his reign.
Born in Dublin in 1667, Jonathan
Swift was raised by Protestant and Royalist parents. Swift’s writings, later in
life, were influenced by his parents’ religious and political beliefs. After
undergoing all necessary procedures, in 1695 Swift became an ordained priest in
the Anglican Church. Pursuing his writing further than published works, Swift
worked under a mentor for thirty years. Swifts parodical and satiric writings
directed at religion and politics during the 18th century did not
sit well with the Anglican Church and were ostracized by Tories throughout
England. However, despite their dislike of his previous work, Swift gained a
reputation in England that landed him a spot as the editor of the Tory’s
official paper “The Examiner” when they came to power in the early 1700’s. As
he continued working for the Tory party, he became more interested in the
political aspects of England. Swift was a huge contributor to several popular
propaganda pamphlets that circulated throughout the country including “The
Conduct of the Allies,” an attack on the Whigs.
Swift’s growing popularity of
satiric and parodical writings sparked the development of a traveler’s story
known as “Gulliver’s Travels.” While Swift was generally viewed as a supporter
of the Royalist Tory party, F.P. Lock, author of Swift’s Tory Politics believed Gulliver’s Travels solidified
Swift’s support of a government “conducted in the national interest and not for
the benefit of a few individuals” (Lock 137). According to Lock, Swift’s
political views encompass order, stability, and hierarchy which are all incorporated
in the conservative Tory outlooks on government. Swift’s continued loyalty to
the Anglican Church epitomized the Tory’s firm principles to remain faithful to
one’s upbringing rather than changing with the times as the Whigs desired. Before
Lock’s work producing propaganda pieces, he presents Swift’s slow transition
from a firm Tory politician to a ‘country’ party member. This transition occurred
after the process of becoming an ordained priest of the Anglican Church. Swift’s
conversion to “country” was seen in his presentation to King William hoping to
expound merits of the Triennial Bill. Opponents of Swift believed the triennial
bill passed in 1640 by Charles I was the cause of his ruin and therefor, should
not be passed. Swift’s refutation to this argument, as seen by Lock, embodied
the strong beliefs of a “country” party member. Although his argument to King
William was perceived as a Tory’s political standpoint, Lock believed meeting
the second Earl of Sunderland sparked a transition from a ‘country’ member to a
‘court’ member. According to Lock, “Swift’s conversion from ‘country’ to
‘court’ was completed by 1697 when he sought patronage from Sunderland” (Lock
143).
Although Swift underwent many political
changes, Gulliver’s Travels, published between 1721 and 1725, was written
during “a period when his deepest political hatred was directed against the
corrupt Whig oligarchy,” (Lock 168). In
Lock’s perspective, the opinions portrayed in Gulliver’s Travels would have been substantially different if the
story had been written ten to fifteen years before its actual publication.
Because Swift was following in the footsteps of a ‘court’ member who agreed
with the political viewpoint of the time, he would not have addressed the
abuses of political power and authority by those invested in it. However,
because it was written in the 1720’s
while Swift remained strong in his conservative beliefs, Gulliver’s Travels presents a more “liberal” idea of Swift’s
politics. Negative themes portrayed in Gulliver’s
Travels such as despotism, absolutism, and rapid social change solidified
Lock’s belief that while Swift was once a politically confused and often
referred to as “furious high-Church man”
(Lock 179), Swift died a “conservative and authoritarian” (179).
Cannon, John
Ashton., ed. The Oxford Companion to British History. Comp. Andrew
Hanham. Oxford [England: Oxford UP, 1997. Print.
Lock, F. P.
"Swift's Political Values." Swift's Tory Politics. Newark: University
of Delaware, 1983. 134-79. Print.
Monday, December 2, 2013
Alexander Pope: Essay on Man
Alexander Pope was a man of many words who used his unfortunate upbringing and corrupt 18th century society to his benefit. Born in London Spring of 1688, Pope was one amongst many who were, “denied most of the privileges of British citizenship, including the right to vote or inherit land,” (540) because he was Catholic. Not only was he denied the right to vote or inherit land, he was also unable to receive formal education. This new act of parliament, the Test Acts, did not stop Pope from becoming self-educated; so by the age of twelve years old he knew French, Italian, Greek, and Latin and began to translate Homer’s writings. To make matters worse, Pope developed Pott’s disease in his youth, severely curving his spine so that he only grew to be about four feet, six inches. Rivals of Pope considered his religion and disability to be, “a sign of a malignant and twisted soul.” (540)
Pope, not being discouraged by the cruelty of his society, began to write, encouraged by the works of other writers and wrote his Pastorals in 1704 at the tender age of sixteen. It was considered to be his first poetic achievement. Soon Pope began to surround himself with great writers such as Johnathon Swift, John Gay, Robert Harley/Lord Oxford, Thomas Parnell, Dr. John Arbuthnot, and Lord Bolingbroke. They formed the Scriblerus Club a decade after Pope had written his Pastorals. By this time, The Rape of the Locke was republished in new form and was attracting much greater attention.
By 1733, Pope started Essay on Man. It was a philosophical poem in which Pope wrote in verse and heroic couplets. Pope wrote Essay on Man attempting to justify God’s ways and humanity’s place in the Universe. Unlike Milton who attempted to illustrate the fall of God’s first creation, Pope wroteEssay on Man to show that even though the world may be imperfect or corrupt, it was the work of God and it should not be questioned.
Essay on Man was written with four epistles which Pope addressed to his fellow Scriblerus club member Lord Bolingbroke. Each epistle had a specific subject matter, containing an overall theme of the nature of man and man’s place in the universe. The four subjects were: the nature of man and his place in our universe, man as an individual, man in society, and man’s pursuit of happiness. Even though this was a philosophical poem, “the work as a whole cannot be taken seriously.” (Boynton, xvii) Pope told Johnathon Swift that Essay on Man was, “a book to make mankind look upon his life with comfort and pleasure, and put mortality into good humor.”(541)
Most of Pope’s, “contemporaries considered [Essay on Man] to be his greatest work, “(Boynton, xviii) but to some it was criticized and thought of as controversial. Even after Pope died in 1744, scholars continued to criticize and dissect Essay on Man, such as Voltaire “who eagerly translated and imitated Alexander Pope’s Essay on Man, characterizing it as, “the most beautiful, most useful, must sublime didactic poem ever written in any language.” (Solomon, 1) Voltaire wasn’t the only one who felt that way; others such as Kant, Rousseau, and Hume also praised the Essay on Man with high remarks to it being an astonishing piece of writing. As such, there were scholars who looked down on and attacked Pope’s Essay on Man. Mark Pattison argued that his generation could no longer readEssay on Man, not because of misunderstanding but because of Pope’s writings. He said that, “We find its arguments confused and its dry rationalism to be unedifying.”(Solomon, 3) Other disapproving scholars considered the essay to be worthless, ignorant, and childish; blaming Lord Bolingbroke for misleading Pope to write frivolous arguments.
It seemed to be that after the 18th century ended, Pope’sEssay on Man wasn’t getting as much gratification and it was becoming a burden to read because it was being considered by critics to be a period piece. Some of the scholars that found Pope’s Essay on Man to be unsatisfying were not from his generation, which could be reason to why they could not grasp the ideas and themes of his arguments, but as said before Essay on Man was not supposed to be taken seriously; it was meant to be a good humored read.
Nevertheless, Pope was said to be a great poet who had mastered a variety of poetry styles such as mock heroic, lyric, and pastorals; he had a satirical way with words and used, “the richness of the society around him,” (542) to lend a helpful hand in his work. Now to this day, he is the third most frequently quoted writer in the Oxford Dictionary of Quotes after Shakespeare and Tennyson.
Works Cited
Black, Joseph Laurence. "Alexander Pope." The Broadview Anthology of British
Literature. 2nd ed. Vol. 3.Peterborough, Ont.: Broadview, 2012. 540-42.
Print. The Restoration And The Eighteenth Century.
Solomon, Harry M. The Rape of the Text: Reading and Misreading Pope's Essay on
Man. Tuscaloosa, AL: University of Alabama, 1993. E-Book.
Pope, Alexander, and Henry Walcott Boynton. The Complete Poetical Works of
Alexander Pope. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin, 1931. E-Book.
Anglicization of Ireland: 1600's
In
his elegiac, yet satiric proposal to solve Ireland’s poverty crisis, sparked by
the English invasion, Jonathan Swift writes, “It is a very melancholy
reflection, that such a country as ours, which is capable of producing all
things necessary, and most things convenient for life, should yet lie under the
heaviest load of misery and want” (528). These opening words delved into the
dilemmas of Ireland and described the intense contrast in Irish lifestyle
before and after the Anglicization of Ireland, which lead to a loss of Irish
culture and doctrine. The moment King Henry VIII of England overturned the
Fitzgerald Dynasty of Ireland; he commenced a conflict that would last for over
a century that did not end until the early modern period when Anglican beliefs
dominated the religious organization of Ireland. For that century, Irish
Catholics struggled with English colonization. English monarchy attempted to
transform Irish culture and convert the native and Anglo-Irish to Protestantism.
Wagner articulates, “by 1603, English lord deputies, backed by a growing
military establishment, had extended effective English rule throughout Ireland”
(641). As a result of constant struggle and war, poverty and starvation shook
Irishmen to the core.
One of the major sources of the Anglicization
of Ireland stemmed from English monarchs’ belief that Protestant doctrine
existed as the one, true religion of God, leaving Irish Catholicism to sink, as
Micheál Ó Siochrú states “religion undoubtedly played a major role in the
conflict of the mid-seventeenth century” (26). English colonization and
settlements created a divided Ireland, with not only two conflicting religions
but also two conflicting political ideas. The invasion of English armies and settlers
disrupted external trade and caused “the
debasement of coinage (that) caused severe economic hardship” (34). Famine,
poverty, and sickness writhed the streets of Ireland, causing the weakness of
many Irishmen and the depleting strength of their armies. Siochrú writes of
the year 1650, claiming that, “the city experienced
severe food shortages throughout the summer, while the plague claimed as many
as 400 victims each week” (46).
Irishmen
could not fight against the stronghold of Englishmen who would invaded urban
areas with thousands of soldiers at a time, bringing with them weapons, the
plague, and Protestant doctrine. Over the course of one hundred years,
Englishmen slowly diminished the culture and influence of Irish tradition in
the Irish’s native land and assimilated a people to foreign ideals and
religious beliefs. English soldiers not only forced Irish citizens to accept
their religious beliefs, but also to accept and bow down the crown and monarchy
of England. The once Lordship of Ireland transmogrified into the Kingdom of
England; monarchy gripped the land of Ireland, dissipating the central
political influences of Ireland.
Although
cities such as Waterford, Limerick, and Galway attempted to cleanse their
churches of Protestant influence, “reclaiming churches and in some cases
expelling the local Protestant population,” British leaders such as Cromwell
still maintained a stronghold on Ireland and subjected the people with
influence of a foreign state (Siochrú 5). The fearsome, Irish commander Hugh
Dubh O’Neill bravely lead a strong army of Irishmen against the British
invasion in a vain: “Despite the failure of foreign
aid to materialize, O’Neill continued to hold out in Limerick. Unable to breach
the defenses of the strongest fortress in Ireland, Ireton resolved to starve
the inhabitants into submission” (Siochrú 51). Years
of conflict depleted the strength of Irishmen, causing issues with population,
money, and health. Streets were filled with depressing sights and soldiers
watched as people suffered with an uncaring eye as Siochrú described:
“28,000 people crammed inside the city walls” while “the plague continued to
claim a large number of victims,” and finally, “the inhabitants of Limerick,
Waterford, and Galway had suffered terribly as a result of the conflict, with
plague, famine, and siege warfare claiming thousands of lives” (Siochrú 21) .
This
political upheaval and unrest of the Irish state goaded Jonathan Swift into
writing his satirical essay that would solve all of the issues in Ireland
caused by poverty and war. The consumption of babies would not only feed
starving families and hungry lords, but also clothed the poor and provide them
with an good that could be traded for funds. The essay symbolized the greedy
monarchs who sloughed aside the lives of the Irish harshly. Swift “comically” suggests that England invaded Ireland
and dismissed their culture, stating, “It is too well known, that we are forced
to obey some laws we never consented to” (529). He symbolizes the callous
attitude of British officials and their dehumanization of Irishmen, stating
that the poor women who begged needed an “easy method of making (their)
children sound and useful members of the commonwealth” by contributing “to the
feeding, and partly to the clothing of many thousands” (522-524). The images of
poverty in Swift’s proposal pull readers into the struggles of the mid-seventh
century Ireland.
Works Cited
Schmid,
Susan Valters, and John A. Wagner. Encyclopedia of Tudor England, Volume 1.
Santa Barbara: ABC-CLIO, Inc, 2011. Print.
Siochrú, Micheál. "Civil Autonomy and Military Power in
Early Modern Ireland” Journal of Early Modern History 15. (2011): 31-57.
Print.
Swift, Jonathan. A Modest Proposal. LePan, Jon, Ed. The Broadview Anthology of British Literature: The Restoration and
Eighteenth Century. Canada Book Publishing Fund, 2012. p. 522-528. Print.
Monday, November 25, 2013
England’s Push for Religious Uniformity During the 17th Century
After a tumultuous start to the 17th century characterized
by nationwide religious unrest, the Parliament of England called for uniformity
in hopes to stabilize the nation. Baptists, Congregationalists, Royalists, Independents,
Quakers, Calvinists, Protestants, Presbyterians, Anglicans, and Catholics were
religious subdivisions scattered throughout England. Needless to say,
uniformity was going to be a challenge. Would this undertaking prove to be
worth the effort? This religious multiplicity had developed in the 1640’s and 1650’s
and was believed to be the main cause of England’s religious and therefor
political instability. Each religious sect had their own practices. They
differed in religious opinions, customs, and rigidity. This was thought to
disturb the general peace of the kingdom, and for the English Parliament, the
diversity of religious ideals made their constituents harder to control. Logically,
it is easier to control a population of like-minded people as opposed to a
handful of independently thinking religious subclasses. It is through the hope
of uniformity that Parliament forced upon its diverse citizens penal acts of
religious censorship that affected and oppressed all branches of religion
besides that of the Anglican, Church of England. These acts were built up by Parliament
to establish and protect an Anglican/Royalist religious and governmental monopoly.
Religion and government were one in the same in 17th
century England. Government legislation directly affected religious happenings.
Their interconnectivity made parliamentary biased religious decisions
unavoidable, which was the intent. Under the reign of the recently restored Charles
II, a number of acts were installed between the years 1660 and 1688 that would
characterize the quarter century known as the “Era of Great Persecution”
(White, 95). The Test Acts purpose
were to strip citizens of their religious freedoms and force them to merge with
the traditions and customs of the Anglican Church. The first of these acts was
the Corporation act of 1661. This act was intended to ensure that all government
positions were held by members of the Anglican Church. The passing of this Corporation
Act received a royal assent to authorization rather than a drawn out fight
through the levels of a non-bias parliament. The Corporation Act stated that
all people of governmental importance such as mayors, town clerks, councilmen,
owners of corporations, or any person bearing office be required to “take the
oaths of Allegiance and Supremacy; then they must assert that they ‘do declare
and believe that it is not lawful under any pretense whatsoever to take arms
against the king” (White, 100), thus restricting public office to members of
the Church of England. The English government sought to control religion
through penal legislation in hopes of bringing peace and uniformity to England.
In addition to the ever-important Corporation act, there were
many other penal laws established to further refine Parliamentary/ Anglican/
Royalists power. These Test Acts further tested people’s religious affiliation and
loyalty in order to weed out religions sects such as Catholicism and
Presbyterianism. Another act that is relevant to our class reading was the 1662
Act of Uniformity. This act required that all ministers were to have received an
episcopal ordination, and also had to publically declare their “unfeigned accent
and consent” (White, 103) to all and everything taught in the Church of
England’s Book of Common Prayer. This
book was accepted by both houses of parliament, and contained all the workings
and teaching of the Anglican Church. Under this act, priest and ministers all
over England were doomed. They were forced to change. Expectedly this didn’t
sit well with many, and when there was non-cooperation, there was persecution,
uprising, and general unrest. This push for religious uniformity intended to
make life blissful for England and the Anglican Church, it is arguable whether this
intent was met and, as a side affect, religious progression in England was
greatly impeded.
It is argued by Clyde L. Grose under the American Society of
Church History, that restoration of an Established Church was a mistake. He
says that political restorations (Charles II) and required religious
institutions (Church of England) have almost never made long lasting positive
affects. Instead of England moving forward with individualistic thinking, the
nation put itself into a sort of religious coma, where no positive progress was
made until the established religion was repealed. England during the 17th
century had many bright minds (such as John Bunyan) who were progressing,
innovating, and positively challenging the religious norms of the day. The
majority of these bright minds were affiliated to religious sects other than
the Church of England. Once the established Church forcibly took over, these
bright minds lost their the right and ability to voice their innovative ideas
to the easily influenced public.
There is no competition in uniformity. Without competition,
people, ideas, and religions become stagnant. They idle instead of moving
forward. It is through competition that ideas are able to be built upon,
tested, and succeed. The Act of Corporation, the Act of Uniformity, and the
rest of the Test Acts all but doomed the competitive, individualistic thinkers
of 17th century England.
“A restoration is
supposed to be a return to normalcy, it is never genuinely that. It invariably
means a return to situation normal to a time past” (Grose, 3).
The restoration of Charles II and the establishment of a
uniform religion through the Test Acts impeded England’s religious and
governmental evolution in the 17th century.
(Easy to say in
hindsight!)
Works cited
Grose, Clyde.
“The Religion of Restoration England.” Church
History Volume. 6, No. 3 (1937):
223-232. Online database.
White, B. R..
“The English Baptists of the 17th Century.” Ed. Roger Hayden.
The Baptist Historical Society, 1996.
93-107. Print.
Monday, November 18, 2013
Oliver Cromwell: From Rags to Parliament
When he was born, Oliver Cromwell it was almost ridiculous to speculate that he would rise to
become a major part of the history of England. The Cromwells may have been considered the
most important family in Huntingdon, but Oliver Cromwell himself did not have the financial
status of the other important figures of his time (Ashley 27). The money that the family had came
from Cromwell’s great great grandfather, Morgan Williams; he operated a successful brewery
and sold beer on a large scale (Ashley 29). However, the family greatly decreased their fortune
through a series of poor money management. Henry Cromwell, wasted most of his fortune on
entertaining. Oliver Cromwell’s uncle, who possessed the same name followed in his shoes. He
acquired a great loss of wealth entertaining King James I at his own expense (Ashley 30). The
end result was him selling his home, the Palace of Hinchingbrooke and living in Ramsay, his
other home (Ashley 31). The family suffered an even further blow: When Cromwell’s father
passed, he was only eighteen, and had very little money to provide for his family. He sold
his land and had to become a farmer to support himself, his sisters and mother. He became
a landlord again by inheriting the land he farmed from Sir Thomas Steward, which brought
him to the salary he would live on (Ashley 33-34). Without the addition of his wife’s money,
Cromwell lived on a salary of 500 pounds annually (Ashley 37). Considering this situation,
it is obvious the prestige of his family name was the major factor that contributed to Oliver
Cromwell’s participation in politics; he had as many as twenty known relatives that in parliament
(Ashley 34). His family relations were the main reason Cromwell was still considered part of the
ruling class (Ashley 34).
Once in parliament, Cromwell’s religion was the main factor in most of his decisions. Oliver
Cromwell’s parents were Protestants who believed in predestination. As a child, Oliver
Cromwell attended the free school in Huntingdon, where scriptures were a major part of his
education (Ashley 45). As a Puritan, Cromwell had several issues with the English church.
His resentment of the English Church was not similar to his fellow Puritans, though. While
Cromwell did despise the ceremonies and idols, his anger was more directed towards the
bishops. When Cromwell read the Bible, he liked to interpret its meaning for himself. It was
his opinion that bishops were trying to make the people more inclined towards their pope.
Instead, he preferred to worship on his own and choose his own preacher (Ashley 51). He
and the other Protestants were determined to remodel the church, getting rid of idols and the
unnecessary ceremonies (Ashley 41-42). Cromwell argued passionately with the other members
of Parliament that a person’s piety was more important than the rituals required by the church
(Smith 59). It was his belief that God chose him to restore the balance between the church and
government by returning the church to its original, simplistic state (Ashley 56).
It was the impending threat of civil war that gave prominence to Oliver Cromwell as a military
figure. During the time before the civil war, he worked to give parliament control over the
military. He suggested that parliament and the House of Lords join forces to pass an ordinance
that gave Robert Devereux, a Puritan, the power to assemble an army to protect Trent until he
had further orders from Parliament (Ashley 80). While the members of the House of Lords were
falling into their chosen alliances, we get the first glimpse of Cromwell’s leadership abilities.
After the constitutional changes of the Remonstrance, the House of Commons was divided into
two sides: those who thought King Charles I punishment had gone far enough, and those who
did not (Ashley 81). Cromwell was one of the people who did not think that the king had been
punished enough. As the tensions rose, Cromwell and his allies gave the king an ultimatum: he
must surrender his executive authority and military power and abandon the Church of England
to the rule of the Puritans, or face the consequence (Ashley 88). These events would mark
the beginnings of the coming civil war, and lead Oliver Cromwell down the path that would
eventually make him ruler of England.
Works Cited
Ashley, Maurice. The Greatness of Oliver Cromwell. New York: Collier, 1966. Print.
Smith, David L. Oliver Cromwell: Politics and Religion in the English Revolution, 1640-1658.
Cambridge [England: Cambridge UP, 1991. Print.
Sunday, November 17, 2013
Eve, Gender, and Marriage
“Eve was a topic which
allowed, even demanded, interpretation both because of the dual emphasis on
transgression and promise to be found in the biblical accounts and because of
the wealth of both scholarly and popular commentary for and against her” (Wiseman
540). It is on such basis of dualism
that we are to evaluate Eve as a motif of feminine weakness while also looking
to her as the supreme mother of humankind.
Post-Reformation thought would definitely use Eve as the agent of the
fallen nature, and would not have been met with opposition due to the
inequality of male and female powers and voice (Wiseman 534). As a state that is shifting in religious
ideology from Catholicism to Protestantism, the context of faith would prove to
weigh heavily upon the mood and place of women within the contexts of community
and the individual relationship. Milton’s contemporaries, some women
themselves, can offer us an insight into the religious, communal and political
aspects that served as the social framework of Milton’s work; coincidentally,
we will also see how they became the prime movers of Milton’s seemingly
critical analysis of women’s generalized role.
One such manifestation of socialized power dynamics lay within the gender ratio of the clergy. Wiseman attributes the dissolution of the national church as the event which initially incited discussion of the appropriateness of women in religious office (536). The result was a literature war which casted Eve in many different lights: relative to authorship, Eve could stand for the race “crooked by nature” (qtd. in Wiseman 535) as depicted by Joseph Swetnam, or “the weaker vessel [that] might be thought particularly likely to carry God’s word” (Wiseman 538) according to the prophetess Anna Trapnel. Secondary to this upheaval of female roles, Milton’s syntax and plot placement of his heroine is criticized to depict Eve-as first and foremost a woman-as innately evil prior to the fall (Wiseman 451). The fault in this reasoning rests within the exclusivity of perfection in the Edenic state; is it then possible that Eve could exhibit traits of sin before fallen nature is even introduced? Wiseman offers an accepted compromise claiming that Adam and Eve are in fact innocent, yet subject to the limitations of language formulated after the fall (542). Still, there is an element of juxtaposing Eve alongside the idea of disobedience, especially in the explication of Eve’s encounter with pride while looking at her reflection (Milton 4:864). Wiseman answers this breech in Eve’s perfection with an argument made by Margaret Fell, another of Milton’s contemporaries (539). Fell quotes biblical passages that assert that “[God] will put enmity between [Satan] and the Woman, and between [Satan’s] seed and her seed; it shall bruise thy head, and thou shalt bruise his heel” (qtd. in Wiseman 539). Fell is making the argument that Eve’s justification is found in the Christ child being born out of her direct lineage (539). While Milton might not have taken the accounts of contemporary writers into consideration, it is important to be familiar with the fact that popular thought was changing in favor of a more ‘liberal’ view of women, and that this change was to be met with opposition under the guise of correction (540).
One such manifestation of socialized power dynamics lay within the gender ratio of the clergy. Wiseman attributes the dissolution of the national church as the event which initially incited discussion of the appropriateness of women in religious office (536). The result was a literature war which casted Eve in many different lights: relative to authorship, Eve could stand for the race “crooked by nature” (qtd. in Wiseman 535) as depicted by Joseph Swetnam, or “the weaker vessel [that] might be thought particularly likely to carry God’s word” (Wiseman 538) according to the prophetess Anna Trapnel. Secondary to this upheaval of female roles, Milton’s syntax and plot placement of his heroine is criticized to depict Eve-as first and foremost a woman-as innately evil prior to the fall (Wiseman 451). The fault in this reasoning rests within the exclusivity of perfection in the Edenic state; is it then possible that Eve could exhibit traits of sin before fallen nature is even introduced? Wiseman offers an accepted compromise claiming that Adam and Eve are in fact innocent, yet subject to the limitations of language formulated after the fall (542). Still, there is an element of juxtaposing Eve alongside the idea of disobedience, especially in the explication of Eve’s encounter with pride while looking at her reflection (Milton 4:864). Wiseman answers this breech in Eve’s perfection with an argument made by Margaret Fell, another of Milton’s contemporaries (539). Fell quotes biblical passages that assert that “[God] will put enmity between [Satan] and the Woman, and between [Satan’s] seed and her seed; it shall bruise thy head, and thou shalt bruise his heel” (qtd. in Wiseman 539). Fell is making the argument that Eve’s justification is found in the Christ child being born out of her direct lineage (539). While Milton might not have taken the accounts of contemporary writers into consideration, it is important to be familiar with the fact that popular thought was changing in favor of a more ‘liberal’ view of women, and that this change was to be met with opposition under the guise of correction (540).
Milton’s Paradise
Lost, while gently conceding that Eve is equivalent in spirituality to her
husband Adam, it remains firm in the assertion of the hierarchy of being. Milton does so through the language, mood and
symbolization of Adam’s marriage to Eve, which uses the classical “model of
male friendship” (Suzuki 387). In this
ideal, Suzuki elaborates that “two autonomous souls equal in status were seen
to unite to become one soul in two bodies” (387). Claims like this may seem unfounded when
scrutiny of Milton’s Eve as compared to Adam produces the conclusion that:
…Though both
Not equal, as
their sex not equal seemed;
For contemplation
he and valour formed;
For softness she
and sweet attractive grace;
He for God only,
she for God in him:
His fair large
front and eye sublime declared
Absolute rule…(Book
4, 295-301)
Suzuki points out that
while Milton reflects an autonomous and equal version of Eve within the
matrimonial relationship to Adam, “the wife obeys by her own rational choice
rather than from a sense that she is a creature innately subordinate to her
husband. Her behavior and words are not
to exhibit a critical judgment that does not match that of her husband, who is
rationally and expediently obeying God” (388).
Milton is thus the first to attribute this depth of relationship to Adam
and Eve, yet he does so while paradoxically reaffirming that Eve must subject
herself to Adam’s rule since he is her sole link in communication with God.
Works
Cited
Suzuki,
Shiego. “Marriage and divorce”. Milton
in Context. Ed. Stephen Dobranski. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, 2010.
382-391. Print.
Wiseman, Susan. “Eve, Paradise
Lost, and Female Interpretation”. The Oxford Handbook of Milton. Ed. Nicholas McDowell and Nigel
Smith. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2009. 534-546.
Print.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


